Why is my 11 year old girl quiet and withdrawn: What I learned worrying about my cousin
Last weekend, I squeezed past coolers of potato salad and watermelon at my aunt’s annual July BBQ to grab more lemonade from the fridge, and found Lila, my 11-year-old cousin, sitting cross-legged on the pantry floor, door propped open just an inch, phone brightness turned all the way down. She jumped when I knocked, like she’d been caught doing something wrong, and quickly closed the TikTok she was scrolling. “Just hiding from the golden retriever,” she said. The dog was outside chasing a squirrel. I knew better, but I didn’t call her out. I sat down on the floor next to her, the linoleum cool against my calves, and asked if she wanted half my lemonade.
I’ve been worried about Lila for almost six months, ever since she started sixth grade at the new middle school across town. She used to be the kid who’d drag all the adults out to the backyard to watch her cartwheel routine, who’d ramble for 45 minutes straight about the guinea pig she saved three months to buy, who begged me to take her to the library every Saturday when she stayed with me as an 8-year-old. Now, most family gatherings, she’s in a bedroom with the door cracked, or hiding in a pantry. She quit the soccer team she’d played on since she was 7, two days before the first game of the season, and wouldn’t tell anyone why. My aunt writes it off as pre-teen moodiness. “All 11-year-old girls are like this,” she says, when I bring it up. “They just hate everyone and want to be on their phones. It’s a phase.”
I get it. My aunt works full time as a nurse, has a 3-year-old son who keeps her up half the night, and she’s just getting through the week. But I also remember being 11, and how that “phase” didn’t feel like a phase when I was in it—it felt like my whole life was falling apart, and no one was paying enough attention to notice. So I started making a point to carve out an hour or two with Lila once a week, usually when my aunt has a late shift.
Two weeks ago, I picked her up after school and we got blizzards from the Dairy Queen down the street from her school. We sat in my car in the parking lot, because she said she didn’t want to go inside and run into anyone she knew from school. We ate in silence for a few minutes, and then she said, so quiet I almost didn’t hear it, “All the girls I used to hang out with plan sleepovers every weekend, and they post the pictures on Instagram, and they never invite me.”
I almost did the thing everyone does. I almost said “they’re just mean girls, you don’t need them anyway” or “you’ll make new friends soon” or even “it’s just middle school drama.” Instead, I remembered what it felt like to sit where she was, and I said, “That hurts so bad. I ate lunch in the bathroom for three weeks when my friends stopped talking to me in seventh grade. I still remember how my jeans smelled like toilet cleaner the whole time.” She looked up at me, surprised, and then started crying into her blizzard. She cried for 10 minutes about how no one sits with her at lunch, how her math teacher calls on her even when she doesn’t raise her hand, how she feels stupid all the time for thinking those girls were her friends.
That’s when I realized how many of us get this wrong. We see a quiet 11-year-old girl who’s pulled away, and we either write it off as a phase, or we rush to fix it. We schedule big “we need to talk” talks at the kitchen table, we sign her up for new activities to meet friends, we buy her new things to cheer her up, and then we get frustrated when she still won’t open up. The truth is, 11-year-old girls are hyper-conscious of being watched and judged, and a big scheduled talk feels like an interrogation.
The small, unplanned stuff works better. For example, I never ask Lila “what’s wrong” when we hang out. I just invite her along to boring, low-stakes things: grabbing groceries, picking up supplies for my apartment, sorting through the bin of old craft supplies at my place. I keep my phone in my pocket, and I don’t pressure her to talk. If she wants to scroll TikTok while we sit on my couch, that’s fine. If she wants to show me the new clay figurines she’s been making (she makes tiny Studio Ghibli characters, they’re incredible), I sit and watch and ask specific questions: how do you get the little whiskers on the Catbus so thin? Where do you get that tiny black paint for the eyes? I bought a $10 clay kit for myself, and we just make figurines while we binge old episodes of The Great British Baking Show. No agenda, no fix.
Another thing I’ve started doing is never minimizing what she feels. When she talks about the friend group, I don’t say “it’s not that big of a deal.” I just say “that sounds awful, I’d be hurting too.” It’s a tiny shift in what you say, but it makes a world of difference. She doesn’t need me to solve her problem right now. She just needs to know it’s okay to feel bad about it.
I’ve also talked to my aunt about trying small shifts too. Instead of asking “how was school” every day when Lila gets off the bus (which always gets a one-word “fine” answer), I told her to just mention one small boring thing she saw that day on her drive home, like “I saw a chicken cross the road on the way from work today, don’t know where it was going.” No pressure for Lila to respond, just a low-stakes opening. It’s only been a few weeks, but my aunt said Lila has started volunteering a tiny bit of information sometimes, like that the chicken in the cafeteria was undercooked today.
Lila still hides at family BBQs. She hasn’t gone back to soccer, and she still doesn’t have a new group of close friends. There are still days she doesn’t want to talk to anyone, and that’s okay. But last week, she texted me a photo of a tiny clay Totoro she finished, and she added a line at the end: I sat with a girl from math class at lunch today. She also does clay. We’re going to work on our projects after school next week.
It’s not a big happy ending. There’s still a lot that’s hard, and I still worry about her some days. But it’s something. And for an 11-year-old girl who feels invisible, that’s more than enough right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why is my 11 year old girl quiet and withdrawn: What I learned worrying about my cousin