Why Is My 11-Year-Old Girl Withdrawn and Quiet? What I’ve Learned Worrying About My Cousin
Last weekend, we squeezed into my aunt’s backyard for our annual summer barbecue, the one where the grill smokes too much and everyone brings too much potato salad. I was ducking around the side of the house to grab an extra bag of ice from the cooler when I spotted Lila, my 11-year-old cousin, leaning against the siding with her phone held two inches from her face. All the other kids her age—three cousins from out of town and two family friends her mom invited—were screaming and splashing in the faded blue pool, passing around a waterproof speaker blasting whatever pop song is popular this month. I nudged her foot with mine and asked if she wanted to head over with me. She didn’t look up from her TikTok scroll, just shrugged and said, “They’re having more fun without me there.”
That’s the line that made my worry shift from a quiet background hum to something I couldn’t ignore. I work as a paraeducator at a local elementary school, so I see quiet, withdrawn kids every day. But it’s different when it’s someone you’ve watched grow up, the kid who used to drag me into her bedroom every Christmas to show me the new comic strips she’d drawn.
A few weeks before the barbecue, I picked her up from school because my aunt had a late work meeting. She hauled her overstuffed backpack into the backseat, and when she dropped her lunch box, it popped open. Half a peanut butter sandwich, an unopened honeycrisp apple, both still cold. I asked if the cafeteria line was too long that day. She stared at her scuffed sneakers and said she ate a granola bar in the library instead. The cafeteria’s too loud, and all the tables are already split up into groups, and no one saves her a spot. My aunt told me later that Lila comes straight home from school, locks her bedroom door, and stays on her phone until dinner. She won’t talk about school, she won’t let my aunt look at her sketchbook anymore, and she turns down every invitation to birthday parties or sleepovers.
Most of the family has shrugged it off. She’s just shy, they say. Preteens all live on their phones now. That’s just what middle school is like. And yeah, middle school is terrible for almost everyone, but that doesn’t mean we have to leave kids to muddle through it alone. The biggest mistake I see adults make with kids like Lila is jumping straight to fixing the problem before they’ve built any trust. My aunt’s first instinct was to email the principal, then sign Lila up for the school’s after-school art club to “meet people who like the same things.” That would’ve worked for some kids, but for Lila, who’s already self-conscious about her art and being new to middle school, it would’ve just felt like being thrown into the deep end when she can barely doggy paddle.
I suggested we try smaller things first, and the first thing I did was take her out for art supplies and ice cream, just us. I didn’t start the drive with “okay, talk to me about what’s wrong at school.” We just walked up and down the aisles of the art store, and I pointed out how expensive good markers are now, and complained about how I still can’t get the hang of watercolor blending. When I bought her that 48-color set she kept picking up and putting back, I mentioned on the way to get ice cream that when I was her age, my best friend since kindergarten dumped me for the cheerleading squad too, and I ate lunch in the bathroom for three months because I didn’t want anyone to see I ate alone. I didn’t make it a big speech. I just said it, like it was a normal thing I remembered.
That’s the trick I’ve learned working with kids: if you open with a tiny, unremarkable vulnerable bit of your own, they don’t feel like they’re being interrogated. Ten minutes later, over mint chocolate chip, she told me what was really going on. Her old best friend did dump her for the popular group, and the new girls in that group call her sketchbook cringey when she brings it out. She didn’t tell her mom because her mom keeps saying “just stand up for yourself” and “just go make new friends” like it’s as easy as grabbing a new carton of milk at the grocery store.
We came up with small, low-friction changes after that. Instead of forcing her to join the school art club, I offered to host a casual art night at my place every other Friday. She doesn’t have to invite anyone if she doesn’t want to. It’s just us, drawing, and eating microwave popcorn, and whatever bad show we want to put on. If she ever does meet someone she wants to bring, that’s fine too. I also told her mom to stop asking her “how was school?” every day when she walks in the door—that question always gets a “fine” and nothing else. Instead, I told her to ask one specific thing: “Did anything weird happen at lunch today?” or “Did you draw anything cool after class?” That’s way easier for a kid to answer than a big open-ended question that feels like a test.
Last week, Lila came over for art night, and she slid a printed copy of a webcomic she posted across the table to me. A girl from another school in the district had commented on it, and they’ve been chatting back and forth about character designs every night. She didn’t want anyone else in the family to know yet, because she didn’t want them to make a big deal out of it before anything even comes of it. I didn’t make a big deal out of it. I just told her the main character’s cape design was really cool, and asked when I could read the next page.
I’m still worried. I don’t know if this year will get easier for her, or if she’ll spend the whole year eating lunch in the library feeling lonely. No one can promise that everything will work out neatly. But I know that right now, she has a space where she doesn’t have to be anything other than exactly what she is. She doesn’t have to make friends, she doesn’t have to be outgoing, she doesn’t have to fix herself for anyone. That’s enough for right now. A lot of adults rush to fix every hard thing a kid goes through, but sometimes the best thing you can do is just wait, and keep the door open, and let them come to you when they’re ready.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Is My 11-Year-Old Girl Withdrawn and Quiet