Why Is My 11 Year Old Girl Suddenly Withdrawn? What I’ve Learned As A Caregiver
Last weekend, I was manning the grill at my grandma’s annual summer barbecue, flipping hot dogs and brushing burnt marshmallow crumbs off my apron, when I noticed Lila on the front porch. Lila’s my 11-year-old cousin, and for as long as I can remember, she’s been the first kid to crowd the grill, begging for an extra sausage and sneaking extra graham crackers for s’mores. This year, she was curled up on the top step, knees pulled to her chest, phone held so close to her face it nearly touched her nose. No one else was with her. I grabbed two cold lemonades from the cooler and walked over, set one down beside her. She mumbled thanks without looking up. I asked what she was binging, and she pulled the phone a little closer, like she was hiding it from me. “Nothing,” she said.
It’s been four months since her parents split up, she moved across town, changed schools, and her mom picked up two jobs to cover the rent. I see Lila every Wednesday night, when my aunt works her evening shift at the hospital, so I’ve watched the shift happen slow, not all at once. She used to drag her beat-up sketchbook everywhere, showing me every new drawing of fantasy characters she’d made, begging me to tape them to my fridge. Three months ago, she stopped bringing it. A month after that, she ducked into a fitting room when we saw a girl from her new math class at the mall, and wouldn’t come out for 10 minutes. My aunt keeps saying she’s “just being a preteen,” that all 11-year-old girls get moody and quiet, that she just needs time to adjust. I get it—my aunt is exhausted, she’s barely keeping her head above water right now. But it’s hard to watch, and I’ve been worried for months.
One Wednesday night a few weeks back, I was folding laundry in the living room while Lila stared at a reality show she wasn’t really watching. I mentioned I’d found an old sketchbook in the back of my closet when I was cleaning, and asked if she wanted it. She shrugged, said “It doesn’t matter, my drawings are stupid anyway.” I sat down on the other end of the couch, didn’t push, just said “When did you decide that? You used to draw those really cool pirate mermaids that were way better than anything I could draw.” She was quiet for so long I thought she wasn’t going to answer. Then she tucked her feet under her and said a group of girls in her new art class found her sketchbook on the floor a couple weeks after school started. They flipped through it, laughed, and said all her characters were ugly and weird. She hasn’t drawn anything since.
My first instinct was to get mad. I wanted to text the principal, call their parents, march up to the school and say something. But then I remembered when I was 11, a girl spread a rumor about me, and my mom called her mom to fix it. It just made everything worse—everyone called me a baby who couldn’t handle her own problems, and the bullying got worse. So I didn’t offer to fix it that night. Instead I said, “That sounds so humiliating. I’d want to hide my stuff too if that happened to me. Do you want to figure out what to do about it together, or do you just want me to listen?” She said she just wanted me to listen. That was it, that was all we talked about that night.
I’ve learned a few small, concrete things these past few months that I wish more people knew when they’re worried about a quiet 11-year-old. First, skip the big “we need to talk” sit-down. If you corner a preteen and ask them to spill all their feelings right that second, they’ll shut down. I stopped asking “how was school” every time I pick her up, because that always gets “fine” as an answer. Instead, I bring up tiny, low-stakes things that don’t feel like an interrogation. I’ll point out a weird billboard we pass, or mention a dumb TikTok I saw that day, or ask her what sound she thinks a cloud would make if it could bark. Stupid, small stuff that doesn’t have a right or wrong answer, and doesn’t make her feel like she’s being grilled.
Second, don’t make them comfort you. When I first started worrying, I almost said something like “I’m so worried about you, you never talk anymore.” But that puts the kid in the position of having to make you feel better, which they won’t do. Instead, I just create low-pressure space that doesn’t require anything from her. I left that blank sketchbook I mentioned on my coffee table for two weeks, didn’t say a word about it. One night I went to get a glass of water after my shower, and she was drawing in it at the dining table, and she didn’t even shut it when I walked in. I keep a pack of her favorite sour candy in the pantry, I leave the TV on whatever channel she wants, I don’t make her hang out with the rest of the family at barbecues if she doesn’t want to. It doesn’t cost anything, and it doesn’t take a lot of extra time, even if you’re busy like my aunt.
Last weekend, after that porch moment, she wandered over to where I was cleaning up and showed me the drawing she’d finished in my sketchbook. It’s that same three-eyed purple-haired mermaid she used to draw all the time when she was 8, and she added glitter to the tail. She said “it’s still kind of stupid,” but she smiled when she said it.
Things aren’t fixed. She’s still the new kid, her mom still works most nights, she still spends most of family gatherings on her phone, and she hasn’t said anything about going back to bringing her sketchbook to school. I still worry about her, some days more than others. But it’s easier now. I don’t think you have to fix every hard thing an 11-year-old goes through, anyway. You just have to leave the sketchbook out, bring the lemonade, and wait for them to be ready to share when they are.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Is My 11 Year Old Girl Suddenly Withdrawn