Why Art and Emotional Expression Matter for Kids (And What It Actually Looks Like Everyday)
Last Tuesday, I was mid-math warm-up with my third-grade class when the classroom door slammed so hard the taped-up alphabet chart wobbled. Leo, 8 years old, hood up, cheeks streaked with dirt and half-suppressed tears, shoved past the kid who’d gone to hold the door, dropped his backpack so hard the desktop pencil sharpener toppled off the supply counter, and curled into his seat with his face pressed into his arms.
The yard teacher had pulled him aside after a pushing match over four square: Javi had called Leo a cheater, Leo had pushed Javi into the fence, and now Leo wouldn’t say a word to anyone. I walked over, knelt down, asked if he wanted to go talk to the counselor, and he just shook his head so hard his hood slipped over his eyes. Normally I’d sit with him a minute, keep prompting him to put what he was feeling into words, but that morning I’d just restocked the art bin by the reading nook, full of new oil pastels and crumpled construction paper someone had donated. I dragged the bin over to his desk, said “You can make whatever you want while we finish this warm-up, no rules,” and walked back to the board.
Fifteen minutes later, a small hand tapped my elbow. Leo was standing next to me, holding a crumpled sheet of paper. It was a big red monster with jagged black spines for teeth, clutching a crumpled four square ball, and a smaller blue monster with X’s for eyes hunched in the corner. “That’s me when I want to punch Javi,” he said. Then he told me the whole thing: Javi had moved the out-of-bounds line when Leo wasn’t looking, everyone on the court had sided with Javi, and his face got so hot he couldn’t breathe, he couldn’t think of anything to say except push.
Over the last year of teaching, and as a mom of a 10-year-old, I get asked all the time why we spend so much time on art instead of extra reading or math practice, and whether all this talk about putting feelings into art is just a fancy trend that doesn’t really matter. A lot of parents come to conferences worried because their kid won’t open up about bad days, won’t tell them what’s wrong, and they think if they just push enough to get the words out, everything will be fixed.
I get that impulse. I’ve had it with my own daughter. Last month, she came home from a week of sleepaway camp early because she’d caught a stomach bug, and she wouldn’t talk about how she felt when she got in the car. I asked her if she was sad to leave her friends, if she was mad she missed the end-of-week hike, and she just shrugged and stared out the window. When I went into her room an hour later to grab dirty laundry for the wash, she was sitting on the floor with her sketchbook open, the entire page covered in layer after layer of dark blue and black crayon, with big block letters across the top that said “THIS SUCKS.” She didn’t call me in to look at it, didn’t want to talk about it. She just put the sketchbook away when I walked in, and 20 minutes later she came down and asked for a peanut butter sandwich.
The thing a lot of people don’t get is that big, messy feelings don’t always fit into words for kids. Their brains haven’t developed enough to sort through “I’m humiliated and left out and sick and disappointed” all at once, to pull all that into a sentence an adult can understand. Art isn’t about making something pretty to hang on the fridge. It’s a place to put that messy feeling, so it stops bouncing around inside your chest.
You don’t need a fancy art setup to make this work, either. I tell parents to keep a stack of junk mail (the back of catalogs works perfectly) and a $1 bulk pack of crayons in a low drawer their kid can reach on their own. No need to tell them they have to draw something when they’re upset — just let them know it’s there if they want it. If your kid says they can’t draw, that’s fine too. It doesn’t have to be drawing. Keep a bag of cheap playdough for them to squeeze, or old magazines to rip up, or even a big cardboard box they can color all over with markers. The point isn’t the end product, it’s getting the feeling out.
Another small shift that works: Don’t push them to explain their art right away, and don’t correct it. If your kid draws an all-black page when they’re mad, don’t say “Why don’t you draw a pretty rainbow instead?” That just tells them their bad feeling isn’t okay to have. If they show you what they made, you don’t have to dig for a big explanation. Just say “That looks really heavy” or “That looks like it hurt a lot” and leave it at that. Most of the time, that’s all they need to hear to open up if they want to.
For teachers, I keep a small feelings bin by my classroom door, with just construction paper, crayons, and two packs of playdough. Any kid who comes in upset after recess can head there for 10 minutes before they have to join class. It’s cut down on my office referrals for pushing and yelling by almost half this year.
Leo taped his red monster drawing to his desk for the rest of the week, and the next day he went up to Javi at recess and told him he was sorry for pushing, and they agreed to redo the game after school. It wasn’t a big fix-all, just one small step. I still have a copy of the drawing taped to my desk drawer, actually. It reminds me that we don’t have to get everything out in words to make it better.
Some days it doesn’t work. Last week, a kid in my class threw the whole art bin off the table when he was mad, and my daughter hid in her room for two hours after a bad test and wouldn’t touch her sketchbook. That’s okay. Art isn’t a cure for bad days, and it doesn’t mean kids will never get upset again. It’s just a tool, one that meets them where they are, before they have the words to meet us where we are. Last night, my daughter came home from school with a bad math quiz, scribbled all over the back of an old grocery store circular, crumpled it up, and threw it in the trash. Then she asked if we could watch her favorite show. That was enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Art and Emotional Expression Matter for Kids (And What It Actually Looks Like Everyday)