My 6 Year Old Can’t Recall Schoolwork or Talk About His Day: What I’ve Learned So Far
I’m leaning against the back of our minivan after school pickup, a crumb-covered granola bar in one hand, when my son Jax drags his dinosaur-covered backpack over to me. I ask the same question I ask every single day: “How was school today?” He shoves a loose rock into the pocket of his sweatpants, shrugs, and says “Fine.” That’s it. I push for more: “What did you do? What did you learn?” He blinks at me like I just asked him to recite the periodic table. “I don’t remember.”
That night, it happens again with homework. The weekly newsletter said they learned three new sight words, and the assignment is to write each one three times. Jax stares at the blank paper, pencil hovering, and says “We didn’t learn any sight words.” I bite my tongue, because the first ten times this happened I got frustrated, asked him why he wasn’t paying attention. Now I just sit down next to him. That’s when I posted in my local parenting group, asking if anyone else had a 6 year old like this. The comment thread blew up, dozens of parents saying their kid did the exact same thing.
I spent the first two months of kindergarten spiraling a little. I was convinced he was zoning out all day, that there was something wrong with his memory, that he was falling behind before he even really started. I talked to his teacher at parent-teacher conferences, and that’s when things started to click for me. She said she sees this at least three or four times a year with kids his age. It’s not that they aren’t paying attention. It’s that 6 year olds’ brains are processing 10 times more new information in a day than we are as adults. By 3 p.m., their working memory is full. All the new details get tucked away into storage before they can even think about pulling them back out, and asking them to recall it on demand right after school is like asking you to list every email you answered at work by 5 p.m. Most of us couldn’t do that either.
That first little shift in perspective changed everything. I stopped assuming he wasn’t paying attention, and started testing small tricks to help him pull those memories out, instead of making him dig for them blind.
The first trick I tried was ditching the big open-ended questions. “How was school” is way too broad for a kid whose brain can only hold so much. Instead, I started asking tiny, specific questions that only need a yes or no answer to get him started. Instead of “what did you do at recess?” I ask “Did anyone chase anyone at recess today?” Nine times out of ten, he’ll say yes, and then launch into a whole story about Tyler chasing Mia and how Tyler fell in the mulch and lost his shoe. Instead of “what did you learn today?” I ask “Did you sing any new songs in circle time?” Cues work way better than open requests for recall, because they give his brain a place to start looking for the memory.
For schoolwork recall, the same idea applies. I used to sit there and ask him to tell me what he learned, what the assignment was, what the words were. Now I pull out his take-home folder and flip through it first, to find small cues. If he can’t remember the sight words, I point to a smudged “b” on the bottom of his art project from that day and say “Your teacher wrote this on your paper after you finished, does that remind you what one of the words was?” Half the time, it pops right out. I also changed our homework schedule, which made a bigger difference than I thought it would. I used to make him do homework right when we got home, because I thought if we waited he’d forget everything. Turns out, he was already so drained that he couldn’t pull any memories up anyway. Now we stop at the park for 20 minutes first, or he builds Lego at the kitchen table while I make dinner, and we do homework after he’s had time to reset. His recall is way better when his brain isn’t full to bursting with all the day’s input.
I did check in with our pediatrician, just to rule out anything bigger, which I tell other parents to do if they’re worried. She said that as long as he can remember routines he does every day (like where his shoes go, what we do before bed) and can follow 2-3 step directions, this is just normal developmental growth. Some kids’ working memory develops a little slower than others at this age, and it almost always catches up on its own.
It’s not like this is fixed now, or that every day goes smoothly. Some days, we get home and he still can’t tell me a single thing that happened, even when I ask ten specific questions. Some nights, we sit at the table for 20 minutes and he still can’t recall the math problem they practiced that morning, and I end up emailing his teacher to confirm the assignment. But it’s gotten easier, for both of us. I don’t get frustrated anymore, because I know it’s not that he’s not trying. It’s just that his brain is still growing the muscle it needs to pull those memories out right when you ask for them.
Last weekend, we were driving to get ice cream, and he randomly started telling me about the time his class watched a video about butterflies two weeks prior. He told me every detail, from the caterpillar eating the leaf to the butterfly flying out of the chrysalis. I just nodded along, because I know those memories are in there. They just don’t come out when I ask for them. They come out when they’re ready.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My 6 Year Old Can’t Recall Schoolwork or Talk About His Day: What I’ve Learned So Far