Parenting Tips: How I Tried Something New To Help My Kids Use Tablets In A Healthy, Fun Way
Last month, I stood by our living room couch holding a bowl of goldfish crackers and realized I’d had enough. My 7-year-old Lila didn’t look up when I waved a cracker under her nose, her eyes glued to the tablet propped on her knees. My 9-year-old Jax snapped when I brushed a Cheeto crumb off his sweatshirt, his shoulders hunched so far forward they looked permanently curved toward the screen. For months, I’d stuck to the rule I heard everywhere: 90 minutes of screen time a day, only after homework, no tablets an hour before bed. But it still felt wrong. The kids fought every time the timer went off, they stopped building with LEGOs or teasing each other on the walk from the bus stop, and the second one finished their homework they’d be begging for their device before the other even put their pencil down. My sister, a 3rd grade teacher, mentioned offhand that she’d started letting kids create instead of just consume on classroom tablets, and on a whim I decided to throw out my old rule and try something new.
The first afternoon I presented the new plan, they groaned so loud I thought the neighbor would hear. “That’s stupid,” Jax said. “We just want to watch Minecraft build videos.” I told them it wasn’t a ban on their videos, just a switch: 45 minutes of whatever they wanted, same as always, then 45 minutes of working on one project together on the tablet. If it was terrible after 10 minutes, we’d go back to the old way, no arguments. They agreed, mostly because I promised I wouldn’t make them do any of those math drill apps they hate.
Jax had just dug out his box of tiny dinosaur toys from the back of the closet the weekend before, and Lila had been drawing dinosaur backgrounds in her notebook for a week. They settled on making a stop motion movie about a T-Rex who escapes the natural history museum to go get ice cream. I pulled up the free Stop Motion Studio app I’d downloaded the night before, showed them how to take a picture, and stepped back. I sat at the dining table folding laundry, and listened. They bickered for 10 minutes about whether the T-Rex should hide behind a trash can or a park bench, laughed so hard when the T-Rex tipped over mid-scene that they snort-laughed, and Lila made Jax slow down when he was rushing to get to the ice cream scene because “the audience needs to know he’s scared of the security guard.” When the 45 minutes was up, they asked for 10 more minutes to finish the final scene. I said yes, and they put the tablets away right after. No yelling, no “just one more video,” no dragging their feet to set the table for dinner. I stood there by the sink shocked.
I’d spent so long worrying about how many minutes my kids were on tablets that I never stopped to think about what those minutes were made of. A kid can spend 90 minutes mindlessly scrolling through short videos and end up overstimulated, cranky, and begging for more. But 90 minutes spent building something together? That’s a totally different thing. It didn’t take big changes or expensive apps to make this work, either. We still stick to roughly 90 minutes a day on school days, same as before. I just split it, and let them lead the second half.
The rules we have are super simple, any parent can copy them. First, the first 45 minutes is always whatever they want. No nagging about what they’re watching, no taking away Minecraft to make them do reading apps. They get their fun passive time first, so they don’t feel like the new routine is just a punishment to take away their favorite stuff. Second, I never pick the project. They can make anything: stop motion movies, silly memes for grandma’s birthday, a comic strip in the free drawing app, even a recorded dance party to their favorite song. If it’s something they make together, not just watch, it counts. Third, we have one free pass day a week, usually Friday, where they can do whatever they want the whole time, no co-creation required. That takes the pressure off when they’re tired after a long week of school.
It’s not perfect, of course. Last week they argued for 20 minutes over whether the T-Rex should get chocolate or vanilla ice cream, and I had to tell them if they couldn’t compromise we’d call it a day. Some days they’re just tired and don’t want to work together, so we skip the creation block entirely. On busy soccer nights, we just do 30 minutes of screen time total while I pack their bags for the next day, no rules. Last week they finished their 2-minute dinosaur movie and made us watch it after dinner. They typed all the text bubbles themselves, so Lila practiced her spelling without me asking, and Jax figured out how to add background music from the app’s free library without any help from me. It’s messy, it’s silly, and it’s theirs.
I still don’t know if this is the “right” way to do screen time. I still worry sometimes that they’re on the tablet too much, and I still have to remind them to put it away when we’re going to the park. But the big change I’ve noticed is there’s no more daily fight at the timer. Tablets stopped being this thing they hoard time on, and started being a tool to make the dumb, funny stuff that kids love. This afternoon I picked up a pack of googly eyes on the way home from the grocery store—Lila asked for them to add props to their next movie, about our cat who knocks over the living room lamp every week. I don’t know if it’ll be any good, but it’s something they’re excited to work on together. That’s more than I could say a month ago.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Parenting Tips: How I Tried Something New To Help My Kids Use Tablets In A Healthy, Fun Way