Why Your Kid Wants to Go Back to School (And Why You Might Not Want to Let Them) – A School Counselor’s Perspective
The crinkle of Mia’s cheese cracker wrapper cut through the hum of my office heater last January. She was slouched in the armchair by the window, 7th grade, a faded Harry Styles hoodie pulled up to her wrists, picking at a chipped chip of blue nail polish on her thumb. “I told my mom I want to come back full time,” she said, staring at her scuffed white sneakers. “She said no.”
Mia started with us at the beginning of the school year, and things went sideways after the first month. She had a bad panic attack in the overcrowded cafeteria during lunch, and her mom, Sarah, pulled her out that same day. We worked out a part-time arrangement: half days of in-person classes in the morning, online work at home in the afternoon. It was supposed to last four weeks, while we connected Mia with a therapist and adjusted to the new middle school routine. Three months later, she was still on half days.
Mia pulled out her phone to show me the group chat with her art class friends, texts bouncing back and forth about a sleepover planned after school the next week. “I’m fine now,” she said. “I didn’t even feel shaky when we had that surprise fire drill last week. I just want to stay for lunch and art club and be normal.”
I met Sarah the next morning. She’s a single graphic designer who works from home, and she brought an oat milk latte in a chipped stainless steel tumbler, crossing and uncrossing her legs the whole meeting. “I know she says she’s fine,” she told me. “But I was the one who had to pry the bathroom door open after that attack. I sat on the floor outside for two hours while she cried. I can’t do that again. What if she breaks and I’m not there to catch her?”
I hear this all the time. When a kid has a really scary experience at school – a panic attack, a bad run-in with bullying, an injury that keeps them out for weeks – parents get stuck. The fear we feel on that worst day doesn’t fade as fast as the kid’s fear does. We get used to the new routine, the quiet safety of having them close where we can keep an eye on them, and saying yes to letting them go back feels like rolling the dice on everything getting bad again. It’s not that mom doesn’t trust Mia. It’s that mom doesn’t trust that bad thing won’t happen again.
I didn’t argue that she was being overprotective. That never works. Instead, we mapped out a trial plan that took the pressure off a permanent yes or no. Two weeks of incremental steps, no big leaps. First three days: Mia stays through lunch and art, comes home after that. Next three days: she stays through the last period and does all her work at school. We set very clear rules that worked for both of them: Mia could text Sarah at any point to come get her, no questions asked, no “I told you so” if that happened. Sarah agreed she would not text me or the front office every hour checking on Mia. If she got antsy waiting, she could walk around the block or fold laundry instead of reaching for her phone. I also had them both write down their expectations on a sheet of notebook paper, which they taped to their fridge. Mia wrote: “I want to sit with my friends at lunch and not miss art club.” Sarah wrote: “My worst fear is Mia has a panic attack and no one helps her.” Putting it all out on paper kept them from sniping at each other when tension ran high.
The first week, Sarah texted me once on day two, 10 minutes into Mia’s first full afternoon, to say she was sitting by her car keys ready to leave the second Mia called. I reminded her of the walk she’d planned with her golden retriever, and she went. Mia never called. By the end of the first week, Mia stayed after school for an art club meeting, and Sarah waited in the car line 15 minutes early, but didn’t come in to check on her like she’d done before.
For parents stuck in this spot, it doesn’t have to be a fight between pushing your kid too hard or keeping them home forever. The small trial with an exit ramp works way better than a permanent decision right off the bat. If you’re stuck, instead of just saying “you’re not ready,” try writing down your three biggest worries, then ask your kid what they think they can do to handle each one. That gives you both something to work with, instead of just standing on opposite sides of the argument. And if your anxiety is the thing holding you back, give yourself a small routine to manage it that doesn’t involve your kid. A 20 minute walk, a coffee call with a friend, a half hour of gardening while they’re at school. You don’t have to stop worrying, you just have to not let your worry stop their progress.
Three months later, Mia is full time. She had her first art show at the school last month, her mom came and bought her a bouquet of daisies after. Last week, Mia stopped by my office and told me her mom almost kept her home when she woke up with a slight stomach ache last Monday. But instead of saying “you can stay,” she said “let’s try homeroom, and I’ll come get you if you still feel bad.” Mia ended up staying all day – it was just pre-algebra test jitters. Sarah still texts me once a month to check in, says she still has bad nights where she lies awake worrying something will go wrong. But she says it’s worth it, to see Mia laughing with her friends after school instead of sitting at the kitchen table working alone. It’s not perfect, and it’s not permanent. It’s just one small step at a time, for both of them.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Your Kid Wants to Go Back to School (And Why You Might Not Want to Let Them) – A School Counselor’s Perspective