What to Do When Your Pre-Teen Doesn’t Know How to Handle Kids Who Don’t Like Her
I’m merging onto the highway after picking my 11-year-old Mia up from 5th grade, her half-eaten bag of cheddar Goldfish rolling around the footwell, the salt shaker from my morning drive-thru breakfast rattling on the center console, when she slams her phone face-down so hard the screen bumps against the plastic. “What’s wrong?” I say, eyes on the road. She doesn’t answer for a minute, just picks at a loose fray on her dinosaur hoodie. Then she says, “Haley and Lexi posted a reel making fun of a backpack that looks just like mine. They tagged it ‘cringe’.” I wait, and she adds, quiet, “I shared my sour gummies with them at lunch on Tuesday. I don’t get what I did wrong.”
I’ve been here before. Three months ago, she started wearing those rubber star hair clips Haley likes, even though she complained they pulled her scalp, because she thought it would make them want to save her a seat on the bus. A month after that, she cried for 45 minutes straight on the couch because they didn’t invite her to their weekend skate party. My first instinct, the first dozen times this came up, was to jump in and fix it. I’d say “they’re just being mean, forget them” or “you’re so much nicer than they are” or even “do you want me to email their teacher?” None of that helped. Mia would just stare at her socks and get quieter, like I’d missed the whole point of what she was saying.
The point wasn’t that those girls were bullies, not really. It was that pre-teens don’t have any framework for “some people just don’t like you, and you didn’t do anything to deserve it.” Their whole world is still contained within that six-hour school day, their single class, their fixed lunch table. It’s not like when we’re adults, we can walk away from a rude coworker and go home to our people, our hobbies, our whole separate life outside work. For them, this feels permanent. If the popular girls at your lunch table don’t like you, that means everyone sees you the way they do. That’s how it feels, anyway.
I learned to stop giving the quick fix first, and start with one question I picked up from a teacher friend: “Do you want to feel better right now, or do you want to figure out what to do next?” That day in the car, Mia thought for a second and said she wanted to feel better first. I took the next exit, pulled into the soft-serve place by the library, got her the mint chocolate cone with sprinkles she likes, and we sat on a splintered wooden bench outside watching people walk their dogs for 20 minutes. I didn’t mention Haley or Lexi or the backpack once. That’s the first thing no one tells you: half the time, they don’t need a solution right away. They just need to not have to think about it for a minute.
When we got back in the car, she brought it up on her own. That’s when we started working on small, concrete things instead of the big vague advice I used to spout. The first one is the one-sentence rule for people who don’t like you. No over-apologizing, no forcing extra jokes to win them over, no awkwardly ducking into bathroom stalls to avoid them in the hallway that leaves you all twisted up inside. If you have to talk to them, one neutral sentence, then you walk away. If they ask for a pencil, “Here you go” that’s it. If they make a comment about your backpack, “I like it” that’s all you have to say. No need to defend yourself, no need to change their mind. Mia thought that sounded too simple at first, but she tried it. She said it took all the pressure off, because she didn’t have to overthink every little thing she said around them anymore.
The second thing we did was make a “good moments” list, not a generic “how many friends do you have” list to prove she’s loved. I pulled out an old spiral notebook from the junk drawer, and had her write down one small thing every person who likes her does that makes her feel good. It’s not a brag, it’s just a reminder when her brain gets stuck on the negative. She wrote: “Lila saves me a spot at art club every Wednesday”, “My cousin texts me cat videos when I’m sad”, “Jake laughs at all my bad dinosaur jokes even when they’re not funny”. When she’s stuck replaying what Haley said after school, she can pull it out and look at it. It’s way more effective than me saying “you have lots of friends, who cares what they think” because it’s her words, her memories, not my generic reassurance.
Last week, she came home and told me Haley made a comment about her dinosaur hoodie in the hallway. Mia just shrugged and said “I like it” and walked over to sit with Lila at lunch. She didn’t cry, she didn’t ask me what she should have done differently. She just said it was weird, but it didn’t ruin her day.
It’s not all fixed. Some nights, she’ll still get quiet while we’re stirring pasta for dinner and say she wishes they’d be nice to her. I don’t tell her she shouldn’t feel that way. I just say that it’s okay to want people to like you, even people who aren’t very nice. This isn’t about teaching her to never care, it’s about teaching her that she doesn’t have to fix other people’s opinions of her, or change herself to make it better. It still comes up, it still hurts sometimes. That’s normal. There’s always going to be someone who doesn’t like you, for no good reason, at any age. The best we can do is give them small, simple tools to handle it, instead of trying to make the whole problem go away. We’re still working on it, and that’s okay.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What to Do When Your Pre-Teen Doesn’t Know How to Handle Kids Who Don’t Like Her