How to Get Your Infant to Keep Her Pacifier in Her Mouth: Parent Tested Low Effort Tips
2:17 a.m., according to the glowing green clock on Lila’s nursery wall. I’m leaning against the doorframe, one hand on the light switch, and I watch the pacifier tumble out of her mouth, hit the fitted sheet, and roll under the crib before she even has time to register that it’s gone. Ten seconds later, the little whimper starts, building into that full-on cry that means my 10 minutes of quiet after rocking her is over. My socks are mismatched—one thick wool, one thin cotton I grabbed off the laundry pile—and there’s a cold spot from the half mug of tea I spilled on my sweatpants on the way up. I’ve done this six times in the last two hours. By the third time, I was convinced I was doing something wrong. By the fifth, I was googling “why won’t my baby keep her pacifier in” while rocking her, one eye closed.
My first son never gave me this problem. He took to a pacifier from his first night home, held it in without any help, and I walked around thinking I had this whole baby thing figured out. So when Lila came along and spit every pacifier out within 30 seconds, I was thrown. I tried three different brands, cherry-shaped nipples, orthodontic nipples, pacifiers printed with little dinosaurs and flowers. I bought that expensive fabric pacifier holder that wraps around the back of the head, but she kept pulling it down and tangling it in her swaddle. I was this close to giving up on pacifiers entirely, which meant giving up on any hope of naps longer than 20 minutes or more than three hours of consecutive sleep at night.
I brought it up at her 4-month checkup, as I held her on the scale waiting for the nurse to get her weight. Half expected the pediatrician to tell me Lila just didn’t want a pacifier, or that I should let her cry it out, or that pacifiers are bad for her teeth anyway. Instead, she leaned against the exam table, wiped a smudge of baby food off her coat, and asked two simple questions I’d never seen anywhere in my google searches: What size pacifier are you using, and when do you put it in?
I told her I used the 0-6 month size, just like the box says. She laughed and said size labels are just marketing suggestions, every baby’s mouth is a different size. Lila was in the 10th percentile for head circumference, so the average 0-6 month nipple was too long for her small mouth. She couldn’t close her jaw all the way around the base, so as soon as she relaxed enough to doze off, the pacifier just slipped right out. When I told her I popped it in the second she started crying, she nodded and said that’s the second mistake. When babies are mid-cry, they’re gasping for air, their mouth is too wide open to get a good seal. You’ve got to calm them just enough to slow their breathing before you put it in.
She threw out a few other small, random tips that I’d never thought of: warm the nipple a little under warm tap water before you put it in, because cold hard rubber feels weird in their mouth and they spit it out before they even start sucking. After you put it in, hold a light steady pressure on the top of the pacifier with your finger for 10 to 15 seconds, until they get three or four good deep sucks in. Most people pop it in and pull their hand away immediately, so the first suck pushes it out instead of pulling it in.
I went home that afternoon and dug out the pack of newborn-sized pacifiers I’d stuffed in the back of the diaper bag after the first month, convinced she’d outgrown them. I ran the nipple under warm tap water for 10 seconds, patted it dry, then soothed Lila until her crying slowed to little huffs. I popped it in, held my index finger lightly on the top, counted to 15, then pulled my hand away. I stood by the crib, waiting for it to fall out like it always did. A minute went by. Then five. It stayed. I leaned against the wall and actually breathed deep for the first time in weeks.
I’ve tweaked a few more things since then that made a big difference. The pacifier clip I used to keep it from getting lost? I was clipping it so tight to her onesie that any time she turned her head, it pulled the pacifier right out. Now I leave two or three inches of slack, so it can move with her instead of yanking it out. I also got rid of all the pacifiers with big, thick plastic shields. The shield pushed against her chin when she laid back to sleep, and that small pressure was enough to knock the pacifier out. Thin, low-profile shields work way better for her small face.
It’s not perfect, obviously. If she’s really overtired or working through a bad gassy spell, she’ll still spit it out over and over. Some nights I still end up replacing it four or five times before she falls into deep sleep. Two weeks ago, she figured out how to spit it out on purpose just to get me to come pick it up, which is a whole new messy game I haven’t figured out yet. But it’s a thousand times better than it was two months ago, when I was ready to throw all pacifiers in the trash and just resign myself to no sleep for the next year.
I ran into another mom at library story time last week, and she was complaining about the exact same problem with her 10-week-old. She’d spent over $40 on different pacifier brands, and none of them stayed in more than a minute. I told her the little tricks the pediatrician told me, and she texted me the next morning saying she’d dug out her old newborn pacifiers, tried the 15 second finger hold, and it stayed in for an hour-long nap for the first time ever. It’s the kind of small win that makes you want to cry when you’re a tired new parent.
A lot of the advice you see online makes it sound like if your baby won’t keep a pacifier in, you’re either doing something wrong or your baby just doesn’t need one. But most of the time, it’s just tiny, obvious adjustments that no one thinks to tell you. You don’t need fancy products or a complicated sleep routine. You just have to stop following the size labels on the box and meet your baby where she is.
Right now, Lila’s napping in her crib down the hall, and her pacifier’s still in her mouth 45 minutes in. I’m drinking a fresh mug of tea, no spills this time, and I’ve got 20 minutes to fold the pile of onesies on the couch before she wakes up. It’s not perfect, but it’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Get Your Infant to Keep Her Pacifier in Her Mouth: Parent Tested Low Effort Tips