Is Unstructured Play A Waste Of Time? A Former Teacher And Mom’s Real Take
Last Saturday, I was folding clean sweatpants on the living room couch when my neighbor popped over to drop off a jar of pickles, and we both leaned against the porch rail watching my 7-year-old. For 90 minutes, he’d been hauling small rocks from the back edge of our yard, wiping the dirt off on his jeans, and stacking them one by one along the railing. No plan, no goal, no app telling him what to do next. “Doesn’t that get old?” she said, sipping her iced coffee. “Shouldn’t he be working on those reading flashcards you mentioned, or something that actually matters? I mean, is that not just a waste of time?”
I almost said yes. I’ve felt that pull too, lately. After back-to-school night, I left with a head full of other parents’ schedules: their 7-year-olds doing weekly coding classes, travel soccer, piano lessons, tutor sessions for math enrichment. I’ve laid awake at 10 p.m. wondering if I’m slacking by only signing my son up for one after-school activity a week. When I was teaching full-time 3rd grade, I saw the pressure firsthand too. I had a student named Leo who spent every single free choice period folding tiny origami cranes, over and over. Other paraprofessionals would stop by my table and shake their heads, say he should be at the literacy center matching words or the STEM table building bridges. Once, during an administrator walkthrough, my principal paused by his desk and asked me what “targeted learning objective” folding cranes was meeting. I mumbled something about fine motor skills and left the interaction feeling like I’d messed up.
But then, a month later, Leo brought me a 12-page stapled story he’d written at home. It was about a flock of paper cranes that flew to the moon to escape a storm, each one carrying a small wish for a child on Earth. He’d illustrated every page, folded a tiny crane to tape to the cover, and entered it in our district’s young writers contest. It won second place. That “waste of time” was just his brain working through a story, one small step at a time, without anyone telling him what to write or how to write it.
Back to the rocks: my son hasn’t written an award-winning story about his stacks yet, but I’ve started paying attention to what he does while he’s out there. If a stack falls, he rearranges the bigger rocks to the bottom, adjusts the smaller ones on top, and tries again. He names each stack after different dinosaurs, talks to himself about what each mountain is for, makes up little stories about explorers climbing them. Last week, he figured out that flat rocks work best for the lower levels, rounded ones look better on top. He’s not doing “official” STEM, but he’s problem-solving. He’s not doing “official” creative writing, but he’s practicing narrative. Most of all, he’s practicing being in charge of his own time.
That’s the part we miss when we call anything that doesn’t have a clear adult-led goal a waste of time. We’ve gotten used to measuring every minute of our kids’ days by what it produces: a test score, a trophy, a new skill to add to a college application. But the skills kids build when they lead their own play don’t show up on a progress report right away. They show up when they’re 12 and can figure out how to entertain themselves on a rainy day instead of screaming that they’re bored. They show up when they’re 16 and can stick with a project they care about even when no one is grading them.
What I’ve started doing, as both a teacher and a parent, is really simple. It’s three small things anyone can try, no extra time or money needed. First, if you’re tempted to redirect your kid from something that looks pointless, ask one question: are they upset? If they’re fully engaged, even in something that seems silly, leave them alone for at least an hour. Interrupt only if you have to, for a meal or an appointment. Second, keep a bin of “junk” materials in your house or yard: smooth rocks, scrap paper, old cardboard boxes, bottle caps, fabric scraps. No instructions, no rules for how to use them. Just let them figure it out. Third, clear one 90-minute block every weekend with no planned activities. No playdates, no practice, no tutoring, no chores that can’t wait. Tell the kids they can do anything they want within house rules, and you’ll do your own thing.
I still have days where the guilt creeps in. Last week, I saw a mom from my son’s class post a video of her daughter winning a regional chess tournament, and I sat for 10 minutes wondering if I should sign him up for chess, or coding, or something that looks more impressive than stacking rocks. But then he came inside, covered in dirt, and pulled me to the porch to see his new 14-rock stack that he’d built a tiny stick fence around. He told me it was a protected mountain for a family of foxes, and I couldn’t help but smile.
We still do reading practice every night, and he has soccer practice once a week, and we never skip homework. We don’t fill every minute with that “productive” stuff, though. We leave space for the rocks, and the crumpled paper, and the things that look like a waste of time from the outside. It’s not a perfect system, and I still don’t know if it’s the “right” thing to do long term. But right now, it’s working.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is Unstructured Play A Waste Of Time