Why Your Toddler Fights the Stroller (and Small Changes That Actually Work)
Last month, I stood in the Trader Joe’s parking lot at 5:30 PM, my shoulder aching from slipping reusable bags, the van still idling because I’d left the cooler of milk inside to avoid it spoiling, and my two-and-a-half-year-old, Mia, was flat on the hot asphalt screaming. The issue? I’d asked her to get in the stroller. A woman pushing a kindergartener on a scooter gave me a small, knowing nod, and I wanted to wave and yell that I used to think this was just a bad kid thing, or a bad stroller thing. I had no idea it was actually a developmental thing I could tweak with almost no extra work.
I got the top-rated stroller all the mom groups rave about. It has enough storage for a week of groceries, big tires that roll over curbs without jostling, reclines all the way back for impromptu naps. I thought I’d checked every box. For the first year and a half, it was fine. Mia would climb in, look at birds, eat snacks, no problem. Then somewhere around her second birthday, it became a battle every single time. I tried everything I’d read: bribes of fruit snacks after the store, carrying her while pushing the empty stroller (which ended with me tripping over a curb and spilling a whole iced coffee all over my shirt), even digging out the old baby carrier. At 29 pounds, Mia left my back sore for three days. I posted in my local mom group saying I needed help with strollers, and got 40 comments that split into two unhelpful camps: just let her walk everywhere, or buy a different stroller.
Letting her walk to the grocery store from our parking spot takes 20 minutes because she stops to inspect every single rock and piece of trash, and by the time we get in, I’m already late and cranky. I couldn’t afford an $800 new stroller on top of the one I already had anyway. So I was stuck, until a friend who works as a preschool aide came with me to the zoo a week after that parking lot meltdown, and watched the whole thing go down. We were standing by the entrance, Mia was sitting in the dirt pulling grass, refusing to move an inch toward the stroller. After I’d huffed and crossed my arms for a minute, my friend leaned against the rail and said, “She just doesn’t like being told where to put her body, right? That’s the whole thing with this age. They’re learning they get a say.”
I’d never thought of it that way. I thought the stroller was just a tool to get us from place to place, but from Mia’s perspective, it’s something I strap her into when I’m done letting her do what she wants. It’s a trap, basically. I’m taking all her control away, right when she’s starting to crave it more than anything. She gave me three small things to try, none of which required buying anything new, so I figured I had nothing to lose. First, give her a choice that doesn’t include “not getting in.” Instead of “do you want to get in the stroller?” which lets her say no by default, ask “do you want to climb in by yourself, or do you want me to lift you?” It sounds silly and small, but it gives her control over the thing that’s happening anyway. Second, let her help push before she gets in. If we’re leaving the park, let her hold the handle and push the stroller to the car for a couple minutes, even if we’re going slow. Third, give her a job to do in the stroller. Let her carry her own favorite toy or snack in the basket, and let her be in charge of keeping an eye on it.
I tried it the next week, on our regular grocery run. I gave her a two minute heads up before we left the playground near my house: “We’re going to get groceries in two minutes. Do you want to push the stroller to the car, or hold my hand while I push?” She immediately dropped the stick she was chewing on and ran for the handle. When we got to the car, I said “Do you want to climb in by yourself, or do I help?” She climbed in, no fuss. I let her put the three dandelions she’d picked in her cup holder, and she held them the whole trip. No screaming. I almost cried in the produce section, it was that weird of a small win.
It makes sense, when you step back. Between 18 months and 3 years old, a kid’s whole main job is figuring out that they’re a separate person from you, that they can make their own choices. When you just pick them up and strap them in without any say, that pushes all their buttons. It’s never really about the stroller. It’s about control, which is the big developmental lesson they’re working on right now. A lot of advice frames this as a tantrum problem to fix, but it’s really just a matter of meeting them where they are, with tiny adjustments that don’t mess up your whole schedule.
That said, it doesn’t work every time. Some days, if she’s already tired and hungry, or we’re running late for a doctor’s appointment, she still melts down. Some days, I’m in too much of a hurry to wait two minutes for her to push the stroller, so I just pick her up and strap her in, and we deal with the screaming the whole way. That’s okay. I also started digging out the beat-up old $20 umbrella stroller I got at a garage sale for short trips, instead of hauling out the big fancy one. It’s lighter, so Mia can actually push it without me holding it up the whole time, and I don’t care if it gets scuffed when she drags it through the dirt. It doesn’t have as much storage, but for a quick trip to the coffee shop, that doesn’t matter.
I still get the occasional side eye when she’s sitting on the parking lot screaming some days. But now I know it’s not that I have the wrong stroller, or that I’m doing something wrong. It’s just a kid practicing being a person, one stroller fight at a time. Most days, the small changes work well enough that we get where we’re going, and nobody leaves with a sore back or a spilled iced coffee. That’s enough for me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Your Toddler Fights the Stroller (and Small Changes That Actually Work)