The Biggest Problem in the Current Education System (And Small Changes Parents Can Make Today)
Last month, I sat across from Lila’s mom at my 3rd grade conference table, the one still scuffed where a kid dragged a metal chair across it last fall. Fluorescent lights buzzed overhead, half the mini candy canes I put out for parents were gone, and Lila’s report card sat between us, all Bs and As, no red marks anywhere. But Lila’s mom twisted the strap of her canvas tote and leaned forward, voice tight: “She cried for an hour last night over that ‘what do you want to be when you grow up’ worksheet for career day. She said if she doesn’t know, that means she’s failing.”
I nodded, because I’d seen this play out a hundred times in 12 years of teaching. A few days after that conference, I watched it happen again during math. We were working through a word problem about how many pizzas to order for our class party. Javi, a quiet kid who brings extra crackers to school every day because he gets hungry mid-morning, raised his hand and said 12. The whole class erupted. “No! The answer’s 5!” they chanted, because that’s what the back of the worksheet said. Javi’s shoulders hunched and he dropped his pencil, staring at his desk. When I asked him to explain, he mumbled that his little brother always tags along to class events, he eats three slices, and three kids in our class have gluten allergies so they won’t eat pizza, so we need extra for the parents who stay. He was right, of course. About real life, anyway. But the worksheet only cared about one correct answer.
People ask me all the time what the biggest problem in our education system is. Most guess underfunding, large class sizes, too much screen time, or bad standardized tests. All of those are real problems, don’t get me wrong. But the one that chips away at kids every single day, that I see cause quiet anxiety even in high-performing kids like Lila, is that we’ve built the whole system around one unspoken rule: there is one right answer, and you need to have it right now. We reward speed and correctness, and we treat not knowing, or having a different answer, as a failure. That’s the rot at the center that touches every kid, no matter their grade or their test scores.
When kids leave school, almost nothing they face will have a pre-written correct answer. Figuring out what job you want takes years of not knowing. Solving a fight with a friend doesn’t have one right move. Planning a budget, fixing a broken bike, even picking what to cook for dinner relies on messy, trial-and-error thinking that our system rarely practices. We’re training kids to fear the one thing they need most to navigate adult life: not knowing.
I told Lila’s mom this, and she asked what she could do at home, because she can’t rewrite the school curriculum or get rid of worksheets. I gave her three small, no-cost changes that she could start that week, no extra planning needed.
First, swap your go-to after school question. Instead of asking “what grade did you get?” or “did you finish your homework?” ask “what’s a question you’re wondering about that you didn’t get to answer today?” It takes two seconds, and it shifts the whole focus of how your kid thinks about school from what they got right to what they’re curious about. Lila’s mom said the first day she asked, Lila just stared at her, because no one had ever asked her that before.
Second, when your kid says “I don’t know,” don’t step in. Don’t give them the answer, don’t tell them “it’s easy, just try harder,” don’t rush them to get it right so you can move on to dinner or soccer practice. Just say “what do you know for sure so far?” That pulls them into thinking instead of shutting down. When I used that line with Javi after the pizza problem, he ended up leading our class in a 15-minute conversation about extra guests and dietary needs that the textbook never even mentioned. He didn’t get a grade for it, but he raised his hand to share a wrong answer the very next day.
Third, carve out 15 minutes a week of ungraded curiosity time. No assignment, no end product, no grade, no expectation that it will turn into a school project or a college application line. If they want to spend 15 minutes looking up why slugs leave slime, or rearranging their Lego to test how many different types of bridges they can build, or drawing 10 different versions of their favorite Minecraft character, that’s it. It just exists for their question. No pressure to produce anything.
Three weeks after our conference, Lila’s mom sent me a quick text. The change stuck. Last week, when the career day worksheet got sent home again, Lila just wrote “I still don’t know what I want to be, but I like drawing cats and helping the librarian get books off the high shelves” and turned it in. No crying, no panic.
I know this doesn’t fix the whole system. I still have to give tests, I still have to grade papers, I still have to rush through lessons to cover all the required material before state testing. Some days I’m part of the problem, when I hurry a kid to get the right answer so we can stay on schedule. The system is big, and it’s slow to change. But these small shifts don’t take extra time, they don’t cost money, and they slowly undo that idea that not knowing is failure.
Last week, I saw Javi stop a first grader who was crumpling up his art project because he “drew the tree wrong.” Javi said, “It doesn’t have to be right. Just tell me why you drew it that way.” That’s the thing we should actually be teaching, isn’t it? Not how to get the pre-written answer. How to keep asking questions even when you don’t know. It’s not a perfect fix, but it’s working, one kid at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Biggest Problem in the Current Education System (And Small Changes Parents Can Make Today)