Why quiet, unresponsive kids in Chinese classrooms need extra help: practical tips for teachers and parents
The rain streaked the third-floor tutoring center window in Guangzhou, and Xiao Ming’s 10-year-old sneakers scuffed the edge of my desk. I’d asked him three times to show me the multiplication homework he’d forgotten to turn in at school that week, and he just stared at the scuff on his left toe, shoulders hunched so tight his secondhand uniform collar pulled up around his ears. His mom had texted me that morning: Please help this kid. He won’t talk to any of his teachers, won’t turn in work, and they say he’s just being lazy.
Xiao Ming moved here from a small village in Hunan two years ago, after his mom got a job sewing clothes in a factory near our center. His dad drives a delivery scooter, works 12-hour days six days a week. They couldn’t get him into the better public school across town, so he’s in a neighborhood class with 48 other kids. He missed three months of school the year they moved, waiting for his transfer paperwork to go through, so he’s always been a little behind. Kids tease him about his thick Hunan accent when he’s called on to read out loud. After the first month of that, he stopped talking entirely in class.
For the first two weeks I worked with him, I got nothing but silence. I tried stickers, I tried asking him about his favorite cartoons, I tried letting him take five minute breaks to draw if he finished one problem. Nothing worked. He’d just sit, stare at his desk, and wait for the hour to be over. I started to wonder if his teachers were right, if he really was just unmotivated.
Then one Tuesday the office printer jammed right before a big group class, and I had a stack of alphabet flashcards that had gotten mixed up when a younger kid dumped the box. I asked Xiao Ming to sort them by character while I fixed the jam, and I didn’t think anything of it. When I came back 10 minutes later, he’d sorted them perfectly into neat piles, even separated the ones with bent corners into a separate stack to be taped later. His shoulders were relaxed for the first time I’d ever seen. He didn’t have to talk, he didn’t have to perform, he just had to do a quiet task. That’s when I stopped blaming laziness and started looking for the small things that were making him freeze.
The first change I tried was cutting his homework load. Instead of assigning the same 10 problems the rest of the class got, I gave him two. Just two. If he finished both and got them right, he was done for the week. No extra work, no punishment for being slow. The first week, he turned both problems in, and both were correct. That was the first time he’d turned in any completed homework in two months. It sounds too simple to work, but that’s the thing: most of the time, when a kid shuts down and stops turning in work, it’s not that they can’t do any work—it’s that the amount assigned feels so overwhelming they can’t even start. Cutting the work to a size they can handle doesn’t coddle them, it gives them a chance to build a habit of finishing something, anything.
Next I talked to his main class teacher. I told her what I’d noticed about the accent teasing, and asked if she’d let Xiao Ming write his answers on a small whiteboard instead of calling on him to speak out loud in front of the whole class. She was harried, told me she didn’t have time to make exceptions for one kid out of 48. I told her it didn’t require extra work. I bought a pack of 10 small whiteboards and markers off Taobao for 15 yuan, dropped them off at her classroom, and said she only had to let Xiao Ming use one. He could hold it up if he knew the answer, and she didn’t have to call on him if he didn’t hold it up. She agreed to try it for a month.
Two weeks later she texted me. He’d held up his whiteboard three times that week, and got two out of three answers right. He’d never answered a single question in front of the class in two years.
A lot of talk about struggling kids in China focuses on big, systemic changes that most parents and teachers can’t do much about in their daily lives. But the small changes that help are way simpler than people think. None of the things we did with Xiao Ming cost any money or took any extra time out of anyone’s day. We just stopped forcing him to fit into the one-size-fits-all model that wasn’t working for him.
If you have a quiet kid who shuts down like this, the three things that worked for us are things you can try tomorrow. First, cut the homework. If they never finish the assigned 10 problems, give them two. Keep cutting until it’s small enough they can cross the finish line. Second, don’t force them to speak in front of a group if they’re terrified of it. Let them write their answer down, or pass it to you quietly after class. It removes the anxiety of being laughed at or judged wrong in front of everyone. Third, give them a small, quiet job to do. Xiao Ming organizes my bin of extra pencils and erasers at the start of every session. His class teacher has him hand out worksheets. It gives them a sense of belonging without shoving them into the spotlight.
It’s been six months now. Xiao Ming still doesn’t raise his hand to answer questions. He still sometimes forgets his homework folder on the days his dad leaves for work at 5 a.m. and no one reminds him. His test scores are still not top of the class, and he’ll probably never get into one of the city’s top high schools. But last week, he walked into my class, pulled a crumpled paper crane out of his oversized uniform pocket, and handed it to me. He didn’t say anything, just smiled a little and sat down. His math grade went from 32 out of 100 to 64. His mom stopped yelling at him every night about being lazy, and now she just checks his two problems before she leaves for the night shift.
We don’t have a perfect, fixed ending for Xiao Ming. There are still a lot of things working against him that small changes can’t fix. But for right now, he doesn’t hunch his shoulders so tight he can barely breathe when a teacher asks him a question. That’s enough for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why quiet, unresponsive kids in Chinese classrooms need extra help: practical tips for teachers and parents