Should my child do a one year exchange after high school graduation? What we learned
Last April, I found my daughter Lila leaning against our kitchen table, one sneaker propped on the lower cabinet, surrounded by crumpled college acceptance letters and a half-eaten slice of sourdough toast. It was raining, and the light through the window turned everything gray. She pushed a printed exchange program brochure across the table toward me and said, “What if I defer my spot for a year and do this in northern Portugal instead?”
I’d spent the last four years carting her to AP classes and SAT tutoring, checking college application deadlines off a shared calendar, so my first gut reaction was no. Why pause after all that work? I’d heard the stories: kids take a year off after high school, lose momentum, never go back. My brother-in-law’s cousin’s kid took a gap year to travel and ended up working at a coffee shop full time, still living at home at 25. That little voice in my head ran through all the worst case scenarios before she even finished explaining why she wanted to go.
We agreed we’d go to the local information session for the program before we decided anything. It was held in a musty church basement, with folding chairs and a pot of bad coffee that tasted like cardboard. A 20-year-old girl who’d done the exact same program two years earlier spoke, rolling up her sleeve to show a tiny tattoo of a sardine on her wrist, a souvenir from her host town. She said she’d gone to high school convinced she wanted to be a doctor, got into a good pre-med program, and realized a month before graduation she couldn’t imagine taking four more years of chemistry classes just because everyone told her it was a good plan. After a year living with a family in Portugal, volunteering at a local outdoor education program, she came back and switched to education, and now she’s student teaching. It wasn’t a big dramatic speech, just a quiet, matter-of-fact story that stuck with me.
After that, we worked through the practical stuff step by step. The first thing I insisted on was that Lila handle all the logistics herself. She had to call her college’s admissions office to ask about deferral policies, fill out the program application, line up her visa, and email the admissions counselor to get all the details in writing. Turns out, most public and many private colleges are fine with deferring a spot for a year these days; Lila’s school just required a $200 deposit hold and a short letter explaining her plans. That step alone told me she was serious: if she’d been willing to spend three evenings on hold with the admissions office and sort through visa paperwork, she wasn’t just looking for an excuse to avoid college for a year.
We also worked through the common worries one by one. Money was the first big one: we’d saved for college, but could we swing an extra year of program fees? We found a reciprocal exchange program, where host families host for free in exchange for their own kid going abroad the next year, so the total program fees plus insurance and a monthly stipend for her came out to less than a year of in-state tuition and room and board. For safety, we didn’t do anything dramatic: we got her a $30 a month international data plan, agreed on a 10 minute check-in every Sunday night (no daily texts, that just makes both of us anxious), and saved the local program coordinator’s phone number in both our phones. We also talked through a backup plan: if she hated it after the first semester, she could come home early and start college in January, which her school allowed. No one was locked into anything.
Lila left in August. The first month, she texted me every other day complaining that her host sister steals her hoodies, that the coffee is way stronger than she’s used to, and that she can never keep up when the whole family talks fast at dinner. One night she called me crying, saying she felt like an outsider who didn’t belong there. I didn’t offer to fly her home. I just let her talk, and reminded her she could call her local coordinator the next day to talk it through. She did, and the coordinator got her connected to a youth community garden group, and that’s where she started making friends.
By October, she stopped complaining and started sending photos: of her helping harvest tomatoes, of the bakery down the street from her host house, of worksheets she made to teach English to local elementary kids after school. When she came home for Christmas, she told me she doesn’t want to study business anymore, like she’d planned when she applied to college. She wants to study public health, with a focus on local food access for low-income neighborhoods. That didn’t happen overnight, it happened because she spent five months working in that garden, talking to people who didn’t have access to fresh produce, and realized that’s the thing she cares about.
It’s not all perfect. She missed freshman orientation, so she has to do a make-up orientation this summer that’s shorter and less social, and she got assigned a triple dorm instead of the double she would have gotten if she’d started this year. She still has weeks where she’s lonely, and she calls me to vent. We still don’t know if this year will “work out” the way people hope it will. She might change her mind again about her major, she might decide public health isn’t for her after all.
What I know now, that I didn’t know a year ago, is that most 18-year-olds have spent their whole lives following someone else’s schedule: what classes to take, what tests to study for, what extracurriculars to put on college applications. Asking them to pick a major and a four-year plan right after graduation is asking a lot. If your kid is asking about an exchange after graduation, the three concrete questions I’d recommend you start with are: What do you want to get out of this year that starting college right away won’t give you? Can you handle all the planning and paperwork yourself? What’s our backup plan if it doesn’t go how you hope?
I got a text from Lila this morning. It was a photo of a jar of strawberry jam she made with berries from the garden, labeled with her messy handwriting. She wrote, “Still don’t know what I’m doing after this, but this is good right now.” That’s enough for me, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Should my child do a one year exchange after high school graduation