Why Is My English Teacher So Mean For No Reason? What Parents And Kids Should Know
The car door slammed so hard the rearview mirror vibrated. My 10th grader, Lila, threw her canvas backpack on the floorboard, crossed her arms, and stared out the side window at the line of parents picking up kids. “Ms. Henderson is the meanest teacher I’ve ever had,” she said. “And she was totally rude for no reason.”
I waited until we pulled out of the parking lot before I asked what happened. She wouldn’t talk at first, so I detoured to the gas station for her favorite mint chocolate chip cone, extra sprinkles. By the time we pulled into our driveway, she was spilling: She’d stayed up until 11 finishing her poetry portfolio, her 7-year-old brother spilled apple juice on the first page an hour before school, so she’d stuffed the crumpled copy in her bag and planned to ask Ms. Henderson if she could print a new one after class. By third period, she could feel a migraine throbbing behind her eyes, so she raised her hand to ask for a pass to get water and a Tylenol from the nurse. Ms. Henderson looked up from the whiteboard, pointed at the crumbs from her breakfast muffin on her worksheet, and said loud enough for the whole class to hear, “If you cared enough about this class to show up prepared, you wouldn’t need to leave every five minutes. Sit down.”
I nodded, because I’ve been that teacher. I taught 11th grade English for three years right out of college, before I quit to stay home with my kids when Lila was little. I remember the exact day I snapped at a kid for no reason that he could see. It was October, I’d stayed up until 1 a.m. reworking my lesson on To Kill a Mockingbird because the school’s Wi-Fi had gone out and I lost all my slides, my golden retriever had eaten a whole chocolate bar the night before and I’d spent three hours at the emergency vet that morning, I hadn’t had time to grab lunch, and I was already 20 essays behind on grading. A quiet kid named Marcus pulled out a granola bar during silent reading, and I snapped at him in front of the whole room: “We don’t eat in this class. Can’t you follow one simple rule?” He just stared at me, put the granola bar away, and didn’t say a word the rest of the period. I wanted to apologize after class, but I had to run to a mandatory staff meeting about test scores, and by the end of the day I forgot.
A week later, I had my parent-teacher conference with Ms. Henderson, and I got there 10 minutes early. I found her at her desk, a stack of poetry portfolios reaching almost to her chin, eating a cold oat granola bar that had been sitting out since morning. A sticky note on her computer screen reminded her to pick up her 8-year-old with asthma from soccer practice at 3, and another said “turn in progress reports by end of day.” She was rubbing her temples when I walked in, and she apologized for the incident with Lila before I even sat down. That same morning, before third period, a student had stayed after to tell her he was sleeping in his dad’s pickup truck because his mom kicked him out, and she’d spent 15 minutes on hold with the overloaded school social worker trying to get him a spot in the district’s emergency housing. Two kids had already left class for bathroom breaks in the first 10 minutes, and she was already frayed thin. She didn’t see the migraine, didn’t see the crumpled portfolio, just saw another disruption and snapped.
That’s the thing no one tells you when you’re sitting in the backseat angry, or standing in the parking lot listening to your kid yell: almost all the time, that “no reason” meanness from an English teacher has a reason, it’s just hidden. English classes carry a different weight than other subjects. It’s not just memorizing formulas or diagramming sentences – kids share personal stories in their writing, they come to English teachers when they’re upset about something at home because English teachers are used to talking about feelings, and they’re usually the first person a kid will talk to when something goes wrong. Most English teachers are also carrying extra duties on top of teaching: they’re the yearbook advisor, the debate coach, the one who organizes the school talent show, because administration always dumps those extra jobs on the department that’s used to doing extra work. And grading writing? It’s not like grading multiple choice, where you can bubble in a score in 10 seconds. Grading one essay can take 10 or 15 minutes, and if you have 120 students, that’s 30 hours of grading a week on top of lesson plans and meetings.
After the conference, I talked to Lila about what Ms. Henderson had going on that day, and Lila decided to stop by her class after school the next day to tell her about the migraine and the juice on the portfolio. Ms. Henderson let her reprint the portfolio, and wrote a note on her poem about her great grandma that said “this made me cry, thank you for sharing it.” It wasn’t a big, heartwarming fix – Lila still complains that Ms. Henderson takes off points for wrong margins and talks too fast when she’s in a hurry. Ms. Henderson still has days where she snaps at someone for no reason they can see.
What I tell other parents when they ask me about this is simple: don’t jump straight to complaining to the principal before you get context. If your kid comes home upset, first just walk through the day with them step by step, to see if you can spot what the teacher might have been dealing with. If you need to reach out, send a short note that says “My kid came home upset after class today, they had a migraine this morning and wanted me to share that context with you” instead of an angry email calling the teacher rude. If your kid is comfortable, encourage them to pop by after class to share what was going on – nine times out of 10, the teacher had no idea they were having a bad day, and will apologize.
Last week, Lila came home upset again because Ms. Henderson wouldn’t let her turn in an essay a day late for partial credit. I got her an extra chocolate chip cookie after dinner, listened to her complain, and didn’t call the teacher. Some days, everyone is tired, and everyone is stretched thin, and things don’t go the way anyone wants. The meanness that feels like it comes out of nowhere almost always has a source – it’s just not the kid standing in front of the teacher that day.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Is My English Teacher So Mean For No Reason