What an 8th Grade Social Studies Teacher Gave My Kid At the End of the Year – And What It Taught Me About Parenting Teens
Last month, the day after my daughter Lila finished 8th grade, she dragged her overstuffed backpack into the kitchen and upended it on the tile counter. Out rolled a half-eaten blueberry granola bar, a crumpled pack of gum, 12 dead ballpoint pens, and a stack of old quizzes and art projects I immediately started sorting for recycling. Halfway through the pile, I hit a folded cream-colored envelope, labeled in blue sharpie: For Lila, From Mr. Henderson.
Lila leaned against the fridge, dripping cherry popsicle juice on the floor, and said it was something he put together for every kid at the end of the year, each one different. No generic holiday card, no mass-produced certificate. I opened it to find a single sheet of notebook paper, with a handwritten line at the top and 8 numbered points below. It read: “You asked 117 questions this year that weren’t in the lesson plan. That’s not a bug. That’s the point of social studies.” The points that followed were specific to her: When you think the textbook is wrong, say it. Just bring one piece of evidence to back it up – that’s all anyone needs to ask of you. High school teachers will tell you to stick to the prompt. That doesn’t mean you can’t write your real answer in the margin, for you. Your habit of jumping into conversations before people finish talking isn’t rudeness – it’s excitement. Just remember to pause 2 seconds after someone stops talking before you speak. I do it too.
I remembered fall parent-teacher conferences that year. I’d pulled Mr. Henderson aside after our scheduled 10 minutes, because I’d heard the same note from multiple other teachers: Lila was disruptive, she talked over peers, she pushed back too hard on assignments. I told him I was worried her habit of rocking the boat would get her in trouble in high school, where teachers have 150 kids and don’t have time for extra questions. He leaned against the cinder block wall, crossed his arms, and said “I get why you’d worry. But I’ve been teaching 22 years, and the kids who change things later are the ones who don’t know how to stop asking the questions no one else is asking. I’m not here to fix that. I’m just here to teach her how to do it nicely.” I nodded at the time, but I didn’t really believe him. I’d spent the previous three years hearing that Lila’s biggest strengths were also her biggest problems, so that’s how I thought of them too.
I sat at the kitchen counter reading that note over twice while Lila wandered off to text her friends about summer plans. Later that night, when I was helping her clear out her desk, I noticed she taped that note to the inside cover of the bullet journal she’s using for high school. She didn’t say anything about it, just smoothed down the edge and closed the book. That’s how she is – she doesn’t gush about things that matter, just holds onto them quiet.
A lot of parents I talk to are in the same spot I was, right? We’re so focused on preparing our kids for the next step – getting into good high school classes, getting good grades, getting into college – that we default to asking them to shrink the parts of themselves that don’t fit the standard boxes. The kid who talks too much gets told to be quiet. The kid who questions the rules gets told to follow them. It’s not that we’re mean, it’s that we’re scared for them. We think if they don’t fit in, they’ll fail, they’ll miss out, they’ll struggle.
But what Mr. Henderson did, which took 15 minutes of his time after school, changed how I do this, and it’s not some big fancy parenting overhaul. The first change I made was swapping out my usual go-to advice. Instead of saying “don’t rock the boat” or “stick to the prompt to get a good grade,” I have two specific questions I ask now when Lila comes home upset about an assignment or a conversation at school: “What do you actually want to say?” and “Do you have one small piece of evidence to back it up?” That’s it. It doesn’t tell her to back down, it doesn’t tell her to be someone she’s not, it just gives her a small, clear guardrail that helps her do the thing she’s already inclined to do, just more thoughtfully.
Another thing: I stopped making grade the first thing I ask about when she brings home a paper. Before, it was “What grade did you get?” Now it’s “What did you write that you cared about?” Last week she brought home a practice essay she wrote for her summer high school prep class, and she got a B- because she went off topic to talk about how the prompt ignored the role of Black women in the civil rights movement. Instead of telling her she should have stuck to the prompt to get a better grade, I asked her to read me the part she added. It was good, it was thoughtful, and I told her that. She still got the B-, but she didn’t walk away feeling like she did the wrong thing by saying what she thought.
For teachers who might read this, the takeaway is even simpler. You don’t need a big end-of-year program or an expensive gift for every kid. Just sit down for 10 minutes per kid at the end of the year, and write down one specific thing you noticed about them that doesn’t show up on a report card. It doesn’t have to be fancy, it just has to be true. Most kids have never had an adult name that thing they do that they think is a flaw, and call it a strength. That sticks with them way longer than any “student of the month” certificate.
I still slip up, honestly. Last week at Lila’s freshman orientation, she pulled me aside after the tour and told me she’d asked the principal why none of the plaques on the wall honor any of the Black or Latinx alumni who went to the school before 1990. My first reaction was to tense up, and I almost said “Well, maybe that’s a fight for another day.” But I caught myself, and instead I asked “What did he say?” She said he told her no one had ever asked that, and he wants her to join the committee that’s updating the hallway next semester. We still don’t know how that’s going to go. She might get frustrated, she might learn that changing things takes longer than she thinks, she might get a bad grade somewhere along the way for asking the wrong question at the wrong time. But that’s okay. Mr. Henderson didn’t give her a guarantee that everything would work out. He just gave her permission to be exactly who she already is. That’s more than any end-of-year gift could ever be.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What an 8th Grade Social Studies Teacher Gave My Kid At the End of the Year – And What It Taught Me About Parenting Teens