What I Wish Every Student Knew: A Teacher’s Guide for Parents and Caregivers
The overhead fluorescent lights in my classroom were already half shut off last Tuesday, and the janitor had just mopped the hallway outside, leaving the whole area smelling like lemon floor wax. I was halfway through stacking grading folders and shoving a half-eaten peanut butter granola bar back into my lunch bag when there was a soft knock on the door. It was Mia, one of my quiet 7th graders, holding her science fair project folded under her arm, the edge of the poster board crumpled where she’d been squeezing it. Her eyes were puffy like she’d been crying in the bathroom.
“I got a B minus,” she said, before I even asked what was wrong. “Is that going to go on my high school transcript? I won’t get into a good college now, will I?”
I pulled out the extra chair by my desk and told her to sit down. This isn’t the first time this conversation has happened in that chair, and it won’t be the last. Just last week, Javi, an 8th grader I had last year, stopped by to tell me he’d skipped turning in his entire history essay the month before because he couldn’t get the introduction right. He said it wasn’t good enough, so a zero was better than turning in something messy.
I reached into the bottom drawer of my desk, where I keep a folded copy of my own high school transcript, and handed it to her. She ran her finger down the lines, and her eyebrows went up. “You got a C in 9th grade biology? And a D first semester of geometry?”
“Yep,” I said. “I studied for hours for that geometry test and still couldn’t get proofs right. I cried in the bathroom after that final too, just like you did today.”
She laughed, a quiet shaky thing, and leaned back in the chair. That’s when it hit me, like it does every time: most students don’t actually get to see the messy parts of the people who are telling them what to do. Parents post the highlight reels on Facebook, teachers show them the polished final versions of assignments, all the other kids at school post about their straight As and their sports awards on Instagram. No one talks about the Ds, the half-done essays, the lines you mess up in rehearsal that no one but you remembers.
Over 12 years of teaching middle and high school, I’ve seen this pattern play out over and over. Kids as young as 10 carry this quiet weight that every small misstep is permanent. That one bad grade will ruin their college chances, one awkward joke will make everyone hate them forever, one wrong choice of extracurricular will mean they never figure out what they want to do. Parents and teachers don’t usually mean to feed this, but we do it anyway when we say things like “this grade matters for your future” without adding the end of that sentence: “but it doesn’t matter more than you do.”
The good news is this is an easy thing to shift, with really small, low-effort changes that don’t require big family meetings or extra appointments. The first thing I tell parents at conferences is to start sharing one tiny, boring failure of yours at dinner every week. It doesn’t have to be a big, traumatic mistake. Just something small: “I forgot to bring the snacks for my work meeting today and had to run to the gas station last minute” or “I messed up the hem on those pants I was mending and now I have to start over.” When kids see the adults in their life messing up small things all the time and still being okay, it takes the pressure off their own small messes. It’s way more effective than just saying “it’s okay to mess up” because you’re showing them, not just telling them.
Another specific thing I suggest: when your kid brings home a bad grade or says they didn’t turn in an assignment, don’t jump straight to fixing it. First ask, “What do you think is the worst that could happen here?” Nine times out of 10, their answer is way more dramatic than the actual outcome. When Javi said his worst case was getting a zero and failing the class, we walked through it together: he could turn it in late for half credit, he could do extra credit to bring his grade up, even if he failed that one essay he’d still pass the class. Once he said it out loud, he realized it wasn’t the end of the world. He turned it in the next day, got a C minus, and that was that.
For teachers, one small shift I’ve made is changing how I mark up assignments. Instead of writing “needs improvement” at the top, I first write one specific thing that worked, then one small thing to try next time. That separates the quality of the work from the worth of the student, and it cuts down on the kids who crumple up their paper and throw it away before they even read the whole comment.
Mia left my classroom that Tuesday, and said she’d go home and tell her mom about the B minus. The next day she stopped by again and said her mom didn’t care about the grade at all—she’d just been worried Mia had been hiding how stressed she was. Mia said she hadn’t realized she didn’t have to get every question right to be okay. Last week I saw her in the hallway carrying a script for the school play; she got a minor part, and said she messed up three lines at rehearsal but no one even noticed, and she’s having fun anyway.
I still keep that old transcript in my desk drawer. Some kids don’t want to see it, some do. Some weeks I forget to share my own small mistakes at the dinner table with my own kid, and some days I still get stressed when I mess up a lesson plan in front of the whole class. This doesn’t fix all the pressure kids are under right now, and there are still days where I leave school feeling like I didn’t say the right thing to the kid knocking on my door. But I keep the transcript there anyway, because every once in a while, it helps one kid stop carrying a weight that was never supposed to be theirs in the first place.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Wish Every Student Knew: A Teacher’s Guide for Parents and Caregivers