Is My Kid’s Messy, Unstructured Play A Waste Of Time? What I Learned As A Mom And Teacher
Last Saturday, I was folding matching socks at the kitchen table, staring at the half-finished decimal practice workbook I’d printed out for my 8-year-old, Leo, that sat untouched on the counter. I’d told him he could have 20 minutes of free time after his regular homework before we tackled extra practice, and 45 minutes later he was still cross-legged on the back porch, not reading, not building with his new Lego space set, just moving acorns around in the dirt. I wiped a stray lint ball off my jeans, walked out, and leaned against the door frame. “Whatcha working on that’s so important?” I asked. He didn’t look up from tucking a tiny cracked acorn into a hollow spot between two clods of grass. “My acorn city,” he said. “This is the hospital for acorns that got hurt when they fell.” The first thought that popped into my head was: This is a total waste of time. We could knock out this math workbook in 20 minutes and still make the 2 o’clock dinosaur museum exhibit I’d bought tickets for. If we waited much longer, we’d miss it entirely.
As a 4th grade teacher, I get this question from parents all the time. Is it a waste of time that my kid spends all free choice drawing Pokémon instead of reading? Is it a waste of time that my 10-year-old reorganizes their shoe closet every Sunday instead of doing flash cards? I used to hedge, say it depends, before I had Leo and started asking myself the same question every other day.
Last month, one of my student’s moms pulled me aside after parent-teacher conferences, voice tight with worry. Her daughter Mia, she said, spends every single recess making menus for a pretend snack bar she runs with her friend on the playground. Can you redirect her to something more useful? she asked. It’s just a waste of time, she’s never going to get better at writing that way. I told her I’d watch for a week, see what was going on.
What I saw surprised even me. For three straight days, Mia and her friend wrote and rewrote their menu, crossing out items that didn’t sell and adding new ones based on what kids asked for. When they started charging for snacks, they added up totals in their head, invented a 10% discount for kids who brought their own napkins, and kept a running list of how much “profit” they made each day. By the end of the week, Mia was asking to borrow my classroom hole punch to bind her menu into a book, and she was doing multi-step addition that was a full grade level above what we were working on in class. When I told her mom that, she stared at me for a full minute before she laughed. She had no idea that the “waste of time” was the most challenging learning activity Mia had done all month.
Back on my porch that Saturday, I was halfway to telling Leo to wrap up his acorn city and get inside for math when I thought of Mia. Instead of herding him in, I sat down on the step next to him and asked him to walk me through the whole city. He jumped at the chance, pointing out the mayor’s house (a giant oak acorn wrapped in grass), the public pool (a flat acorn cap filled with rainwater), and the apartment complex where all the new baby acorns lived. When he counted how many apartments there were to make sure there was enough room for all the new acorns that fell that week, he got to 37, forgot where he was, started over, and counted again slowly out loud. That was exactly the counting practice I was going to make him do in that workbook.
I’ve learned over the last few years that the first thing I get wrong when I ask “is this a waste of time” is assuming that learning only looks like what I planned it to look like. I used to yank Leo away from whatever random project he was obsessed with the second I decided it was time for “real work”, but now I do one small thing first that changes everything: I stop and listen for 10 minutes. I don’t interrupt, I don’t judge, I just ask him to tell me what he’s doing. More often than not, there’s more learning happening in that messy acorn city than there would be in 20 minutes of forced workbook practice.
If you do have a hard stop—like you have to leave for soccer practice in 10 minutes, or dinner’s going to get cold—you don’t have to let it go on forever. I always give a 10-minute warning now, and I let Leo mark where he left off instead of making him clean it all up right away. If he’s working on the porch, we just put a big plastic tub over it so it doesn’t get rained on, and he can pick it back up the next day. If you’re worried about fitting in the structured practice you think they need, work with their obsession instead of against it. If your kid only wants to draw Minecraft mobs instead of write, ask them to write a one-sentence backstory for each character to go with their drawing. It’s the same writing practice, just on their terms.
That doesn’t mean every unplanned activity is automatically worthwhile, of course. I’ve had days where Leo zones out flipping through TV channels for two hours, not engaging with anything, just killing time. That’s when I turn it off and we go for a walk, no guilt. The difference is pretty clear once you start looking for it: if they’re focused, making choices, and building something (even if it’s just an acorn city), it’s not a waste. If they’re just checking out, it’s okay to step in.
We ended up missing the dinosaur museum that Saturday. I got a refund for the tickets, and we did the math workbook on Sunday instead. Leo still adds new acorns to his city every time we go outside, and he gives a tour to every guest that comes over. I still catch myself scrolling Instagram some nights, seeing other parents post about their kids’ latest awards and tutoring progress, and I wonder if I’m doing enough. I still get it wrong sometimes, pulling him away too early when I’m in a hurry, or letting zoning out go on too long when I’m tired. But for now, pausing before I call something a waste of time is working pretty well. Last week I saw Mia at the grocery store, and she pulled out a new binder from her backpack: she’s now selling custom birthday invitations to her classmates for $1 each, saving up for a new bike. It still looks like just playing to most people, but I know better.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is My Kid’s Messy, Unstructured Play A Waste Of Time