How to Talk to Your Kids About Old Scars: Practical Parenting Tips
Last Saturday, I was flipping blueberry pancakes at the stove, sleeves rolled up because it was already 80 degrees by 9 a.m., when my 5-year-old, Jax, froze mid-grab for a stray blueberry off the counter. He pointed at the thin, pale scar snaking across my inner forearm—the one I got when I fell through a glass coffee table at 12, the one I’ve spent years tugging sleeves down over when I meet new people. “Mommy, what’s that big owie on your arm? Did someone hurt you?”
I fumbled for a second. For as long as I’ve had kids, I’ve defaulted to dumb jokes: it’s a shark bite, it’s a mark from a secret superhero mission. That usually works, kids giggle and move on. But that day, Jax didn’t laugh. He stepped closer, touched the edge of it gentle with his sticky blueberry finger, and asked again. “Does it still hurt? Did you cry a lot?” My 7-year-old, Mia, looked up from her cereal, lifted her shirt to show the faint pink scar on her lower belly from her appendectomy two years ago. “Is my scar going to turn pale and weird like that? Is mine ugly?”
Suddenly a silly offhand question felt like a big thing I’d never prepared for. I mumbled something about it being just an old scar, no big deal, and turned the stove down to low to think. That night, I texted my sister, who’s a pediatric nurse, and asked what other parents do. What I got back wasn’t fancy advice, just a bunch of small, doable things that have worked for our family over the last couple months.
The first thing that changed was I stopped joking and dodging. I used to think making light of it kept it from being scary, but what I realized is that dodging or joking makes a scar feel like something bad, something we can’t talk about honestly. When Jax asked again a few days later, I just said, “I got that when I was 12, a little older than Mia. I was running through my grandma’s house and fell through her glass table. It hurt a lot back then, and I had to get stitches, but it’s all healed now. It doesn’t hurt at all anymore.” That’s all he asked, so that’s all I said. He nodded, wiped his hand on his pants, and went back to building his Lego castle. No big scene, no tears, just done.
That’s the second thing I learned: only answer what they ask, match it to their age. A 4 or 5 year old doesn’t need to hear the whole story of how I needed 11 stitches and missed my end of school dance, or if your scar is from something harder—like a past car accident, an illness, or even a time when you hurt yourself—you don’t have to share details they can’t process. A friend of mine has a visible scar from a suicide attempt in her 20s, and she told me she just tells her 6 and 8 year old “that’s an old scar from when I was very sick a long time ago. I’m all better now, and it doesn’t hurt.” That’s enough. It answers their question, it’s honest, and you don’t have to lay all your stuff on them before they’re old enough to understand.
When Mia asked if her scar was ugly, I used to blurt “of course not, it’s cute!” But that just made her more insecure, like I was lying to make her feel better. Now, I just meet her where she is. I said, “Scars look different when they heal, right? Yours is still pretty new, so it’s pinker than mine. It’ll fade a little over time, but it’ll always be there. It’s just part of you, the same way mine is part of me.” Then I reminded her that it’s the scar that meant she got to eat 3 cherry popsicles a day in the hospital, and her dad brought her that stuffed otter she still sleeps with. That stuck with her more than telling her it was cute. Now she tells that story to anyone who asks.
We also talk about boundaries now, which I never thought of before. Last month, we were at the playground, and Jax spotted a little boy with a thick scar across his cheek from a cleft repair. I tensed up, waiting for him to point and stare like kids do, but he just walked over, pulled up his pant leg to show his own scar from falling off his trike last year, and asked “what’s yours from?” The little boy said “I had an operation when I was a baby. It doesn’t hurt now.” Then they ran off to climb the slide together. But if either of them had not wanted to talk about it, we’ve talked about how that’s okay too. If someone asks about your scar and you don’t want to tell them, you can just say “it’s personal, I don’t want to talk about it” and walk away. It’s your body, you get to decide.
What I didn’t expect is that talking openly about scars also takes away the power they have over me, a little. I grew up thinking my scar was ugly, something to hide, and I passed that quiet anxiety on to my kids without meaning to. Once I started talking about it like the normal thing it is, they stopped seeing it as something weird or scary. It’s just a mark on my arm, same as the freckles on Jax’s nose or Mia’s curly cowlick at the back of her head.
Last week, Jax asked me again if my scar would ever go away. I said “no, it’s going to stay with me forever. That’s okay, it’s just part of me.” He nodded, and went back to his video game. Some days I still catch myself yanking my sleeve down out of old habit, and I don’t have all the answers for when the kids get older and ask harder questions. But for now, this works. We don’t make a big deal out of scars, so they don’t make a big deal out of them.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Talk to Your Kids About Old Scars: Practical Parenting Tips