What to Do When You Have No Clue Why Your Kid’s Behavior Suddenly Changed
Last Tuesday, I stood at the kitchen sink unloading the dishwasher, a half-eaten granola bar of my own sticking to the counter, when Milo dropped his backpack by the door and kicked the trash can so hard a crumpled juice box rolled out onto the floor. He’d been talking about his 5th grade cave tour field trip for 12 days straight, had begged me to pack extra gummy bears and help him make a sign for his hiking group the night before. Now he crumpled the neon “I Survived Cave Tour” sticker he’d come home with and threw it at the fridge.
I held a wet ceramic dinner plate mid-air, and my first thought, the one I didn’t say out loud, was HELP ME TF OUT WHAT DO I DO.
This wasn’t the tantrums I’d navigated when he was four, when he’d scream because his toast was the wrong shape and I’d know exactly what we were dealing with. Milo was 10, he’d gone almost a full year without blowing up like this out of nowhere. Two weeks prior, he’d twisted his ankle at recess and gotten a walking boot, and that’s when the weird behavior started. One night he refused to go to soccer practice he’d played for three years, just sat on the entryway floor and wouldn’t move, no explanation. Last Sunday he cried for 15 minutes because I bought the wrong brand of chocolate milk. I’d texted three other parents, scrolled three different parenting blogs at 11pm, and all I got was vague stuff about “checking in” that didn’t help when I was standing there staring at a crumpled sticker and a kid who wouldn’t speak.
My first instinct that Tuesday was to snap back. I was behind on work, I’d forgotten his favorite sour gummy bears that morning because my boss had called an emergency meeting, and I already felt guilty about the boot thing because I’d told him he was fine to run at recess two days before it happened. I almost said “what is wrong with you” or “can you stop being dramatic” or “you were so excited for this trip, what is your problem”. But I remembered what my sister, a 4th grade teacher, had texted me the night before when I’d sent her a panicky voice note: when you have no clue what’s going on, stop trying to fix it before they’re ready.
I put the plate down on the counter, wiped my wet hands on my jeans, and said the only thing she told me to try that didn’t feel stupid: “This feels really awful right now, doesn’t it?”
He stared at me for a second, shoulders hunched up to his ears, and then nodded and started crying. I didn’t move closer, didn’t push him to hug me, didn’t ask what was wrong. I just leaned against the counter and waited, while he cried and kicked the trash can one more soft time. After about five minutes, he mumbled that the tour guide had made fun of his boot when he couldn’t keep up, that all the other kids laughed, and he didn’t want to say anything because it was stupid to be upset over a joke.
That’s when it clicked. All the times I’d been panicking, thinking I was missing some big developmental thing or that he was being bullied at school or something terrible was going on, it was just a small, embarrassing thing he couldn’t figure out how to say out loud. He was 10, he didn’t want to tell his mom that a grown up made fun of him and it hurt. He just knew everything felt bad, so he kicked the trash can.
I’ve tried a few specific things since then that have worked way better than panicking and pushing for answers. First, I stopped asking “what’s wrong” the second an outburst hits. When someone’s that upset, their brain can’t even put the answer into words, so asking just makes them shut down more. Instead, I just name the feeling out loud, plain and simple: “That’s really frustrating”, “You look really hurt right now”, “This whole thing sucks”. No follow up questions, no demand for explanation. Just that.
Second, when we’re both calm, I ask about tiny details instead of pushing for big feelings. The day after the field trip, we were sitting on the couch eating microwave popcorn watching that old Lego cartoon he likes, and I said “what was the most boring part of the tour, anyway?” instead of “are you still upset about what that guide said?” That low pressure opening let him bring up the joke again on his own, and we talked about how even stupid jokes can hurt, and it’s not silly to be upset about it.
Third, if he still doesn’t want to talk, I leave a tiny, low-stakes opening instead of making it a big thing. Last week, when he threw his cleats in the backyard and wouldn’t come to dinner, I just picked them up, put them by the back door, and slipped a sticky note that said “I’m here if you want to talk” on the fridge. I didn’t mention it again. An hour later, he came downstairs and told me the team was moving up a division, and he was scared he’d be the worst because he missed two weeks of practice with his ankle.
It’s not like this fixes everything. I still have moments, like last night when he crumpled up his math homework and refused to finish it, where I stand there and still think HELP ME TF OUT WHAT DO I DO. I still snap sometimes, yesterday I said “can you just cut it out” when he was dragging his feet getting ready for school, and I apologized later, that’s all. We don’t have big heart to hearts every week, and some days he still doesn’t tell me what’s wrong. But that’s okay, it turns out.
I used to think when my kid was acting out I needed to have the answer right away, that I needed to fix it immediately or I was doing something wrong. Now I know most of the time when I’m that confused, it just means they need a minute to be upset before they can tell me what’s wrong. I just wait, name the feeling, and keep the door open. That’s enough, more than enough, most days.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What to Do When You Have No Clue Why Your Kid’s Behavior Suddenly Changed