What Happens When Schools Turn Off Personal Device WiFi: A Teacher’s Perspective
Last Wednesday, I stood at the front of my 5th grade classroom, eraser still in hand from writing the day’s research project prompt on the whiteboard, when the first hand went up. “Ms. Henderson, my WiFi’s gone,” Javi called from the back row. Half a dozen more hands popped up before he finished talking. I pulled my teacher laptop closer, clicked the network menu, and our school WiFi was still there, working fine for me. I walked over to Lila’s desk, where she’d pulled up the settings on her personal iPad Pro, and sure enough—our school’s guest network didn’t even show up as an option. A kid behind me muttered, “How did the school even turn it off?” and I had the exact same question.
I grabbed my chipped ceramic coffee mug on the way down to the tech office after class, and found Dave, our head tech, sorting charging cords at his front desk, a half-eaten bag of peanut M&ms next to his keyboard. I asked him what the change was about, and he leaned back in his rolling chair and pulled up a dashboard on his monitor. The numbers didn’t lie: over the previous three months, 76% of the traffic on the guest network (the one open to personal student devices) came from social media and game sites, not educational tools. Admin had spent three months talking about it, he said, and finally voted to cut access entirely, only leaving it open for pre-approved devices.
I left the office frustrated. I’d been letting kids use their own laptops and tablets for four years, for a lot of good reasons. Javi types twice as fast on the gaming laptop his older brother gave him than he does on our clunky 7-year-old school Chromebooks. Lila uses a text-to-speech app on her iPad that doesn’t work properly on school devices because of outdated operating software. Jake, whose dad bought him a lightweight laptop for his birthday last year, had just started using it to type his long-form essays because carrying the heavy school Chromebook back and forth hurts his bad shoulder. By that night, I had an email from Jake’s mom: “Jake says the school turned off WiFi. Is that true? How is he supposed to get his work done?”
I wrote her back explaining the change, and we ended up chatting on the phone a few days later. She told me she’d gotten an alert from her cell provider the previous month that Jake had used 12GB of extra data on his line, way over their plan, and she’d just assumed it was all for school projects. She had no idea he’d been scrolling TikTok for 20 minutes every day during independent work, switching back to his research tab whenever I walked by. That’s when I started to shift my thinking a little, even if I still didn’t love the abrupt change.
Over the past two weeks, I’ve been keeping casual notes on how class goes now that personal device WiFi is gone. The difference is more noticeable than I expected. Before the change, I’d stop class to redirect off-task behavior an average of 9 times a period during independent work. Most of those redirects were kids scrolling or playing games on their personal devices. This past week, that number dropped to 3. A lot of kids still bring their personal devices to type notes or write, but if they want to go on social media, they have to use a phone hotspot. Almost none of them do—partly because it’s a hassle, and partly because most parents put data limits on their kids’ plans, so they don’t want to waste it on TikTok during school.
That doesn’t mean the change is all good, of course. Marco, one of my students who doesn’t have internet at home, used to download all his homework assignments onto his personal laptop at school every Friday so he could work on it over the weekend. Now he can’t. I’ve started checking out a spare school Chromebook to him every week, which works, but it’s an extra step I have to remember, and sometimes I forget on Friday afternoons when I’m rushing to get out the door. A group of four kids working on an after-school robotics project used to tinker with their code during free period on their own laptops, and now they have to wait until they get to the robotics club meeting once a week, which has slowed their project down.
From what I’ve seen, though, there are concrete things you can do if your school makes this change, whether you’re a parent or a teacher. If you’re a parent, skip the frustrated email to the teacher first—start with a low-pressure conversation with your kid. Instead of asking “Were you using WiFi to mess around?” ask “What do you use your personal device WiFi for at school, day to day?” That question gets way more honest answers. If your kid needs access for an accessibility tool, a medical device, or a specific learning accommodation, send a direct email to admin and your child’s teacher, list the specific need, and ask for a device-specific exception. In my experience, schools will almost always approve these within 48 hours—we got Lila’s exception done in a day, and it works perfectly.
If you’re a teacher, pull your student accommodation list right after the change is announced, and send all approved devices to tech services right away, don’t wait for parents to reach out. Keep a couple extra school devices checked out to your room for kids who don’t have internet at home and need to download homework. It’s a small step that prevents a lot of unnecessary stress.
I still think the change could have been communicated better to teachers and families before it went live, and I still wish there was a middle ground instead of cutting access entirely for most kids. But this week, when I walked around the room during independent work, I saw 22 kids focused on their research projects, only a couple needing redirections, and I can’t argue with the results. We’re still figuring out the kinks for kids who do need access, and I’m sure we will be adjusting as we go for the rest of the school year.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When Schools Turn Off Personal Device WiFi: A Teacher’s Perspective