Which Math Pathway Is Best For My Kid? A Middle School Math Teacher Explains
The hum of the school’s fluorescent lights gets louder by 7pm on conference nights, and last month I was picking at a crumbly granola bar wrapper when Mia’s mom sat down, pulled out a folded sheet of notebook paper, and asked the question I get at least 10 times a semester: Which math pathway is the best one for my kid?
The sheet had notes scrawled on it from her sister, a high school counselor, about how accelerated algebra in 7th grade looks better on college apps, how falling behind now means closing doors to STEM majors later. Mia was slouched in the chair next to her, picking at a loose thread on her hoodie, and when I asked her how math was going this quarter, she mumbled that it takes her two hours to do homework every night, and she never has time to walk her dog after school.
I’ve been teaching 7th grade math for 12 years, and I’ve watched hundreds of families navigate this choice. Two years ago, Javi’s parents insisted he test into accelerated even after I told them his scores were right on the cut line, and that he’d mentioned he preferred working through problems slowly. He kept up, got a B- every quarter, but he quit the after-school math competition club he’d joined in 6th grade—said he didn’t have time to practice, and anyway, he was “too bad at math to have fun with it.” After first semester of 8th grade, his parents let him switch to the on-level pathway, and by the end of the year he was bringing me Sudoku puzzles he’d solved on the bus to school every Monday. He got an A in both semesters, and last I heard he’s signed up for AP Calculus his senior year, same as most of the kids who accelerated early.
Lila was another kid I remember clearly. She scored high enough on the placement test to accelerate easily, but she told me she didn’t want to give up her summer to take the required prerequisite class. She wanted to go to horse camp, something she’d done every year since she was 8. Her parents were nervous she’d fall behind, but they let her stay on-level. This year, as a junior, she’s taking AP Statistics, she has an A, and she’s using what she’s learning to analyze water quality data for a 4-H project she’s doing. She told me last month she’s planning to major in environmental science, and she doesn’t feel like she’s missed a single step.
The first thing I tell parents is that there’s no universal “best” pathway, but there are three concrete questions you can ask that will point you in the right direction, way better than any test score or college admissions rumor. First, ask your kid how much time they spend on math homework right now, unprompted. If they’re already spending two hours a night on on-level work, and they’re stressed every time they sit down to do it, accelerating isn’t going to make that better—it’s going to double the work and the stress. If they finish their homework in 20 minutes and complain that they’re bored, that’s a good sign accelerated will fit. Second, ask them if they ever play with math for fun. That doesn’t mean they have to love solving equations for fun, it just means do they ever calculate the tip at a restaurant without being asked, or figure out how much paint they need for their bedroom project, or do logic puzzles in their free time? If that answer is yes, they’ll handle the faster pace. If the answer is no, that doesn’t mean they’re bad at math—it just means they don’t need to rush. Third, call your kid’s high school guidance office and ask what flexibility you have. Most high schools don’t lock you into a pathway forever. If you start on-level and want to accelerate later, or start accelerated and want to switch back, you can usually do that after a semester without falling behind. Most also offer summer classes that let you catch up if you change your mind later, so you don’t have to make a permanent choice when your kid is 12.
I also tell parents that the idea that accelerated middle school math is required for top colleges is almost always wrong. Unless your kid is already 100% set on getting a PhD in pure math or an engineering degree from a top 10 program, most colleges don’t care when you took algebra. They care that you took the hardest classes you could handle successfully, and that you finished the required prerequisites for your major by the time you graduate. A B in accelerated doesn’t look better than an A in on-level, and it definitely doesn’t look better than an A in on-level followed by an A in AP math a year later.
After we talked for 20 minutes, Mia and her mom decided to start her 7th grade year on the on-level pathway, with a plan to check in after first semester. If Mia is bored and finishing all her work quickly, she can switch to accelerated for the second half of the year. If not, she stays on track, and can still take AP math by senior year.
Last week, her mom emailed me an update: Mia hasn’t cried over homework since the first week of school, she joined the art club she wanted to do after school, and she just turned in an extra credit project where she calculated how much it would cost their family to adopt a second rescue dog, complete with three hand-drawn graphs of monthly expenses. We still don’t know what pathway Mia will take for high school, and that’s okay. The best pathway isn’t the one that looks most impressive on paper. It’s the one that lets your kid learn math without hating it, right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Which Math Pathway Is Best For My Kid