What Is the Best Way for Kids to Learn and Read? Tips From a Third Grade Teacher
Last month, I sat across from Mia’s mom at a fall parent-teacher conference, watching her twist the lid of a travel coffee mug until her knuckles turned white. She pulled out a printed spreadsheet of reading app progress, a list of leveled readers we’d sent home, and sighed. “We do 20 minutes every single night after homework. No exceptions. She still says she hates reading, and half the time she can’t tell me what happened on the page she just finished. What’s the best way to actually get her to learn and read like she’s supposed to?”
I pulled my stack of student work toward me, flipped past Mia’s neatly typed assigned persuasive essay about why we should have more recess, and stopped at the messy, doodle-covered back pages of her journal. “Have you seen this?” I said. Mia had written three whole paragraphs about her hamster, Mr. Nibbles, escaping his cage over the weekend. She detailed how he’d chewed through the corner of her backpack, eaten half of her chocolate chip granola bar, and hidden behind the TV for two hours. There was a little pencil drawing of him peeking out from behind a couch leg, a sunflower seed in his mouth.
Her mom blinked. “She wrote that? I thought that was just doodling. That’s not real reading or learning, though, right? I thought it had to be the books that match her level.”
That’s the question I get every single week from parents. After 12 years teaching third grade, I’ve had every version of it: what program works best, what curriculum should I buy, what books do I make them read to get them caught up. A few years ago, I would have pulled out my go-to list of recommendations. Now, I just show them what I showed Mia’s mom: the messy, unassigned stuff their kids are already doing when they don’t think anyone’s watching.
I had this exact moment with my own son last year. He was in fourth grade, and his teacher sent home a note saying he needed to read more chapter books to hit his end-of-year goal. For a month, I pushed him to pick a “real” book from the school reading list. He’d sit with it for 20 minutes, stare at the page, and tell me he was done. Then I noticed he’d spend 30 minutes every night after that poring over the back of his Pokemon trading cards, memorizing stats, and re-reading the 20-page rule book for his new Lego set over and over to figure out how to modify a spaceship. I caught myself getting ready to tell him that wasn’t “real reading,” until I realized he was reading more, more fluently, than he ever had with the assigned chapter book. He just didn’t care about the story of the kid who went to summer camp. He cared about Pokemon and Lego.
That’s the insight I’ve slowly picked up over the years: the best way to learn and read isn’t about sticking to a strict method or matching a predetermined level. It’s about leaning into what your kid already cares about, and giving them space to practice that skill on their own terms. There are a few small, concrete things I tell parents to try that don’t cost any money and take almost no extra time.
First, stop policing what counts as reading. Let them read the “junk.” Next time you go to the library, let them pick any three books they want, even if all three are silly graphic novels about farts, even if they’re well below the reading level the school listed for them. Don’t make them swap one for a “more challenging” book to “build skills.” If your kid only wants to read fan fiction about their favorite YouTube creator, that’s fine. If they only want to read cereal boxes at breakfast, that’s still reading. The point isn’t what they read at first. It’s that they build the habit of picking up something to read because they want to, not because they have to.
Second, put down the reading log and stop quizzing. I know many schools require reading logs, but if you can get away with it, stop forcing 20 minutes of quiet reading with a book they hate. If you have to turn in a log, let them count the time they spend reading trading cards or comic books. And after they read, don’t ask them “what was the main idea” or “what did you learn.” That feels like a test, and it turns reading into a chore. Instead, ask one simple question: “what part was the most fun?” That’s low pressure, and it gets them talking about what they read without making them feel judged. Mia’s mom told me after the conference she’d been quizzing Mia on comprehension after every reading session, just to make sure she was paying attention. She swapped the quiz for that one question, and within a week Mia was volunteering whole stories about what she’d read, instead of giving one-word answers.
Third, leave interesting stuff around the house. Instead of shoving all of your kid’s favorite reading material in their bedroom, leave a stack of comic books next to the couch, keep the hamster care book on the kitchen table, leave the instruction manual next to their new Lego set. Kids pick up stuff to read when they’re waiting for dinner to cook or for you to finish a work call, far more often than they’ll go out of their way to get a book from their room for assigned reading.
A couple weeks after the conference, Mia’s mom sent me a quick email. Mia had read the entire hamster care book she picked up from the library, and written four more entries in her journal about Mr. Nibbles’ new cage mate. She still stumbles over big words sometimes, and she still hasn’t read the leveled chapter book we sent home for the month. But last week I saw her at recess, sitting on the bench, showing her new journal pages to her best friend, pointing out the parts that made her laugh.
I still don’t have a magic answer for parents who ask me what the best way is. There’s no program that works for every kid, no set of books that fits every interest. What I do know is that learning and reading stick when they’re tied to something the kid actually cares about, not just a progress chart or a test score. Some days, my son still only reads trading cards and building instructions. Some days, he doesn’t read anything at all after school, he just plays outside. That’s okay. It’s not a perfect system, and it doesn’t always move the needle as fast as we want it to. But it’s the best thing I’ve found, after 12 years in the classroom and 10 years as a mom, to help kids actually want to learn and read.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Is the Best Way for Kids to Learn and Read