Do Grades Measure Learning, Or Just How Well Kids Follow Instructions? A Teacher’s Perspective
After school last Tuesday, I was leaning over my desk grading 4th grade fractions quizzes, my chipped vanilla latte sweating through its paper cup onto the stack, when I hit two papers that stopped me. First was Mia’s: neat, every step written out in the blue colored pencil she insists on using, margins straight, every formula copied exactly from the whiteboard I’d left up that morning. It was a perfect A. Javi’s was next: crumpled at the corners, all the answers written in the blank space next to the problem, no steps shown at all. He got every answer right, but per my own classroom rubric, I had to mark him down a whole letter grade for not following instructions. It came out a C.
I called both over after dismissal. Javi showed up scuffing his new basketball sneakers on the leg of my desk, shoved his hands in his hoodie pocket. “Why do I have to write all that stuff down if I already know the answer?” he said. “Fractions just make sense when I do it in my head. It’s slower to write all that garbage.” I asked him to explain how he got the hardest problem on the quiz, the one half the class missed. He walked me through it, drew a little pizza on the back of the quiz to show me how he split it, explained it clearer than I’d explained it to the class that week.
Mia came in the next day for extra help, because she told her mom she still didn’t get fractions, even though she got the A. I asked her to walk me through the same hard problem. She stared at it, twisted the end of her braid, and said “I just did the steps you wrote down. I don’t know why I do step two before step three, I just memorized the order so I wouldn’t lose points.”
This isn’t just a classroom observation for me. I’m also a parent of a 10th grader, and last month he came home with a B- on a history research paper he’d spent three weeks working on. He’d argued that the 19th century labor movement was more influenced by women organizers than most textbooks say, and he’d gone to the local historical society to pull primary sources to back it up. Eighteen of the 20 points he lost weren’t for bad arguments or bad sources. They were because he didn’t follow the teacher’s required 5-paragraph format. He’d structured it to fit his argument, not the template, and that cost him.
That’s when it hit me how much of what we call a “grade” is really just a measure of how willing a kid is to follow the rules we set, not how much they’ve actually learned. It’s not that teachers are being unfair, most of the time. When you have 120 papers to grade over a weekend, checking for compliance with instructions is fast. It’s easy to mark off points for missing steps, wrong format, or a word count that’s 50 words too short. Assessing deep learning takes time. Sitting with each kid to ask them to explain their thinking, reading through an unstructured argument to see if it makes sense, that takes 10 times as long. Most of us don’t have that time, given the way schools are structured right now.
After that fractions quiz, I started making one small change in my classroom that takes almost no extra time but makes a huge difference. I put two small marks at the top of every assignment before I add the required letter grade. One is for content: that’s the grade for how many answers you got right, how well you understand the material. The other is for work habits: that’s the grade for how well you followed instructions for formatting, steps, turning it in on time. After I made the change, Javi got an A for content and a C for work habits. His parents didn’t ground him for a bad grade or assume he was behind in math; they talked to him about why showing steps will matter when he gets to harder, more complex problems, instead of fighting about whether he understood the work. Mia got an A for work habits and a C for content, so we knew we needed to spend extra time practicing the actual concept, not just celebrate the good grade and move on.
For parents, I have one small concrete habit I recommend. When your kid brings home a grade that doesn’t feel right, or even one that does, instead of starting with “good job” or “why is this so low,” ask two specific questions first: “Can you show me what you know how to do here?” and “What points did you lose just for not following instructions?” When my son brought home that B- history paper, I asked those two questions, and we saw immediately that 90% of the points lost were for format, not content. We sat together and talked through his options: he could leave it as is, stand by his structure, and keep the B-, or he could reformat it to fit the teacher’s template and get a higher grade. He chose to reformat it, and that conversation taught him more about how institutions work than any grade ever could.
Another low-friction check-in I suggest for parents is to set aside 10 minutes once a month, over dinner or in the car on the way to practice, and ask your kid to teach you one thing they learned that month that wasn’t on a test. It doesn’t have to be big. Last month, my son taught me how to calculate the odds of drawing a full house in poker, and that told me way more about how well he understands probability than any algebra test grade he brought home that semester.
Grades aren’t going anywhere. Colleges need them, schools need some consistent way to track progress, and that’s not going to change any time soon. I still have to turn in a single letter grade for each of my students every report card period, that’s the rule. I just add a little line of context about what that grade covers, most of the time. There are still days I’m crunched for time and I grade a stack of papers just checking for compliance, same as everyone else. It’s a work in progress. The real mistake isn’t that we have grades—it’s that we too often treat them like a perfect measure of how smart a kid is, or how much they’ve learned. More often than not, they’re just a snapshot of how well that kid fits the rules that happen to be in place that semester. Some kids are good at both learning and following directions, some struggle with both. A lot of them are like Mia and Javi, strong in one place and still growing in the other. That’s okay, as long as we know what we’re actually looking at when we pull that paper out of the backpack.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Do Grades Measure Learning, Or Just How Well Kids Follow Instructions