How To Approach A Child Who Refuses To Join Group Activities: Tips From A Classroom Aide
The glitter was already stuck to my jeans and the apple cider was starting to steam over onto the art table when Mia’s mom pulled me aside before our first grade fall harvest party. She twisted the strap of her diaper bag (she’d brought it even though Mia’s little brother was at daycare that day) and leaned in, voice quiet enough that Mia, who was already curled up in the reading nook hugging her fox, couldn’t hear. “How do I approach this?” she said. “I keep going back and forth. If I force her to join, she cries. If I let her sit out, I’m scared she’ll never get used to it.”
I’ve been a part-time classroom aide at this school for six years, and I get this question at least once a semester. Most of the time, the parents have already tried everything: bribes with new toys, pre-practicing group games at home, pulling their kid out of events early when they get upset, pushing them through even when they’re wiping tears on their sleeve. Mia’s mom told me she’d spent 20 minutes in the car that morning talking about how fun the pumpkin relay would be, and Mia had just stared out the window and said nothing.
I nodded, told her I’d check in, and went back to setting out googly eyes. I didn’t go over to Mia right away. I helped a kid unstick his sleeve from a glue bottle, refilled the paper towel roll, laughed when another kid dropped his mini pumpkin and it rolled under the bookshelf. When things settled a little, I grabbed an extra glue stick and walked over to the reading nook, sat down on the stained bean bag (I spilled my oat latte there back in September, no one’s bothered to clean it) next to her. I didn’t say “Why aren’t you playing with the other kids?” I just nodded at the fox in her lap and said “His fur looks really soft. What’s his name?”
She mumbled something so quiet I almost missed it. “Finn,” I repeated back. She nodded. “I used to hide in the bathroom during middle school dances,” I told her. She looked up at me, surprised. “I hated everyone looking at me. I’d stay in there until my friend banged on the door to tell me the slow dance was over.” She smiled a little, just the corner of her mouth.
The pumpkin relay was starting, teams lined up on either side of the table. I said “My team is missing one person right now, but we don’t need anyone to run with the pumpkin. Do you think Finn would be our good luck mascot? You can stand right at the back with me, and you don’t have to do anything except hold him. If you hate it, we can come right back here and read picture books, no problem.” She thought about it for 30 seconds, squeezing Finn’s paw, then stood up.
We stood at the back of the line. She never yelled, never moved up to take her turn, but when our team’s runner dropped the glitter glue, she leaned forward a little. When we won, one of the boys on our team turned around and high-fived me, then accidentally high-fived her shoulder. She didn’t flinch. She just smiled.
After school, Mia’s mom pulled me aside again, curious. She said she’d been so used to either forcing Mia to join or letting her sit out entirely that she’d never thought of the middle ground. That’s the thing no one tells you when your kid is the one sitting in the corner: it doesn’t have to be all or nothing. Most people either think you have to push past anxiety to “fix” it, or you have to protect your kid from all stress forever. But the middle is where the good stuff happens.
I don’t go around labeling kids “shy” in front of other people, first off. Putting that label on them in front of their peers just gives them a reason to stay that way. Second, I never put them on the spot by asking them to explain why they don’t want to join in front of a group. That just makes them dig in. If I’m going to ask, it’s one on one, later, when no one’s listening. Third, the role you give them doesn’t have to be big. It can be mascot, it can be the person who holds the team’s water bottle, it can be the person who counts how many points everyone got. It just gets them in the space, without the pressure of performing. And I don’t make a big deal out of it when they agree. I don’t gush about how brave they are, because that just tells them the thing they did was actually really scary, and now they should be scared next time too. I just act like it’s normal.
It’s been a month and a half since the harvest party. Mia still doesn’t join every game. Last week, when we did the class turkey trot, she walked the last lap with me instead of running with the other kids, and that was okay. She’s painting the backdrop for our class play next month, instead of having a speaking part, and she’s already drawn three little foxes in the corner of the paper. She sits with two other girls at lunch now, and they pass her goldfish crackers when she forgets her snack.
Last night, I got a text from her mom. It was a photo of Mia and the little girl from down the street sitting at their kitchen table doing a puzzle. The text said, “She asked to invite her over. I didn’t push. I still don’t know if I’m doing this right. Half the time I think I’m pushing too hard, half the time I think I’m not pushing enough.”
I texted her back what I tell every parent who asks me that original question: that question you’re asking, “How do I approach this?” that’s just part of it. No one gets it right every time. Right now, Mia’s doing fine. She’s not fixed, she doesn’t have to be. We’re just taking it one small step at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How To Approach A Child Who Refuses To Join Group Activities: Tips From A Classroom Aide