How to Help Kids Get Better at Teamwork: Real Tips From a 4th Grade Teacher
The glue stick fumes and leftover grape juice from snack time still hung in the air when I found the volcano group mid-argument last month. Mia had her arms crossed so tight her elbows stuck out, staring at the crumpled construction paper on the table. Javi was clutching a bottle of orange glitter glue like a weapon. Leo was slouched in his chair, pretending to look up eruption facts on his Chromebook, but his screen was open to a dinosaur game. “They’re being stupid,” Leo said when I walked over, not looking up. “Can I just work alone?”
I’ve been teaching 4th grade for 8 years, and I’ve had this conversation hundreds of times. For a long time, my go-to move was to jump in, split up the tasks, remind everyone to be nice, and move on so we could stay on schedule for the project deadline. But lately I’ve been trying something different, after a dozen parent conferences where people ask me the same thing: how do I help my kid get better at teamwork? It comes up for the kid who always bosses everyone around, the kid who always checks out and lets everyone else do the work, the kid who comes home crying that no one wants to be on their team. Most of the advice I see floating around is vague: just put them in group activities, they’ll learn. Or tell them to communicate better. That doesn’t help much when you’re standing in the middle of a fight over glitter glue.
So that day, I pulled three extra chairs to the table and sat down. I didn’t tell anyone to calm down or take turns being nice. I just said, “Let’s go one at a time. Each of you gets to say one thing that matters to you about this project, no interrupting. Start with what you want, not what the other person did wrong.” Mia went first. She said she needed a good grade on this project to get her science badge for camp, and the rubric said we had to label all the parts, which she’d already done with red lava in mind. Javi went next. He said his grandma went to Hawaii over spring break and saw a real eruption, and the lava was bright orange, not red, and he wanted it to look like what she saw. Then Leo, after a minute of prodding, said he didn’t want to do anything wrong. He’d messed up the last group project by gluing the wrong side of the diorama, and everyone got mad, so he’d rather just not participate than mess this one up too.
I didn’t say anything after that, just waited. After a minute of silence, Mia said, “I don’t care if half the lava is orange. I just need the labeled part to be red so the teacher can see it.” Javi said he’d put all the glitter on the orange half, that was fine. Then they both turned to Leo, and asked what part he wanted to do. He said he’d memorized all the facts about when volcanoes erupt, because he’d been watching videos about them for fun, so he could do the presentation part. By the time I walked away, they were un-crumpling the construction paper, and Javi was squeezing glitter glue onto his half.
That interaction stuck with me, because it’s the core of what I’ve learned about helping kids get better at teamwork: it’s not about getting along all the time. It’s about practicing small, specific skills that they don’t pick up just by being in a group. I’ve started telling parents to try the “one thing that matters” exercise at home, when kids are working together on chores, or a school project, or even planning a family game night. Instead of jumping in to break up a fight or assign roles, you just have each kid say what matters to them first. It takes five minutes, and it stops everyone from just listing what the other person did wrong. It doesn’t work every time, but it shifts the conversation from fighting to problem solving faster than any “be nice” speech I’ve ever given.
Another thing I’ve started doing, that I tell parents to try too, is don’t assign roles right away based on what you think the kid is good at. For a long time, I’d put the kid who likes drawing in charge of art, the kid who likes writing in charge of labels, and that meant kids who thought they weren’t good at anything never got to try a new part, or find something they can contribute. At home, that means if your two kids are building a birdhouse, don’t automatically give the measuring and cutting to the older kid just because they’re bigger. Ask each what part they want to try, even if it seems like it’s a bad fit. I tried this with my own 10 and 12 year old last month, when they had to build a birdhouse for 4-H. My older daughter always takes over every project, and my younger one just walks away. When we did this, my younger said she wanted to draw the outline for the wood. My older was nervous she’d mess it up, but she let her do it. It wasn’t perfectly straight, but it worked, and my younger helped paint it purple with glitter, and both of them were proud of it. It’s lopsided, but the sparrows don’t care.
I still don’t get it right every time. Last week, a group of 4th graders working on a state project ended up gluing three separate sections to one poster board because they couldn’t agree on a layout, and we turned it in that way. Afterward, we talked about what didn’t work, but I didn’t make them redo it. That’s the other thing: it’s okay if the end product isn’t perfect. The point isn’t the project, it’s the practice. Some days, my own kids still fight over who has to take the trash out, and they end up not talking to each other for an hour after. But the trash still gets taken out, and they’ve had a little more practice working through a disagreement than they had before. Teamwork isn’t a skill you master once. It’s just a hundred small, messy conversations that add up over time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Help Kids Get Better at Teamwork: Real Tips From a 4th Grade Teacher