My Child Is Hated By Their Classmates: How to Help Them Cope
I was leaning against my car in the middle of an October drizzle, waiting for my 10-year-old Lila to get out of 5th grade, when I saw her walking toward me with her hood pulled so far over her face I could barely see her scuffed rain boots. She climbed into the backseat, dropped her backpack on the floor, and didn’t reach for the aux cord like she always does—the one she uses to blast her favorite Taylor Swift album before we even pull out of the parking lot. She just stared out the window at the other kids yelling by the bus stop.
When I asked if everything was okay, she said it so quiet I almost missed it: “All my classmates hate me.”
My chest tightened, and my first thought was exactly what every parent’s first thought is: Who do I need to confront? I wanted to pull out my phone right there, email the principal, track down the parents of the kids being mean, demand it stop. But I kept driving, because I remembered when this happened to me in 7th grade, my mom barged into my room 10 minutes after I got home and told me I just needed to smile more and stop being so quiet, and I never told her anything about it again.
We got home, and Lila shut her bedroom door. I didn’t knock right away. I heated up milk on the stove, made her hot chocolate with extra mini marshmallows the way she likes it, and waited 10 minutes. When I did knock, I carried the mug in with me, didn’t sit on her bed where I’d be crowding her, and sat on the rug next to her stuffed animal bin. I said, “I brought hot chocolate. You can tell me every single bad thing that happened today, or we can just watch those rescue cat videos you love. I don’t have to fix anything right now if you don’t want me to.”
That’s when she started crying, and told me everything. The whole class had a group chat for a big end-of-month birthday party, and everyone was invited except her. Someone accidentally added her, then someone else wrote “Lila’s weird” in the comments before they removed her. They don’t pick her for kickball at recess, no one sits with her at lunch most days, and last week someone wrote “Lila smells” on the cover of her math notebook.
I didn’t say “it’s not that bad” or “they don’t really hate you” or “just be nicer.” I just said, “That sounds so humiliating. I’d be hurt too. That’s really awful.” That’s the first thing I’ve learned about this: you don’t have to jump to fix it before they feel heard. Most of the time, kids just need to get the bad feeling out before they can do anything about it. If you start problem solving before they’re done hurting, they learn not to tell you when things are bad.
After she calmed down, I asked her one simple question: “Is this every single kid in your class, or just some of them?” She thought about it for a minute, and admitted it’s really just three popular girls that everyone else is scared of. Most kids don’t actively hate her—they just don’t want to get on the bad side of those three, so they stay away. Jacob shares his extra markers with her when she forgets hers, and the new girl sat with her at lunch two days last week. Catastrophizing is normal when you’re 10; a bad experience with a small group quickly turns into “everyone hates me” in your head. Asking that one question helps pull it back into perspective, without dismissing how she feels.
That night, I did email her teacher. I didn’t demand anyone get detention, or that the girls be forced to be friends with Lila. I just told her what happened, and asked if she could consider assigning random groups for projects instead of letting kids pick their own. I’ve heard from enough teachers that this one small change cuts down on 90% of the intentional leaving out that happens in upper elementary. She wrote back the next morning saying she’d already started doing that after another parent mentioned a similar issue, so that was that.
A week later, I mentioned that the local rec center had started a new after-school rockhounding club—Lila’s been obsessed with collecting fossils since we went to a quarry dig over the summer. I didn’t say “you need to go make new friends here.” I just said, “I saw this flyer, it meets once a week on Wednesdays. You can go once, and if it’s boring, we never have to go again.” She said okay.
It’s been a month now. Last Friday, she came home holding a big chunk of black obsidian she traded with a girl named Mia in the club, and Mia invited her over this weekend to sort their fossil collections together. She still has bad days. Last Monday, she came home quiet because the three girls made fun of her dinosaur backpack, and she ate lunch alone because the new girl was absent. She still says some days she doesn’t want to go to school. It’s not fixed. There’s no perfect ending where everyone likes her now.
I used to think if my kid was hated by her classmates, I had to fix it immediately. I had to get her moved to a different class, make everyone be nice to her, get her a whole new group of friends to make the hurt go away. But now I know that’s not how it works. Most of the time, you can’t force other kids to like your kid, and you don’t have to.
This weekend, I’m driving her to Mia’s house, I’m packing extra chocolate chip cookies for both of them, and I won’t badger her with a million questions the second she gets in the car to come home. I can’t make every kid in Lila’s class like her. I can just be the place she comes back to when it sucks, help her find small spots of connection with people who already like the same things she does, and remind her that one group of people not liking her doesn’t mean there’s anything wrong with her. Some days are still bad, and that’s okay. We’re taking it one hot chocolate and one fossil trade at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My Child Is Hated By Their Classmates: How to Help Them Cope