What It’s Really Like Having the “Nice” Boy: Parenting Tips for Kids Who Hate Disappointing Others
I’m pulling into our driveway after picking my 10-year-old Leo up from a birthday sleepover when I notice it: his favorite green hoodie, the one with the frayed T-Rex patch he earned at summer camp and sleeps in three nights a week, is gone.
“Where’d it go?” I ask, twisting around to look at him in the backseat.
He shrugs, scrolling through a Minecraft video on his phone. “Jake said it was the softest hoodie he’d ever felt. He asked to keep it, so I gave it to him.”
“Did you want to keep it?”
He pauses for half a second, then shrugs again. “It’s fine. He liked it more than I did anyway.”
I don’t push him right then, but my chest tightens. This isn’t the first time this has happened. For as long as Leo’s been in school, his report cards have had the same line: “Leo is such a kind, cooperative boy. He never causes any trouble.” Other parents tell me how lucky I am when we have neighborhood cookouts—he’ll give up his favorite lawn chair to a great-uncle he barely knows, he’ll let the younger kids pick the game without arguing, he never talks back. I used to smile and say thank you, agree that it’s a blessing to have a kid who doesn’t rock the boat. But over the last couple of years, I’ve started to see the weight that comes with being the “nice” kid, especially for a boy.
Last soccer season, he worked every practice for three months to earn a starting spot in the end-of-season playoff. Fifteen minutes before kickoff, the coach pulled him aside and asked if he’d give up his spot to the new kid, whose dad sponsored the team and had never gotten to play. Leo just nodded, grabbed his water bottle, and sat on the bench the entire game. I didn’t find out how badly he’d wanted that spot until three weeks later, when we were washing the car and he offhandedly mentioned he’d been excited to play. When I asked why he didn’t say no, he looked at me like I’d asked a silly question. “Coach asked. I didn’t want to be a jerk about it.”
We don’t talk about this much. We praise boys for being tough, or for being nice, but “nice” for boys too often just means they don’t inconvenience anyone else—even when that means inconveniencing themselves. It’s not that kindness is a bad thing; it’s that the label “nice kid” can turn into a box they trap themselves in, because they start to believe their value comes from never making anyone upset.
After the hoodie incident, I started trying small, concrete things to help him untangle that a little, nothing big or dramatic. The first change I made was ditching vague questions. I stopped asking “Did you have fun?” or “Are you okay?” after playdates or games, because those always get a yes. Now I ask specific, small questions that give him permission to complain. After any group activity, I ask one of two things: “What was the most annoying thing that happened today?” or “Was there anything you had to do that you didn’t want to do?” It sounds silly, but it opens the door. Last week, after a group study session, he told me the other kids made him write all the flashcards for their history project, and that was the first time he’d ever mentioned he felt taken advantage of, instead of just saying “it was fine.”
The second thing I do is practice saying no in low-stakes, low-pressure ways. When we’re folding laundry or driving to school, we do two-minute role plays. I’ll be the friend asking to borrow his favorite baseball glove, and he has to practice saying no without being mean. We run through lines together: “I need this for practice this week, but you can borrow my old one” or “I don’t lend this out, sorry.” He thinks it’s dorky, teases me for being weird, but I’ve seen him use the lines. A month ago, when his cousin asked for his good everyday skateboard, Leo said almost exactly that—he offered the old outgrown one from the garage instead of giving away the one he still rides. I almost dropped my coffee when I heard it.
I also make a point to model small nos out loud in front of him. If a neighbor asks me to bring cookies to the school bake sale and I’m too swamped that week, I say no on the phone in front of him, then turn to him afterward and say, “See? I said no and they didn’t get mad. The world still turns.” He rolls his eyes, but I know he notices. I talked to his teacher about this pattern last fall, too, and she started doing quick 30-second check-ins with him once a week between classes, just asking if everything was working out okay, no audience, no pressure. That works for teachers too—nice kids won’t speak up in front of the whole group, so a quiet one-on-one question gets way more honesty than waiting for them to raise their hand.
It’s still a work in progress. I don’t want to turn him into someone who says no to everything just to get his way; a lot of the time, when he gives up something small for someone else, that’s just kindness, and that’s fine. The goal is just to help him see that his needs matter as much as everyone else’s. Last week, he told me he still didn’t want to switch parts in the class play—he’d agreed to be the frog even though he wanted the pirate role, because his friend said he really wanted it. That’s his call. Some days he gives away more than he should, some days he stands his ground, and that’s okay. We’re still figuring it out, one hoodie, one soccer game, one dorky role play at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What It’s Really Like Having the “Nice” Boy: Parenting Tips for Kids Who Hate Disappointing Others