How Long Should You Let Your Kids Ramble? Practical Tips for Parents and Teachers
7:42 a.m., I’m leaning against the minivan, scrolling through an email from the elementary school about my sub assignment for the day, when my 7-year-old slings his dinosaur backpack over one shoulder and stops dead by the open door. “Mom. Mom. You know that rock I found on the playground yesterday? The one with the stripe?”
Before I can answer, he’s off. It’s not just a rock—he thinks it’s a piece of a T-Rex tooth, because the science guy at the library said T-Rex teeth are that exact gray color. Then the playground got new wood chips last week, and the guy who dropped off the wood chips had a truck with a dog in the back, and the dog was brown and looked just like the one my cousin got for Christmas, and my cousin’s dog ate a whole bar of soap last month and had to go to the vet… I feel my shoulders tighten. I’m already running 3 minutes behind, if I hit traffic I’ll miss the pre-class briefing, and I’m this close to saying “Not now, bud, we have to go.”
I didn’t say that, though. Not after what happened the week before, when I was subbing first grade. We were lining up for recess, already 1 minute behind schedule per the regular teacher’s lesson plan, when Lila raised her hand halfway down the line. She said she needed a hall pass, and before I could hand it over, she started talking: her guinea pig got out of the cage last night, they found him behind the towels in the dryer, he ate half of her mom’s birthday cookie, they reburied the half he didn’t eat in the backyard, her brother said the guinea pig is too fat to fit in his tunnel now… The teacher’s note in the sub folder explicitly said “keep transitions tight, we’re already a day behind on reading groups.” I almost cut her off mid-sentence. Instead, I leaned against the doorframe, counted to 10, and waited. Two and a half minutes later, she stopped, smiled, and said “Okay, I just needed to tell someone that. Also I have to pee.” We walked to the bathroom, we only got to recess 2 minutes late, no one cared, no one got in trouble. That small interaction stuck with me.
I started noticing how often we cut kids off mid-ramble, me included. We’re busy, we have places to be, lessons to teach, dishes to put away, dinner to get on the table. Rambling looks like a waste of time to adults: it’s disconnected, it goes nowhere, it takes longer than we have. But what I’ve seen, both at home and in the classroom, is that rambling is how kids learn to tell stories. Their brains don’t automatically sort the important bits from the boring, tangential bits. That’s a skill you learn by practicing—by getting all the messy connections out on the table, and figuring out how to string them together for someone else. If you cut them off every time before they finish their train of thought, they don’t get that practice. I’ve had second graders who can’t explain why they’re upset, or what they need help with on a math worksheet, because they’ve never had the space to practice talking through all the extra bits to get to the point.
I don’t let kids ramble for 15 minutes every time we’re walking out the door, that’s not realistic. I’ve got a job, I’ve got deadlines, and a household to run, that kind of open-ended chatting doesn’t work every minute of the day. But I’ve started using three small, low-effort habits that work for me both at home and in the classroom.
First, if I’m rushed, I name the time upfront. I pull out my phone, set a visible timer for 3 minutes, and say “You’ve got 3 minutes to tell me all of this, and I’ll listen the whole time. Then we have to go, and we can talk more at dinner.” That way, I don’t get impatient checking the clock every 10 seconds, he knows what to expect, and he still gets to tell his story. That morning in the minivan, that’s what I did, and he fit the whole rock, dog, soap-eating story into 2 minutes 47 seconds. We only ended up being 2 minutes late to school, I still made my pre-class briefing, no harm done.
Second, when I do have downtime—after dinner, on a weekend walk, waiting in line for ice cream—I don’t interrupt to make them “get to the point.” I just nod, and maybe throw in a “what happened next?” if there’s a lull. No redirecting, no pushing for a conclusion. They get to practice following their own train of thought, and I learn all kinds of small things about their day I would have missed otherwise.
Third, when I’m subbing and a kid starts rambling in the middle of a lesson, I keep a small spiral notebook by my desk. I ask them to tell me their story, or let me write down the first line, and we share it with the class during the 5 minutes of free time we have after lunch. That way, the lesson doesn’t get derailed, but the kid doesn’t feel like their story doesn’t matter.
I still mess up. Some days I’m exhausted, or running so late that I just say “we can talk about this later” and yank the car door closed. Last month I cut off a fourth grader mid-story about his cat’s new kittens because we had to wrap up the state practice test, and I still feel a little twinge about it. It’s not about being perfect, and there’s no set number of minutes that’s always right. Some days it’s 30 seconds, some days it’s 10. It just depends on what’s going on. But I’ve started pausing that one second before I cut in, and asking if I can spare just a minute. Most of the time, that minute isn’t going to break my schedule. But that minute is where kids learn how to talk, how to share what matters to them, and how to turn all the messy bits of their day into a story someone else wants to hear.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How Long Should You Let Your Kids Ramble