What Happens When A Teacher Mocks A Student: A Personal Story And Lessons For Parents
It was third period 10th grade biology, the air smelled like formaldehyde and burnt microwave popcorn from the teacher’s lounge down the hall. I’d sat in the front row since freshman year, always raised my hand even when I wasn’t 100% sure I had the answer. That day we were going over Punnett squares, and I mixed up dominant and recessive alleles when Mr. Hale called on me. He leaned back against the lab counter, twisted a peppermint in his mouth, and said, loud enough for every single kid in the room to hear, “Honey, did you even open your textbook last night, or were you too busy texting your little boyfriend to remember basic terms?”
The room erupted. I stared at my worksheet, the blue ink blurring under my thumbs, and I didn’t raise my hand again for the rest of the school year. Thirty years later, I still hate him for it.
Last month, my own 10th grader slammed the front door after school, threw her backpack on the couch, and a pile of dirty soccer socks tumbled out onto the rug. She’d just had the same thing happen: her math teacher joked about her mixing up slope and intercept in front of the whole class, after she’d stayed up until 9:30 finishing her study guide the night before. As I handed her a glass of iced tea and sat down next to her, that old tight feeling in my chest came back, the one I’d forgotten I even carried.
I’ve worked as a para in an elementary school for the last eight years, so I know how chaotic classrooms get. I know Mr. Hale wasn’t some cartoon villain. He coached the boys’ varsity soccer team, stayed after school for extra help every Tuesday, and most of my classmates thought he was the best teacher in the school. He was tired that day, probably, trying to corral a room of overheated 10th graders who’d checked out for spring break, and a throwaway joke to get the class on his side felt easier than just saying “close, try again” and moving on. He forgot about it by lunch. I didn’t.
A lot of parents I know jump one of two ways when their kid comes home with this story: they either rush to email the principal and demand the teacher be disciplined before their kid has even finished talking, or they brush it off and say “it’s just a joke, don’t be so sensitive, you need thick skin for the real world.” I didn’t do either. First, I just said, “That’s so embarrassing. I’d be furious too. I still remember exactly how that feels from when I was your age.” I didn’t offer a solution right away. We sat there for 10 minutes while she ranted and ate half a bag of chocolate chips, and that was enough for her to stop crying.
After she calmed down, I asked her one simple question: “What do you want to happen here?” So many adults assume they know what’s best for a kid in this situation, but giving them control back when they’ve just been embarrassed in public matters more than anything we can do on our own. She said she didn’t want a big parent-teacher conference, she didn’t want the teacher to get in trouble, she just didn’t want it to happen again. So we worked on a short note together, right there at the kitchen table. We didn’t write anything angry. We wrote: “Hi Mr. Torres, When you made the joke about my formula mix-up yesterday, I felt really embarrassed in front of the whole class. I work really hard in math, and I’d appreciate it if you could correct me quietly after class next time I get something wrong.” That’s it. He wrote back an hour later, apologized, said he’d been frustrated with how noisy the class was that day and it slipped out, and it hasn’t happened again.
For teachers who might read this, the lesson is simple and easy to put into practice. If you need to correct a student, especially one who already works hard and gets nervous speaking up, do it quietly. Pull them aside after class, write a note on their paper, lean in and whisper the correction instead of calling it out for the whole room to hear. If you slip up and say something you shouldn’t, apologize right away. It takes 10 seconds to say “that was out of line, I’m sorry” after class, and that’s enough to keep that kid from carrying your offhand comment around for 30 years. I can’t count how many times I’ve seen a throwaway comment from a teacher turn a kid who loves raising their hand into a kid who never speaks up again, just to avoid being wrong in public.
For parents, the first step is just don’t dismiss the feeling. Don’t start with “what did you do to deserve that?” or “maybe you misunderstood.” Your kid is already raw and embarrassed, and that kind of reaction just tells them they can’t come to you next time something bad happens. After you validate how they feel, let them lead the next step, don’t force a big confrontation they don’t want.
I still don’t lose sleep over Mr. Hale. I don’t look him up on social media to tell him off, I don’t bring him up at dinner parties. That doesn’t mean the feeling goes away. Every time I raise my hand in a staff meeting, or admit I don’t know something at a parent-teacher conference, that little flutter is still there, right in my chest: what if I’m wrong, what if everyone laughs. I hate that it’s still there. I hate him for putting it there.
I’m glad I didn’t brush my daughter’s feelings off, glad we didn’t rush to escalate something she didn’t want escalated. It doesn’t fix every bad thing that happens at school, and it doesn’t erase the things that happened to me when I was her age. But it’s something. It’s enough for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When A Teacher Mocks A Student: A Personal Story And Lessons For Parents