Is Unstructured Fiddle Time For Kids A Waste Of Time? A Second Grade Teacher’s Perspective
The coffee in my conference room mug had gone lukewarm, and Mia’s mom leaned forward, twisting the strap of her canvas tote between her fingers. “She spends 20 minutes every morning before school just arranging her erasers by color and size,” she said. “I’ve been telling her it’s a waste of time, that she should be doing her morning reading or packing her bag instead. Is this something I should be cracking down on? Am I letting her waste time that she should be using to learn?”
I glanced over at the drawing Mia had taped to the edge of my desk that week – a lopsided unicorn with purple glitter glue hooves – and thought about what I’d seen three days earlier. I’d been setting up for morning work, and Mia was perched at her desk, tongue sticking out of the corner of her mouth, lining each eraser up along the seam of her desk mat. I’d walked over ready to gently remind her to get out her book, when I heard her whisper to her tablemate, “See? The pink ones are all the same size, but the pink sparkly one is fatter. It doesn’t fit.”
I paused, leaned against the bookshelf, and watched for a minute. By the time she was done, she’d grouped them by shape, sorted each group by size, and lined the whole collection up from smallest to largest. Two days later, when we pulled out fraction tiles for our first lesson on comparing parts of a whole, Mia was the first kid to raise her hand and explain why 1/3 was smaller than 1/2. “Because the smaller the pieces, the more you have,” she said, and I immediately thought of her erasers.
This isn’t the first time a parent has asked me this question. Last year, a dad told me his 7-year-old spent every recess building stick forts at the edge of the playground instead of running around playing tag with the other boys, and he was worried it was a waste of social time. A grandma told me her granddaughter spends an hour every weekend rearranging her stuffed animal collection by the order she got them, and it cuts into time she could be taking art class. I get it. When you’re a parent or a teacher rushing through a packed schedule, every minute counts. When I was raising my own son, I used to get frustrated when he’d insist on stirring the pasta for 20 minutes while I was trying to get dinner on the table and get him to his piano lesson on time. I’d tell him it was a waste of time, yank the spoon out of his hand, and send him to go wash up. Years later, he reminded me that he was testing what happened when he stirred faster vs slower, watching how the tomato sauce swirled up the sides of the pot, and that’s how he understood the lesson on force and motion his teacher did at school that week. I’d written a whole learning experience off as a waste of time because I was in a hurry.
The thing is, most of the time, what looks like useless fiddling isn’t actually a waste. It’s just learning that doesn’t come with a worksheet or a scheduled lesson plan. Kids don’t learn only when we tell them to learn. They learn when they’re curious about something, when they’re testing their own ideas, when they’re doing something that feels good to their brain. A lot of the time, those little routines like sorting erasers or rearranging stuffed animals are how kids calm their overstimulated brains down before they do the hard work of focusing on school work. Mia told me once that sorting her erasers makes her head feel “less messy” before she has to read. That’s her own little trick to get ready to learn, and if I take that away, she’s the one who struggles to focus all morning.
I don’t tell parents to let their kids do whatever they want whenever they want, obviously. If sorting erasers makes you late for school every day, that’s a problem. But there are small, easy things you can do instead of just shutting it down and calling it a waste. First, before you interrupt, pause for 60 seconds and just watch what they’re doing. You’ll almost always notice something they’re working out that you didn’t see at first glance – sorting, counting, problem solving, practicing patterns. Second, if it’s not messing up your whole schedule, give them a set time limit instead of shutting it down entirely. Instead of barking “put those erasers away right now,” try “you can sort for five more minutes, then we need to put our shoes on to leave.” Mia’s mom tried this, and she told me the morning fight completely went away. Mia knew she got her sorting time, and she knew when it was time to move on, so there was no arguing. Third, if you do need to stop them, take 30 seconds to acknowledge what they’re doing before you move on. Instead of “that’s a waste of time, let’s go,” try “that’s a really neat order you got those stuffed animals in. We have to leave for soccer now, and you can finish when we get back.” It doesn’t add much time, and it validates what they care about instead of writing it off.
Last week, we had a delayed fire drill, and we were stuck waiting on the playground for 10 minutes longer than planned. Half the kids were scattered along the edge of the field picking dandelions instead of standing in the line I’d told them to stand in. I almost walked over to round them up, annoyed that they were wasting time and getting grass stains on their pants. Then I stopped, and I listened. One kid was counting his petals out loud, another was comparing how fluffy his seed head was to his friend’s, another was making a wish and blowing the seeds off, counting how many floated away. I leaned against the fence and let them be. We went back inside two minutes late, and it wasn’t the end of the world.
I still catch myself wanting to rush past the “unproductive” bits some days. When we’re cramming to get ready for end-of-year testing, I get annoyed at any minute that isn’t on my lesson plan. But I’m trying to get better. What looks like a waste of time to an adult with a full to-do list is almost always time well spent for a kid who’s just figuring out how everything works.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is Unstructured Fiddle Time For Kids A Waste Of Time