How Our School’s New Loose Parts Recess Initiative Works (And What We Learned About Getting Parent Buy-In)
The bell rang at 8:45 last October, and I found Mateo and Javi hunched against my third-grade classroom door, one pressing a crumpled maple leaf to a scraped knee and the other refusing to make eye contact. It was the third recess fight that week, all over unmarked four square lines, stolen swings, and nowhere quiet to go when a kid got overwhelmed by the noise. That’s when our principal pushed our half-planned new initiative to a vote: we were redoing our blacktop recess, adding a loose parts play area, and cutting back on the scheduled structured games that had been leaving half the kids bored anyway.
Most of the teachers were on board, but we all knew we’d face questions from parents. I got an email from Mateo’s mom that night: “What even are loose parts? Is this just letting the kids run around with garbage? What about splinters? What about someone getting hit with a board?” It was a fair question. We’d collected most of our first round of donations from parents and local businesses: cut scrap plywood from the construction site down the street, empty 2-liter bottles, old car tires from the local tire shop, cardboard moving boxes, rope, sea glass a grandma who lived at the beach collected, and even a stack of old plastic containers from the school cafeteria. It looked like a mess when we dumped it all in the corner of the playground the first Saturday.
The first day, half the kids just stood around staring at the pile. The other half swarmed it, and within 10 minutes two boys were tugging opposite ends of a big piece of rope, yelling. I walked over ready to break it up, and they stopped before I got there, worked out that they were both building ramps for their toy cars, so they’d cut the rope in half with the help of a fourth grader who brought scissors from his backpack (we now keep scissors locked in the recess bin, that was our first small tweak). By the end of the first week, I noticed I was only breaking up one fight every few days, instead of three or four. Kids who usually sat on the wall alone were hovering around the building projects, asking to help.
Six weeks in, I sat down with Mateo’s mom for fall conferences. She leaned forward before I even started talking and said, “I have to tell you, I was so worried about this new recess. He used to come home every day complaining that someone was mean to him, that he didn’t have anything to do. Now he comes home and talks for 20 minutes about the castle he’s building with Javi, and he asked if we can save all our cereal boxes to bring in. He even worked out a deal with his little sister to share his Legos at home, because he said that’s what you do when you build something together.” That was the first time I really saw the impact beyond just fewer adult interruptions.
It hasn’t been all smooth sailing. Last spring, a kid brought a broken glass jar he’d fished out of a donation box, and it slipped and cut his pinky. We had five parent emails in 24 hours demanding we scrap the whole initiative. We didn’t. We sat down as a staff, made three small changes: we added a 10-minute check every Monday morning to sort all new donations, we banned all glass donations no matter how harmless they look, and we posted a quick update on the parent Facebook page explaining what happened and what we changed. Most parents were fine after that; a few still pull their kids out for supervised indoor recess, and that’s their choice.
What we’ve learned about rolling out any new initiative at a school applies just as much to parents navigating change at their kid’s school, or teachers trying to get support for a new idea. First, you can’t over-communicate small, specific details. We started out sending one 2-paragraph email, and that wasn’t enough. Now we add a 2-sentence “recess update” to our weekly school newsletter, with a photo of whatever the kids built that week. It doesn’t take long to put together, and it lets parents see what their kids are actually doing, not just imagine the worst. Second, expect small messes and small problems, and be open about adjusting instead of defending every part of the plan. We didn’t say “loose parts is perfect and nothing bad will ever happen” after the cut. We said “that was our mistake, here’s what we’re changing to keep it from happening again.” Third, if you’re a parent worried about a new initiative at your kid’s school, ask for one specific example before you decide it’s a bad idea. Instead of emailing to say “this new homework policy is terrible,” ask the teacher to share what a typical week of homework looks like for your child’s grade. Most of the time, the worry comes from gaps in information, not the initiative itself.
Last week, I was on recess duty, and I sat down on the bench to catch my breath between monitoring the blacktop and the loose parts area. A group of second and third graders pulled me over to show me their latest project: a whole “community center” built out of cardboard boxes and old fence posts. They’d made a little chair in the corner for anyone who needed a minute to calm down when they were mad, and a little shelf to hold lost teeth and lost toy parts. We still get an email every month or so from a parent worried about splinters, or worried that their kid is just playing instead of “doing anything productive” at recess. We still have occasional arguments that need me to step in, and we still tweak our rules every few months. It’s not perfect. But more kids come into my classroom after recess happy and tired, instead of angry and amped up, and more kids are working out problems on their own before they come to an adult. We’re still figuring it out, week by week. That’s the thing about new initiatives: they don’t have to be perfect to work.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How Our School’s New Loose Parts Recess Initiative Works (And What We Learned About Getting Parent Buy-In)