Why Kids Associate Nurses With Women and Blue Collar Jobs With Men: Parenting Tips for Breaking Career Stereotypes
Last month, I volunteered at my second grader’s career day, standing next to my husband, who’d come as a guest to talk about his job as a pipefitter. He’d brought a box of old copper fittings and a mini pipe cutter for kids to try, and the table was packed with elementary kids squeezing fittings together and pretending to fix leaks. Halfway through the morning, I noticed a tiny first grader named Mia hanging back by the door, twisting her braid around her finger. When my husband waved her over to come try the cutter, she whispered, “My mom says only boys do this stuff. I’m gonna be a nurse, that’s for girls.”
It stopped me cold, because I’m an ER nurse. My husband and I fit the stereotype on paper, but I’ve spent my whole career seeing how those lines hurt people. I’ve had patients ask my male nurse colleague for his doctor’s order more times than I can count, and my husband has had customers ask for the “lead guy” when his coworker Lila, a 10-year veteran electrician, shows up to a job. After career day, we loaded Milo’s craft bag into the car and stopped for ice cream on the way home, sprinkles getting ground into the car seat cushion as Milo piped up from the back: “Is that true? Boys can’t be nurses and girls can’t fix pipes?”
That question stuck with me for weeks. I’d always assumed we’d talk about stereotypes when Milo was older, but it turns out they show up way earlier than that. They’re in the worksheets his teacher hands out, where the nurse is always a woman and the construction worker is always a man. They’re in the cartoons he watches, and the casual comments relatives make at holidays. It’s not that anyone is sitting down and teaching these ideas on purpose—they’re just the default that kids pick up without anyone noticing.
I’ve talked to other parents who brush it off, saying kids will grow out of it, or that it’s just a kid thing. But I’ve seen how these early ideas stick. A lot of bright teenage girls rule out blue collar trades before they even look into them, because they’ve always been told those are “guy jobs.” And a lot of boys who would make great nurses never consider it, because they’ve heard it’s “women’s work.” We don’t have to overhaul the whole school system to change that, though. We’ve found small, low-effort things that work for our family, and they don’t involve big awkward lectures.
First, instead of just telling kids stereotypes are wrong, we let them spend time with people who break them, in casual settings. We didn’t organize a big school assembly or anything. We just invited our friend Jake, a pediatric nurse, over for backyard barbecue last summer. He brought his stethoscope, let the kids listen to each other’s hearts, and told them about how he gives out lollipops after shots and calms down kids who are scared before surgery. No one gave a speech about boys being nurses—he just talked about his job, and that was enough. A month later, we stopped by Lila’s job site when she was finishing a small rewiring job at a neighbor’s house. She let Milo and Mia hold her voltage tester, explained what it does, and let them watch her screw a cover plate onto a wall outlet. Kids don’t remember what you tell them, they remember what they see.
Second, we’ve started catching the casual default language we use all the time, and adjusting it. I used to automatically say “Go ask Dad to fix that wobbly chair” when I was right there holding a screwdriver, just because that’s the line I grew up hearing. My husband used to automatically say “Go ask Mom, she’s the nurse, she’ll look at that scrape” when he could clean a wound just as well as I could. Now, if I can change a fuse or fix a chair, I do it, and I say “Let me show you how I do that” instead of passing it off to my husband. If my husband has a headache, he doesn’t hand it off to me to handle. It’s a small change, but it adds up. When Milo asks me why I used to always ask Dad to do that, I just say “I got used to saying that, but I can do it too.”
Third, we point out stereotypes casually when we see them in books or shows, instead of turning it into a big lesson. The other night we were watching a cartoon where the only medical character was a female nurse and the only construction worker was a male foreman. I didn’t pause the show and give a 20-minute talk. I just said, “Huh, I don’t see any male nurses or female construction workers here. Uncle Jake is a nurse, remember?” That’s it. It’s just a gentle nudge to make them notice that the world in the show isn’t the whole real world.
We’re not perfect. I still catch myself defaulting to old lines sometimes, and I still see Milo repeat stereotypes he hears at the playground. But last week, Mia brought a drawing to our neighborhood block party. It was her, wearing a hard hat and holding a stethoscope, and she said she wants to fix pipes and help sick people when she grows up. I don’t know what she’ll end up doing. She might change her mind a hundred times before she’s an adult. That’s fine. The point isn’t to push her into a specific job—it’s to make sure she doesn’t rule out the thing she might love just because someone told her it’s not for people like her. That’s all we can do, right? One small comment, one casual meeting, one small adjustment at a time. It’s not a perfect fix, but it’s working for us so far.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Associate Nurses With Women and Blue Collar Jobs With Men: Parenting Tips for Breaking Career Stereotypes