Why Disengaged Kids Shut Down And What Actually Helps: Lessons From Teaching In Rural China
The first week I volunteered at the small rural primary school in Anhui, I found Xiao Ming slouched in the back row of third grade, gray school hood pulled over his black hair, his desk carved so full of tiny ants you could barely see the brown wood. We were doing group place-value activities that morning, and every table was chattering as they sorted blue and red number blocks. Xiao Ming’s table had left an empty spot for him, and no one even bothered asking him to join anymore. He just stared at the banyan tree outside the window, his thumb rubbing the chewed eraser of his pencil, like he wasn’t even in the room. After class, the homeroom teacher pulled me aside, her voice tired. “Please help this kid,” she said. “He hasn’t spoken a word in whole-class instruction in two years. Hasn’t turned in more than three homework assignments total. His parents work in Guangzhou, he lives with his grandma who can’t even read. We don’t know what to do with him anymore.”
I’d been told to expect this, of course. Half the kids at the school are left-behind children, many fall behind when they move back and forth between rural and city schools with their parents, and with 45 kids in a class, there’s no time to pull someone aside for 30 minutes every day to catch them up. I started with what I thought I should do: I asked him to stay after class for extra math help the first week. He waited until I turned my back to collect my bag, then ran out the door before I could call him. I tried leaving a note on his desk asking what he liked to do. He left it crumpled in the trash can after class. For the first two weeks, I thought I was just going to be another person who failed to get through to him.
One afternoon I stayed late to wipe down the blackboards after school, and I saw him lingering by the school gate, looking up at the banyan tree where a flock of crows nested. I didn’t walk over to talk about homework. I just leaned against the doorframe and said, “Those crows wake me up at 6 every morning, I swear they’re louder than the school bell.” He froze for a second, then nodded, barely noticeable. That was the first response I ever got from him. I didn’t push for more. I just waved and walked home.
After that, I started paying attention to the ants he carved everywhere. They were on his pencil, his textbook, every page of the blank exercise book he carried. They were all different, some with little segmented bodies, some carrying crumbs. I had an extra cheap sketchbook in my bag I’d brought for planning lessons, so I left it on his desk one morning with a new pencil. I didn’t leave a note, didn’t make a big deal out of it. When I came back after lunch, the sketchbook was gone from his desk, and I didn’t see it again for three days. Then he left it tucked on my desk after class, the first 10 pages filled with ants crawling all over a big banyan tree. No words, just ants.
That’s when I realized I’d been doing everything wrong. I’d started with the assumption that the problem was he was behind, so we needed to fix his grades first. But the real problem was that every time he stepped into class, every interaction reminded him he wasn’t “good enough” at school. If he tried to answer a question and got it wrong, the other kids laughed. If he turned in half-done homework, the teacher marked it zero and put it at the bottom of the pile. After a while, it’s easier to just not try at all. If you don’t participate, you don’t have to feel stupid in front of everyone.
I changed what I did, small things that didn’t take extra time out of the school day. First, I stopped calling on him in front of the whole class. When we walked around checking worksheets, I’d stop at his desk, point to the one or two problems he’d done, and whisper “that’s right” so only he could hear it. No big praise, no drawing attention to him, just a quiet confirmation that he got something right. Second, I let him contribute to group work in a way that played to what he could do. When we made posters for math or science, I’d tell the group Xiao Ming was their official artist, because he drew better than anyone. He got to be a useful part of the group without having to do the math or reading he was still behind on. Third, I never pushed him to talk if he didn’t want to. If I asked him a question and he just stared at his desk, I’d smile and walk away. No “come on, just tell me” no making him feel bad for being quiet.
After a month, I was collecting homework from the stack on my desk, and there was a crumpled third-grade math worksheet tucked in the back. Xiao Ming’s name was scrawled in the corner, all the single-digit addition problems done correctly, and a tiny ant doodled in the margin. I didn’t hold it up to the class or make a big deal out of it. I just wrote a little check mark on it and handed it back to him the next day. A month after that, he mumbled “xiexie” when I gave him a pack of fine-tip drawing pencils I’d picked up in the town center. It was so quiet I almost didn’t hear it, but it was the first time I’d heard him speak.
This isn’t a problem that’s only for left-behind kids in rural China. I’ve talked to teachers in Chinese cities, and parents across the world, who deal with the exact same thing: a kid who shuts down, stops trying, gets labeled as lazy or unmotivated. The default response is always to push harder, to give more homework, to force them to participate, to catch up as fast as possible. But that just makes the wall higher. You don’t need a fancy intervention or hours of extra tutoring to start. You just need one small positive interaction a day, that has nothing to do with grades or performance.
It’s been six months now. Xiao Ming still doesn’t raise his hand in class. He still doodles on his homework more than he fills it out some weeks. His reading and math are still almost a full grade behind where they’re supposed to be. I don’t know if he’ll ever catch up to the rest of his class, or if he’ll go on to high school like all the other kids. But two years ago, he didn’t talk to anyone, didn’t turn in any work, and spent every day staring out the window. Now he sits with his group when they work on projects, he turns in homework about half the time, and he says hello when I pass him in the hallway. Last week he left a drawing on my desk of the banyan tree, full of crows, with a tiny ant carrying a pencil eraser at the bottom. It’s not a perfect, dramatic turnaround. It’s just small, slow progress. And for a kid who’s spent years invisible, that’s more than enough for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Disengaged Kids Shut Down And What Actually Helps: Lessons From Teaching In Rural China