How To Help Your Kid Handle Annoying People At School: A Teacher’s Perspective
Last Tuesday, right after morning recess, I was wiping marker off the whiteboard when Leo burst into my 4th grade classroom, mulch crammed in the tread of his sneakers, and slammed his water bottle down hard enough to slosh Gatorade all over his long division worksheet. “Javi is so annoying I can’t even play four square without him breathing down my neck,” he said, loud enough that a third of the class looked up and nodded in agreement.
Javi’s been in my class this year, and he’s that kid. The one who taps his pencil through silent reading, leans over your shoulder to comment on your drawing when you’re trying to work, and asks to join your game three times even after you said no. He’s not mean. He doesn’t hit or steal or call names. He just wants to be around people so bad he can’t read the room, and that makes him exhausting for 9 and 10 year olds who just want to play their game without interruption.
After school that day, Leo’s mom pulled me aside by the bike rack. She said Leo’s talked about Javi every night for a week, he’s been asking if he can stay inside for recess every day, and she doesn’t know what to say. She doesn’t want to badmouth Javi to Leo—she knows he struggles with social skills—but she also doesn’t want to tell Leo his frustration is wrong. That’s the question I get all the time. No one talks much about annoying kids, not the way we talk about bullying or classroom conflict, but every school, every grade, every classroom has at least one. They leave a lot of kids and parents stuck on what to do.
I thought back to when I was 11, sitting in 6th grade science class, behind a kid named Marty who clicked his pen nonstop through lectures and tapped my shoulder to ask what the homework was five times a period. I went home complaining every day, and every adult but my mom told me to just be nice and ignore him. My mom just said, “It’s okay to be annoyed. You don’t have to like everyone, you just have to be polite when you’re around them.” That stuck with me, because it was the first time anyone told me my frustration wasn’t out of line.
The first mistake most adults make is jumping to defend the annoying kid before we validate the annoyed kid’s feelings. If your kid comes home saying someone at school is annoying, don’t lead with “he doesn’t mean any harm, he just wants a friend.” That tells your kid their feelings don’t count, even if what you said is true. Instead, start with “That does sound frustrating. I’d be annoyed too if someone wouldn’t leave me alone when I was trying to play.” It takes two seconds, and it makes your kid feel heard before you talk about next steps.
Next, give them a simple, concrete script they can actually memorize, instead of vague advice to “stand up for yourself.” Kids this age don’t know what to say that isn’t “go away” (which starts a fight) or nothing at all (which just leaves them fuming). I give all my kids two go-to lines they can pull out anytime. If someone is hovering or bugging them while they play: “We’re full right now, you can be next.” If someone is bothering them while they work: “I need to focus right now, please leave me alone.” They’re short, clear, and not rude, so most kids don’t end up in trouble for saying them, and it works far better than the subtle hints most kids rely on—like turning their backs or rolling their eyes—that kids like Javi just don’t pick up on.
You also don’t have to force your kid to be friends with them. A lot of adults feel like we have to make every kid include every other kid all the time, but that’s not realistic. I don’t want to be friends with every person I work with, why would I expect that from a 9 year old? If your kid wants to sit somewhere else at lunch or avoid a game the annoying kid is playing, that’s okay. Small accommodations don’t hurt anyone. In my class, if Javi’s having a hyper day and bouncing all over the playground, I let kids who get frustrated come in and color or play a board game early, no questions asked. If a parent tells me their kid can’t focus because the kid next to them is tapping nonstop through math, I swap seats. It’s not punishing the annoying kid, it’s just giving everyone the space they need.
A couple of weeks after Leo talked to me, he tried the script on Javi at four square. Javi was hovering like usual, and Leo said “we’ve got four players right now, we’ll switch out in 10 minutes, you can be next.” Javi actually stepped back and waited on the edge of the court, no hovering, no asking again. Leo came back in after recess and told me it worked, like he couldn’t believe it.
It’s not perfect, of course. Some days Javi still forgets, some days Leo still comes in frustrated and asks to stay inside for 10 minutes to cool down. Last week, Javi followed a group of kids to the library during free choice and one of them snapped at him, and Javi spent 20 minutes sitting on the bench outside my room because he thought no one liked him. It’s messy, it doesn’t get fixed in a week, and it never will be completely perfect.
But the thing is, learning how to handle annoying people is a skill kids need anyway. We all have annoying coworkers, annoying neighbors, annoying people in our grocery stores who stand too close. They don’t have to be villains to be frustrating, and our kids don’t have to pretend they’re not just to be nice. Right now, this is working for Leo. He stopped asking to stay home from school, he knows what to say when Javi bugs him, and he knows it’s okay to walk away if it doesn’t work. That’s enough for me, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How To Help Your Kid Handle Annoying People At School: A Teacher’s Perspective