Why Does My Child Talk About The Same Thing Over And Over? Tips For Repetitive Or Obsessive Kid Conversations
Last Tuesday, I was carpooling my 7-year-old son Leo and his friend from soccer practice, heading to the frozen yogurt shop for post-practice treats. Halfway through the roundabout by the mall, Leo leaned forward between the seats and started in: “Did you know axolotls can regrow their own spinal cords? Did you know that? Do you think if an axolotl lost its whole head it could grow a new one? What do you think that would feel like? Do axolotls remember who they are after they regrow a limb?”
I glanced in the rearview. Leo’s friend was staring hard at a cow grazing in the field off the highway, his headphones dangling around his neck, not answering. I’d answered every single one of these questions at least 10 times in the previous week. My jaw tightened. I’d already snapped at him three times that morning for bringing up axolotls during breakfast. For a second I wanted to pull over and tell him to pick a new topic, already.
This is the thing no one warns you about when you have a kid who gets stuck on obsessive, repetitive conversations. One minute you’re a patient, cool parent, the next you’re counting how many times they’ve mentioned dinosaur teeth or robot vacuum cleaners that day, and you’re this close to losing it. I spent months panicking that something was wrong with Leo. I’d Google “obsessive conversations in children” at 10 p.m. after he fell asleep, reading all the worst case scenarios, wondering if I should push for an evaluation right away.
I brought it up at his well-child check last fall, and then talked it over with his first grade teacher, who has 12 years of experience with kids this age. Both of them told me the same thing: this is way more common than you think. For most kids, repetitive conversations aren’t a sign of a big problem. It’s just how a developing brain works. Sometimes a fact or an idea is so new, so big and interesting, that the brain can’t let go of it. It’s like getting a song stuck in your head, except you have to say every thought you have about it out loud, right now. Sometimes it’s anxiety: when Leo started first grade, he spent three weeks talking nonstop about school bus safety rules, because that was the one thing he could wrap his head around in a whole new scary routine. It was his way of feeling in control.
I stopped shushing him cold turkey after that, and tried the small tricks both the doctor and teacher suggested, and I was surprised how fast things shifted. The first thing that worked was acknowledging the topic first before redirecting, instead of just shutting it down. I used to say “We’ve talked about this already, can we talk about something else?” which just made Leo more determined to get his question out, because he thought he wouldn’t get another chance. Now I use a specific line: “That’s such a cool question about axolotls. Right now we’re talking about what topping Mia wants on her frozen yogurt. After dinner, we’re going to have 10 whole minutes to talk all about axolotl regrowth, okay?” It sounds simple, but it works. He knows the conversation isn’t going away, so he doesn’t have to squeeze it in right this second.
The second trick is actually keeping that promise. I carve out that dedicated 10 minutes every day when he’s stuck on a topic. Sometimes we look up videos, sometimes we draw pictures, sometimes we just go through all his questions one by one. When Leo was stuck on axolotls, we even drove to the local pet store to look at the two axolotls they keep in a tank by the reptile section. After about a week and a half, he started running out of new questions. The 10 minute chats got shorter, and then one day he didn’t even mention it, because he’d processed the whole thing, and his brain was ready to move on to the next thing (currently it’s 4.5 billion-year-old space rocks that fall to Earth. Go figure).
His teacher told me she uses a similar trick in the classroom. If a kid is stuck on a topic and keeps bringing it up during math, she lets them keep a small drawing or note about the topic in their desk, and they get to share it during the last two minutes of circle time that day. That way they get their turn, and they don’t interrupt the whole lesson to get it out. It works way better than scolding them for being rude. If a topic sticks around for months and starts getting in the way of school or friendships, that’s when it makes sense to talk to a doctor or therapist, but that’s pretty rare for most kids.
Of course, it doesn’t always go perfectly. Last week, Leo interrupted the children’s librarian during story time to ask if the salamander in the picture book was a close cousin to axolotls. I wanted to sink into the carpet. But the librarian just smiled and said “Great question, we’ll talk about that right after we finish the story” and that was that. I still get embarrassed sometimes, when we’re at a dinner party and he brings up asteroid craters to someone who just wanted to talk about the weather.
It’s not a problem that’s fixed forever. Every few months there’s a new topic, some new set of repetitive questions that follow us to the grocery store, the playground, the car. But it’s not the crisis I thought it was when I first started panicking and scrolling through search results at 10 p.m. Most days, the specific, small steps work, and it’s just another weird, predictable part of raising my kid. Some days, I even find myself learning something new about axolotls, or space rocks, that I never would have known if he hadn’t asked me the same question 15 times.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Does My Child Talk About The Same Thing Over And Over