Why It’s So Hard To Get Parent Survey Responses (And What I’m Changing This Year)
The coffee in my mug has gone lukewarm, the crumbs from my after-school granola bar are stuck to my laptop keyboard, and I’m staring at my Google Forms dashboard. 17 responses. I sent the short survey about after-school homework routines to 92 of my fourth-grade families three weeks ago. 17. That’s less than 20 percent.
I’m working through an action research project for my master’s in elementary education, and the whole point is to adjust my homework policy based on what my specific families need, not what a textbook says works. I know homework is a pain point for a lot of people— I hear it in quick hallway chats, I see the half-finished worksheets coming back on Monday, my own 8-year-old comes home tired from first grade and drags his feet on his own 10 minutes of reading. I don’t want to guess what families need. I want to ask. But I can’t make good changes without enough responses.
I went into the teacher’s lounge the next day and asked around. What’s your typical response rate for parent surveys? One third grade teacher said she’s lucky to get 12 percent for anything that’s not a mandatory permission slip. A special ed teacher said she only ever gets responses from two groups: the parents who email me three times a week anyway, and the parents who are already upset about something and looking for a place to vent. I laughed because that matched my 17 responses perfectly. I had two extremely detailed responses from parents who think homework should be eliminated entirely, 12 from the parents who are already signed up for everything and check every box, and three from people who accidentally opened it and answered the first question then stopped.
Last week I ran into Sarah, one of my students’ moms, at soccer pickup. Her son Jax is in my class, and she works full time as a nurse, so I rarely hear from her unless Jax is out sick. I mentioned the survey offhand, and she slapped her forehead. “Oh my god, I saw that email. It got buried under three bus route updates, a PTA fundraiser request, and a note from the nurse about head lice. I completely forgot. I’m so sorry.” Another parent told me she opened the link while waiting in car pickup, it had 18 questions, and she got through the third one when it was her turn to go, and she never went back.
That’s when I realized I was making all the classic mistakes. I’d taken a sample survey from my master’s program, kept all the extra demographic questions I didn’t actually need, threw a link in a mass email, and expected people to drop everything to fill it out. I was treating the survey like something that was important to me, instead of something that I was asking them to fit into their already overpacked days.
I started making small changes, no extra budget, no extra work really. First, I cut the survey from 18 questions to 7. I got rid of the questions about household income, how many caregivers work full time, and what grade your child was in last year—all stuff I don’t actually need to answer my core question: is my current homework load working for you, and what should I change? The seven questions I kept are all quick: How many nights a week does your child finish my homework? How many minutes does it take on average? Do you think it’s too much, too little, or just right? Would you prefer most homework to be optional, with only one weekly project? It takes less than two minutes to fill out now, instead of 10.
Second, I offered three ways to respond instead of just one. I printed out small paper copies for every kid, with a QR code for people who prefer to do it online right next to it. I added a line that said you can fill out the paper and send it back to school with your kid, or text me your answers one by one if that’s easier than opening a form. A lot of parents text me quick questions anyway, so I figured why not make that an option.
Third, I stopped sending mass reminder emails. Instead, when I reply to a parent’s email about something else— a question about a field trip, a concern about a test grade— I just add one line at the bottom: “If you haven’t had a chance to fill out my 2-minute homework survey yet, here’s the link again, no rush.” That’s way less annoying than a blast email that screams REMINDER: FILL OUT MY SURVEY, and it doesn’t get lost in the clutter of other mass messages.
Finally, I changed my incentive. I’d originally budgeted $25 for one grocery store gift card for a random drawing. I split that into five $5 coffee gift cards instead. Same total cost, just five chances to win instead of one. A lot of people figure they’ll never win the big one, so they don’t bother, but a free coffee feels like a possible win even with long odds.
It’s been a week since I made these changes, and I’m up to 48 responses now. That’s still less than half of my families, but it’s almost triple what I had before, and the responses are way more diverse. I’ve gotten answers from 12 parents who never respond to anything, including three that just texted me their answers in 30 seconds. I’m not going to get 100% response rate, and I’ve made peace with that.
I’m still learning, and still waiting on more responses. I’ll add a quick link to the bottom of my conference sign up email next week, and that’ll probably get me a dozen more. The thing I didn’t expect to learn from this whole process is that asking for input isn’t just about putting a link out there. It’s about making it as easy as possible for people to give it, the same way I make learning tasks fit my students’ needs. It doesn’t matter how much I care about the answer if I’m asking people to jump through 10 hoops to give it to me. No neat ending here, I’m still waiting on more responses, and some families will never fill it out no matter what I do. But this is working a whole lot better than what I was doing before.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why It’s So Hard To Get Parent Survey Responses (And What I’m Changing This Year)