What to do if you can’t post on parenting forums because you need 100 positive karma and a 10-day-old account
It’s 2:17 a.m. My 4-year-old is finally asleep in his bed after an hour-long screaming meltdown triggered by the scratchy tag on his new dinosaur sweatshirt. I’m on the couch, cold chamomile tea sweating next to me, granola bar crumbs stuck to the front of my old college sweatpants. My pediatrician brushed off my concerns about his frequent outbursts and sensitivity to loud noises as “just a strong-willed kid,” Google has given me 50 different conflicting answers, and I’ve clicked through to the big neurodivergent parenting sub I keep seeing people mention. I type out every messy, tired detail of the last six months, hit “post,” and up pops the line I’ll never forget: In order to post your account must be older than 10 days and have 100 positive karma.
I’d made the Reddit account that same hour. I’d never needed one before – I just browsed cat memes and baking tutorials when I waited in the doctor’s office, never logged in or posted anything. I sat there blinking at the error message, my throat tightening. What even is karma? Why would a community for struggling parents lock new people out when they’re the ones who need help the most? I almost closed the window, almost gave up and went to bed to cry into my pillow like I’d done a dozen other nights. Instead, I texted my college roommate who’d been on Reddit forever, and she talked me off the ledge.
She explained that most large online communities for parents have that rule to block scammers and bad actors. People make dozens of new accounts every day to sell fake cures to desperate parents – $120 crystal kits that “cure ADHD,” essential oil blends that claim to reverse autism, weight loss teas for kids with eating disorders. Other trolls make new accounts to start fights, post fake sob stories to get donations, or harass people asking for vulnerable, personal help. The 10-day and 100 karma rule stops almost all of that garbage before it hits the main feed.
She told me what to do next: don’t make a new account, don’t bother with those weird “free karma” subreddits because auto-mods can spot those and block you anyway. Just comment on a couple posts a day when I had a minute, that it’d go faster than I thought. I started doing that. While my son napped on weekends, while I waited for my coffee to brew in the morning, I’d scroll through new posts. I said “This is so hard, I’m sorry you’re going through this” on a post about a kid’s first IEP meeting. I said “We tried cutting out artificial food dye and that cut down on meltdowns a little for us” on a question about behavioral tips. Most comments got one or two upvotes, sometimes more. By the 11th day, I checked my profile and had 132 positive karma.
I posted my question, and got 47 comments back. No scammers, no one calling me a bad parent. Just dozens of other parents saying “That’s exactly what sensory processing disorder looks like, here’s the checklist I took to my doctor to get him evaluated.” One mom sent me a link to a free parent support group in my city that I didn’t know existed. That post ended up changing how we approached my son’s needs, and it never would have happened if I’d given up after that error message.
Now, a few years later, I help mod a small sub for parents of sensory kids, and we have the same rule. I’ve seen it work first hand. Last month, 21 new accounts signed up in 24 hours, all of them less than a day old, zero karma, all set up to post the same link to a $90 supplement that claimed to “fix neurodivergence.” All of them got blocked automatically before any of our regular members even saw them. If we didn’t have that rule, our whole front page would have been that garbage, and at least a few desperate tired parents would have wasted their money on it.
After talking to dozens of new parents who’ve hit that same error message I got that night, I have a few concrete things I tell them to do. First, scroll back up to the top of the sub and check for pinned threads. Almost every big parenting forum has a stickied “new user quick question” thread that lets anyone post, no karma or age requirement. I didn’t know that my first night, and I could have gotten my question answered 10 days earlier if I’d just looked. Second, don’t game the system with karma farms or new accounts. It just gets you flagged, and you’ll have to start all over again. Third, spend 5 minutes a day commenting on 2 or 3 posts. You don’t need to write a novel. Any genuine 1-sentence comment will get upvoted pretty quickly, because most people on these groups are happy to see new people joining the conversation. Fourth, if you’re dealing with an urgent situation – you’re worried your kid is hurting themselves, you need help right now – send a quick message to the mod team. Almost all of us will waive the rule for urgent needs.
It’s still not a perfect rule. I think about that 2 a.m. night a lot, how that 10-day wait felt like an eternity when I was so scared I could barely breathe. There are still people who can’t spare 5 minutes a day to comment, people who need help today and can’t wait. There are still trolls that get through, and scammers that find workarounds. But most days, it works. Last week, I saw a new parent asking about that error on a help sub, and I told her what I’d learned. She messaged me two weeks later saying she got the evaluation referral she’d been asking her doctor for for months, thanks to the advice she got after she posted. It’s messy, it’s inconvenient, but it keeps the spaces that help parents like me safe. I still wish it didn’t have to be that way, but I get why it is.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What to do if you can’t post on parenting forums because you need 100 positive karma and a 10-day-old account