How to Limit Commercial Kids’ Pop Culture Without Hurting Your Child’s (Or Your) Social Standing
Last month, I stood in my backyard stacking paper plates after a baby shower for my friend Lila, who’s expecting her first girl this fall. Half the gifts were decked out in Bluey and Paw Patrol branding, and Lila had spent the whole afternoon oohing appropriately over each onesie and activity set, but I caught her rolling her shoulders out when no one was looking, like she’d been holding her breath for an hour. Once most guests had cleared out, she leaned against the fence next to me and said what she’d been holding in: She wants to skip all the mainstream commercial kids’ pop culture in her home – hates the endless marketing, the cookie-cutter content, the way every toy is just an ad for a show. But she’s terrified. “How do I do this,” she asked, “without making my kid an outcast, and without me becoming that preachy parent no one wants to invite over?”
I get the question, because I’ve been doing this for seven years with my son, starting when I was a first-time parent just as anxious as Lila. I started out all or nothing: no branded toys, no kids’ TV channels, no merchandised anything in the house. That first big playdate when my son was four drove home why that rigid approach doesn’t work. All the other four-year-olds were bouncing off the walls quoting Peppa Pig, and my son just sat in the corner stacking blocks, because he had no idea what anyone was laughing about. When we got in the car, he asked me why all the other kids knew a joke he didn’t, and I felt that twist in my gut that I’d messed him up on purpose.
Over the years, I’ve worked out a low-friction middle ground that keeps our house how I want it, and hasn’t left either of us socially blacklisted. The first thing I changed was drawing a clear line between house rules and world rules. At our house, we don’t keep branded kids’ pop culture toys on the shelves, and we don’t have weekly episodes of any of the big hit shows playing regularly. But when we’re anywhere else – playdates, birthday parties, a long wait at the dentist’s office – I don’t say a word if my son watches an episode of Bluey or plays with a friend’s Minecraft Lego set. I don’t correct him, I don’t make a face, I don’t bring up my preferences at all.
That small separation does more than anything else to keep him from being the odd one out. He picks up all the common references he needs just from being around other kids, without having that content in our home every single day. Last year, when every kid in his second grade class was obsessed with a YouTuber’s Minecraft manhunt series, he came home quoting jokes about creepers and dream sequences that he’d heard at recess. He didn’t need to watch 2 hours of it a week at home to follow the conversation, and he never even asked to, because he already got what he needed from his friends.
For your own social standing as a parent, the biggest trick is to keep your choices low-key, not a public statement. If someone gives your kid a branded toy as a gift, you don’t have to announce that you don’t allow those, and you don’t have to regift it in front of them. I just thank them sincerely, put it in the back of the closet, and donate it three or four months later when no one is asking about it. If another parent asks why we don’t have all the popular shows at our house, I don’t launch into a speech about how marketing harms kids. I just say “We keep our screen time pretty limited around here, so we stick to the movies we all watch together as a family” and change the subject. No judgment of their choices, no big preachy take, just a fact about what works for my house. Most people don’t care what you do behind your own front door, as long as you don’t make them feel bad for what they do in theirs.
Last year, my son was invited to a Minecraft-themed birthday party for a classmate. I could have made a big deal out of it, but instead I picked up a Minecraft-themed gift card to the local toy store, wrapped it up, and sent him off. He knew all about Minecraft from recess, so he jumped right into the TNT-themed party games and had a great time. When the host mom asked if he played Minecraft at home, I just smiled and said “He knows all about it from his friends, he’s been looking forward to this party all week.” No drama, no awkwardness.
I think a lot of prospective parents assume it’s all or nothing. Either you let every branded pop culture thing into your home, or you boycott it all and end up with a kid who can’t make friends and a bunch of parents who think you’re weird. But that’s just not true. You don’t have to host the content in your house for your kid to know the references that let him fit in. Kids absorb that stuff from everywhere: the playground, the lunch table, other people’s houses. You don’t have to invite it into your home to let your kid be part of the conversation.
I told Lila all this as we picked up stray blue and pink confetti off the grass, and she said it took a lot of the pressure off. She still doesn’t want a house full of branded toys and endless algorithmically-generated kids’ content, and that’s fine. It’s not perfect, of course. Last spring, my son came home begging for a Paw Patrol bike that all his friends had, and I said no, and he cried on the couch for 45 minutes. That’s just part of it. There are going to be awkward moments, and times he feels left out, just like there are when you set any boundary as a parent. Right now, this approach works for us. My son has a solid group of friends, I still get invited to birthday parties, and our house doesn’t look like a toy store ad for a kids’ TV network. When he hits middle school and all his friends get into whatever huge new thing comes out, I’ll probably have to adjust. That’s just how it goes, right? No one gets parenting perfect, especially when you’re trying to do things your own way.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Limit Commercial Kids’ Pop Culture Without Hurting Your Child’s (Or Your) Social Standing