Why Quick Feedback on Student Work Matters: A Teacher’s Response to an Alberta Parent’s Question
My cold coffee had gone lukewarm and my 10-year-old’s soccer cleats were propped against the kitchen table leg, crumbs from an after-school granola bar crusted on my laptop trackpad, when I opened the email from Calgary. It was from Sarah, mom of Jaxon, my grade 9 science student. She’d seen I’d sent Jaxon’s cell respiration lab report back graded via our school portal 48 hours after he turned it in, and she had a question. Her older son had just wrapped up a grade 11 history project he’d spent 10 hours on, and it had taken his teacher three weeks to return it. By the time it landed in his backpack, Sarah wrote, he couldn’t even remember half the ideas he’d argued for, let alone what he’d been confused about when he wrote it. The feedback went straight into the recycling next to the trash can. She wanted to know: is turning work around fast just a nice perk, or does it actually help kids learn more?
I thought about this for a minute before I wrote back, because I didn’t always prioritize quick feedback. When I started teaching 12 years ago here in Lethbridge, I thought good marking meant checking every single line, writing a paragraph of feedback for every assignment, and that took time. I’d let essays sit in my trunk for two weeks while I coached volleyball and graded papers on the weekends, and by the time I handed them back, I saw exactly what Sarah was talking about. Once, I handed back a unit test two weeks after we’d taken it, and a student named Mia looked at the red mark on her variable question and said, “Wait, we did this unit already?” She’d already moved on to cell division, and the mistake she’d made with independent and dependent variables didn’t connect to anything she was working on now. She stuffed the test in her binder and never thought about it again, and I watched her make the exact same mistake on the end-of-term exam.
With Jaxon’s lab, I’d marked it the afternoon after he turned it in. He’d written a really solid hypothesis, which was the main learning goal we’d worked on that week, but he mixed up the x and y axis for his graph. I wrote that one note at the top: “Great hypothesis! Double check what goes on each axis – can you fix this before our next lab on Friday?” and handed it back. When he saw the note, he laughed and said, “Oh right! I was arguing with my dad about this when I did it at home, I forgot to ask you.” He fixed it in 10 minutes during study hall that same day, and when we did our photosynthesis lab three days later, he got the axis right on the first try. That mistake didn’t stick, because the feedback hit while the confusion was still fresh in his head.
The thing most people don’t realize is that quick feedback doesn’t have to mean sloppy feedback. I don’t mark every comma splice or every minor calculation error on every assignment. If the goal of the assignment is to practice writing a clear hypothesis, I only grade the hypothesis, note one repeated grammar mistake if I see it, and that’s it. I block off two hours on my calendar every time we have a major assignment due, no extra committee meetings, no other lesson planning that day, just marking. For daily exit tickets or practice worksheets, I spot check 10 papers for common mistakes, go over those mistakes at the start of the next class, and that’s it – no full grading for every single one. That’s how I get work back fast without burning out.
For parents who are waiting weeks for their kid’s work to come back, there’s small, low-effort stuff you can do to make the feedback count when it does arrive. You don’t have to email the teacher and demand faster turnaround (though it’s fine to ask). Next time your kid finishes a big assignment, ask them to spend two minutes telling you what the hardest part was, what they were confused about, and write that note on the top of the assignment before they turn it in. When they get it back weeks later, the first thing they’ll see is that note, and they’ll remember what they were thinking when they did the work. If it’s already been graded and returned, just ask them to re-read their own essay or lab out loud before they read the teacher’s feedback. That jogs their memory of the context, so the feedback actually sticks instead of just being a number on a page.
Sarah asked me if turning work around fast means I care less about getting it right, and the opposite is true. I care that the feedback actually does something, instead of just being a waste of everyone’s time. When I take too long to mark, I end up nitpicking every little thing, because I have time to overthink it, and that just overwhelms kids. They look at a page covered in red marks and ignore the one thing they actually need to change. A single specific comment, while the work is still fresh, sticks way better than a page full of corrections three weeks later.
I sent that response to Sarah on Wednesday night, and she wrote back yesterday morning. She pulled out her older son’s old history project, sat down with him at the dinner table, and had him re-read his opening argument before they looked at the teacher’s feedback. He remembered right away that he’d been unsure if he was using primary sources correctly, which was exactly what the teacher’s feedback addressed. He’s adjusting that same skill for his current research project, something he never would have done if they’d just looked at the grade and tossed it.
I still don’t get every assignment back fast. Some semesters, when we have full report card week and my own kids have back-to-back hockey tournaments, big essays sit on my desk for a week longer than I’d like. I don’t claim it’s a perfect system, and it doesn’t work for every type of assignment. But it’s a small shift I made years ago that’s made all the difference for how much my students actually get out of the feedback I give them. Most days, that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Quick Feedback on Student Work Matters: A Teacher’s Response to an Alberta Parent’s Question