Is My Kid’s Endless Doodling a Waste of Time? What I’ve Learned as a Teacher and Mom
I’m sitting across from my 10-year-old son’s 5th grade math teacher last month, stirring lukewarm coffee from a crumpled school paper cup, the classroom heater blowing hot enough to make my sweater itch. She nods toward the open notebook on the desk between us, where a scaly green dragon peeks out from the edge of a page of long division problems. “He does this every day during independent work,” she says, not harsh, just genuinely curious. “I’ve wondered if it’s just a waste of time I should be nipping in the bud.”
I smile and tug my own beat-up teacher notebook out of my tote bag, flip to the back, and turn it toward her. Half a dozen lopsided daisies and messy stick figures of my kids are scrawled along every margin, leftover from every staff meeting and professional development session I’ve sat through in the last year. “I still do it,” I say. “I wouldn’t get through a 90-minute training without it.”
Twelve years of teaching, and I still catch myself falling into the same trap as every other parent. A year ago, I was the one asking if my son’s doodling was a waste of time. We’d just moved him up to the advanced math track, his grades were hovering in the low C range, and every time I cleaned out his backpack, half the pages of every notebook were covered in robots, exploding space ships, and elaborate storyboards for video games that didn’t exist. Not a single one had anything to do with algebra or vocabulary.
I remember the fight we had at the kitchen table over factoring polynomials. I’d leaned over to check his progress, and there he was, shading in the wing of a dragon instead of writing down his work. I ripped the whole page out of the notebook, crumpled it up, and tossed it in the trash. He just stared at me, lip pushed out, eyes shiny, and said “I can’t do the math if my hand isn’t doing something else.” I didn’t believe him. I told him it was just a distraction, a waste of 20 minutes every night he could spend finishing his work faster so he could go play outside.
A month after that fight, I had to cover a 5th grade class for a colleague who went home early with a migraine. I had 28 10- and 11-year-olds, all working on state test practice reading packets, and I wandered up and down the rows while they worked. Half of them were doing something other than reading: twisting hair around their fingers, picking at eraser crumbs, doodling tiny hearts or footballs in the margins, twisting rubber bands around their wrists. One boy, who I knew struggled with ADHD and had been sent to the office three times that month for “wasting time” during independent work, had a whole 4-panel comic strip going in the back of his notebook while he waited for his classmates to finish. I checked his last progress report: his reading score was 10 points higher than the previous quarter, when his old teacher had made him put all drawing materials away and sit on his hands to stop fidgeting.
That night, I looked up what researchers actually say about it, no fancy jargon, just plain facts. Turns out, for a lot of people, especially kids who struggle with sustained focus, doodling and fidgeting don’t pull attention away from the task at hand. They occupy the part of the brain that would otherwise get bored and wander off to something way more interesting than fractions or reading comprehension. What looks like distraction is actually self-regulation.
I tested it with my son first. Instead of banning doodling, we made a simple deal: he can draw anything he wants in the back third of every notebook, as long as all assigned work goes in the front two thirds, and he finishes all the problems before he packs up his bag for the night. No more fighting, no more tearing up pages. I was sure he’d just spend the whole homework period drawing, but he didn’t. He’d doodle while he read through a word problem, while he worked through the steps in his head, then turn the page and write down his work. Within two months, his math grade climbed to a low B, and it’s stayed there ever since. Last semester, I tried the same trick with a 3rd grader in my class who couldn’t stay seated for 15-minute reading groups. His mom had been telling me he was just wasting time and being disruptive at home too. I told her to let him doodle while we read, and keep a small container of playdough at his desk for group time. Three weeks later, his reading fluency was up 12 words per minute, and he hadn’t gotten up to wander around the room once in two weeks.
The thing is, we’re all conditioned to think that every minute of a kid’s school and homework time has to be visibly productive. If they’re not actively writing an answer or memorizing a word, it’s a waste. But that’s not how most brains work. The question “is this a waste of time” always depends on who you’re asking, and what their brain needs to get the work done.
I don’t give fancy advice, but the small things I tell parents who ask are concrete. If you’re worried about doodling, don’t ban it first, test a simple boundary. Try “drawing only in the back of the notebook” or “doodling only while I read instructions out loud” instead of an all-out ban. If your kid draws on their homework, don’t make them redo the whole page just for a drawing in the margin. Most teachers don’t care, and a quick 1-sentence note explains everything if they do. If you’re still not sure, spend a week counting: write down how long it takes your kid to finish homework with doodling, then compare it to the week you banned it. I’ve had three parents tell me this year that it cut their nightly homework time by 15 minutes, because their kid stopped getting up every two minutes for a snack or a drink when their hands already had something to do.
Back to that parent-teacher conference. The teacher nodded, and said she’d try the notebook boundary instead of moving my son to a desk up front by herself to stop him from drawing. Last week, my son came home with his graded math test, a B+ scrawled at the top. The same green dragon was drawn in the corner of the answer sheet, and the teacher wrote “cool dragon” next to it. It’s not perfect. Some days he gets carried away and draws too much, and we have to remind him to wrap up the drawing and finish his work. I still catch myself sometimes, old habit, thinking wouldn’t it be faster if he just focused on the problem? But then I remember me, doodling lopsided daisies through 90-minute staff meetings, still able to take down what I need to know. Wasted time looks different for every brain. What looks like a waste to one person is just how another person gets the job done.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is My Kid’s Endless Doodling a Waste of Time