11 Year Old Girl Shutting Down: What I Noticed And What’s Actually Working
Last weekend’s family barbecue smelled like charred hamburgers and citronella, and I was squeezing past the pantry to reach the lemonade dispenser when I saw her. Lila, my 11-year-old cousin, was curled up on the floor between the cereal boxes and extra paper plates, thumb scrolling mindlessly on her phone. The Minecraft sticker on her case was peeling at the corners, the same one she got for her birthday two years ago. Outside, the other kids her age were yelling over a cornhole game, and my aunt had just been asking where she’d run off to.
I didn’t call her out or tell her to go outside. I just grabbed my lemonade and nodded, and she gave me a tiny, tight smile before looking back at her screen. Ten minutes later, when her mom pulled me aside, she just shook her head and said she’s “just being a preteen.” “All they do is hide on their phones now, right?” she said. “I took her phone away for three days last month and she didn’t speak to any of us the whole time. Must just be screen addiction.”
But I’ve taught 4th grade for 8 years, and I see this a step before the preteen moodiness everyone talks about. Lila wasn’t always this quiet. Two years ago, she’d show up to every family gathering with a bag of face paint and beg every adult to let her give them a unicorn makeover. She’d do cartwheels across the lawn and stay up late telling me terrible jokes. Over the last year, she’s pulled back more and more. She turned down my invitation to a craft fair last fall, said she was busy. Her grades dropped from straight A’s to a C in math and B’s across the board. No one was asking the right questions, everyone was just writing her off as moody.
I talked her into going to the bookstore with me a month ago, told her I’d buy her any graphic novel she wanted and spring for a vanilla milkshake with extra sprinkles after. She said yes, which surprised me. We sat in my car in the parking lot after, eating our milkshakes, and I didn’t jump in with questions. I just mentioned that I’d seen her new horse drawings she’d posted to her finsta, and I thought they were really good. That’s when she started picking at the label on her cup, and the whole thing came out.
All the girls in her grade started doing fit checks after school, talking about which boys liked who, and making fun of anyone who still cared about stuff that’s “for little kids.” She still likes drawing original characters, playing Roblox with her cousin who lives in Canada, and collecting stuffed animals. One girl called her cringe for drawing in her notebook during free period last month, and the whole table laughed. After that, she stopped raising her hand in class, stopped bringing her sketchbook to school, stopped wanting to hang out with anyone from her class. “I just don’t want anyone to make fun of me anymore,” she said. Sprinkles fell off her milkshake onto my dashboard, and she didn’t even brush them off.
That’s the thing no one tells you when your preteen starts pulling away: 9 times out of 10, it’s not just moodiness or screen addiction. It’s that they got stung for liking the wrong thing, and they’re hiding to protect themselves. The usual advice people give — “just ignore them,” “don’t care what others think” — is useless. It doesn’t fix the feeling that you’re wrong for liking what you like.
Instead of telling her she needed to change or make new friends at school, we started small. First, I told her I’d keep my guest room art table open every Friday after school. She can come over, draw, order whatever takeout she wants, and no one will bother her. I don’t push her to talk if she doesn’t want to. Sometimes we just sit and draw for two hours and that’s it. That’s low pressure, no big speech required.
Next, we went to her parent-teacher conference together, and I helped ask for a specific small adjustment instead of a generic “please watch out for her.” We asked her math teacher to call on her for visual problems, like graphing and geometry, because she’s good at that kind of thinking and it would give her a small win every week. It sounds tiny, but after three weeks, she came home and told me she got a problem right in front of the whole class, and no one laughed. That’s the kind of small win that builds confidence back up, way better than any lecture about being more outgoing.
Then, instead of forcing her to hang out with the “nice girls” in her neighborhood that her mom kept pushing, we signed her up for a teen drawing club at the local community center. It’s for kids 10 to 14, and none of them go to her school, so there’s no existing social drama to deal with. She went for the first time last week, and when she got home she texted me a picture of a drawing she made with another girl there who also loves horse original characters.
It’s not all fixed. She still hides in the pantry at big family barbecues. She still gets a C sometimes in math. Her mom still gets frustrated sometimes, says she wishes Lila would just be “more social.” I have to remind her that forcing a kid to be someone they’re not just to fit other people’s ideas of normal doesn’t help anyone. We don’t need her to be the loud, cartwheeling kid she was a few years ago if that’s not who she is anymore.
Last Friday, she showed up at my door with five new drawings and a request to watch the old High School Musical movie I told her I still love. We ate cold fries off paper plates, and she laughed so hard at the cheesy choreography she snort-laughed. That’s the most I’ve seen her relax in over a year. We don’t know what next month will bring, if the girls at school will be nicer or if she’ll still want to hide away some days. But that’s okay. We’re not rushing to fix anything. We’re just showing up, one drawing session and one milkshake at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » 11 Year Old Girl Shutting Down: What I Noticed And What’s Actually Working