MAP Testing: A Veteran Elementary Teacher’s Honest Thoughts For Parents
Last week, I wrapped a parent-teacher conference with 4th grader Mia and her mom, Lila, and was just stacking my papers to leave when Lila pulled out her phone, twisted the lid of her half-empty iced coffee, and held the screen out to me. “Can we talk about this?” she said. It was a screenshot of Mia’s fall MAP test score: 78th percentile in reading. Lila’s thumb hovered over the screen. “Last year she was 82nd. Does this mean she’s falling behind? Do I need to get her a tutor?”
The conference room still smelled like the goldfish crackers a kindergarten class had left after their field trip that morning, and my laptop was open to Mia’s latest writing project: a three-page narrative about her rescue hamster, Mr. Nibbles, that had more plot and heart than most adult emails I read. I’d spent the last 20 minutes telling Lila how Mia led her reading group in a thoughtful discussion about animal rights the week before, how she helped a new student learn the ropes of our classroom blog. But that 4-point drop in percentile was the only thing Lila could see.
I’ve been teaching 12 years, and I’ve given MAP tests twice a year for most of that time, so I’ve had this conversation more times than I can count. I get why it’s confusing. Schools don’t do a great job of explaining what the test actually is, or what the score actually means, before they push a notification to your phone with a random number.
To start, MAP stands for Measures of Academic Progress, it’s a computer-adaptive test that adjusts question difficulty based on whether your kid gets answers right. It’s designed to measure growth over time, not just mastery of what’s been taught that semester. And that’s about where the good news ends, for the most part.
A few years back, I had a 3rd grader named Javi who scored in the 12th percentile for reading on his fall MAP test. His score triggered an automatic flag for intervention, and the district pushed me to refer him for extra testing before I even had a month to get to know him. What they didn’t know was that Javi spent 20 minutes of the test period watching a wolf spider crawl around the base of his computer, and never finished the last 10 questions. What they also didn’t know was that Javi could talk for 45 minutes straight about the life cycle of snapping turtles, had read every library book on reptiles in the building, and could build a working Lego robot from a diagram he drew himself. When he re-tested the next month after I reminded him the test didn’t count toward his recess time, he scored in the 61st percentile. No intervention needed.
To be clear, it’s not all useless. I use MAP data as one tiny tool, not a final verdict. If a kid is consistently getting Bs in my class but their MAP score is 30+ percentile points higher than what their class work shows, that tells me they’re bored, not challenged, and I can bump them up to more advanced reading groups or give them extra projects to work on. If their score is 30+ points lower than their in-class work, that’s a flag that they might be memorizing facts for unit tests or leaning too hard on parent help with homework, and I can check in on what they actually understand independently. That’s the only good use I’ve found for it: a starting point for a conversation, not an end result.
But for parents, there are three concrete things I tell everyone who sits where Lila was sitting. First, any shift smaller than 15 percentile points isn’t a meaningful shift. It’s just normal variation. Your kid could have been hungry, distracted, excited for recess, tired from a soccer game the night before, or just guessed right on more questions last year. A 4-point drop doesn’t mean anything. Second, instead of panicking and booking a tutor before you talk to anyone, ask your kid’s teacher two specific questions: How does this score line up with what you see in the classroom every day? Is there any gap between this score and my kid’s work that we actually need to address? Nine times out of ten, the answer will be that the score lines up fine, or the gap is tiny and easy to fix at home. Third, if your kid is stressing about the test before they take it, tell them this exact line: “This test doesn’t change your grade, it doesn’t change what classes you get into next year, and it doesn’t change how smart you are. It just helps your teacher figure out what to teach next.” No need for big pep talks, just give them the facts so they don’t carry the weight of that score around.
Lila nodded, and clicked her phone off, and laughed when I reminded her that Mia finished her entire MAP test in 12 minutes flat because she wanted to get out to recess for the fourth grade four square tournament. She said she’d gotten caught up in the parent Facebook group for our town, where everyone posts their kids’ 99th percentile scores like trophies, and she’d started comparing. I told her I’ve seen kids score 99th percentile who rush through the test to get to lunch, guess on half the questions, and can’t write a coherent paragraph when they get to my class. That number isn’t a measure of your kid, it’s a measure of how they performed on one 45-minute test on one random Tuesday in October.
The truth is, most schools do MAP testing because it’s required for state funding, not because it’s the best way to measure what kids know. I’d trade every MAP score we get for an extra hour a week of one-on-one reading time with each kid, but that’s not how the system works right now. There’s a lot that’s broken about how we use standardized tests in schools, and MAP isn’t an exception.
After Lila left, I sat there for a few more minutes grading spelling tests, and thought about Javi. He’s in 7th grade now, and his mom emailed me last month to say he made the state robotics competition team. He still hates multiple choice tests, he still gets distracted by interesting bugs, and he’s doing just fine. Right now, what works for me and for the parents I talk to is just keeping things in perspective. MAP is a tool, not a report card. It’s a snapshot, not the whole album. There are still so many things it can’t measure: curiosity, how kind a kid is to their classmates, the ability to keep trying when something is hard. Those are the things that matter, and none of them show up on a test score.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » MAP Testing: A Veteran Elementary Teacher’s Honest Thoughts For Parents