When Your Kid Asks “What Would You Do If You Were Me?”: Parenting Tips For Sticky Kid Problems
I was wiping coffee splatters off the kitchen counter last month when my 10-year-old son Leo slung his backpack down hard enough to knock over the half-empty carton of milk I’d left out for his after-school snack. He kicked the leg of the stool, crossed his arms, and sighed so deep his shoulders shook. “My science group is a disaster. What would you do if you were me?”
My hand didn’t even pause on the counter. I’ve been a parent long enough to recognize a problem when I hear one, and my brain immediately jumped to the simplest solution. “Tell your teacher Javi isn’t pulling his weight. That’s what I’d do. She’ll reassign the work.”
Leo just stared at me for a second, then crumpled his granola bar wrapper into a ball and tossed it at the trash can. He missed, didn’t stop to pick it up. “Whatever,” he said, and trundled up the stairs to his room. I stood there staring at the crumpled wrapper, coffee stain still on my sweater, and realized I’d messed up. That question wasn’t an invitation to solve the problem. It was a call for something else, and I’d missed it completely.
Fifteen minutes later, I grabbed an orange soda from the fridge—his favorite, the kind I only let him have on school days if it’s been a bad one—and knocked on his door. He was sitting cross-legged on his bed scrolling TikTok, volume turned all the way down. I sat on the edge, set the soda down next to his leg, and said, “Earlier when you asked what I’d do if you were you, I got it wrong. I answered before I even asked what’s actually going on. Wanna start over?”
That’s when all the stuff I didn’t know came out. Javi, Leo’s best friend who joined our school last year, hasn’t been okay for weeks. His mom lost her job as a paraeducator at the elementary school, and he’s been staying after with the counselor twice a week to talk about moving and possibly switching schools if they have to relocate for a new job. Leo didn’t want to tell the teacher Javi wasn’t pulling his weight because that would make Javi look lazy, and he already feels like an outsider. If the whole group failed because of Javi, Leo thought Javi would decide no one wanted to be his friend anyway. And if Leo split the group, that would just confirm it. He was stuck: either he failed the project, or he lost his best friend. No good options.
When he finished talking, he looked at me again and asked, “So what would you do if you were me?” This time, I didn’t give an answer. I repeated back what I’d just heard: “If I were you, I’d feel stuck between two really bad choices, right? You don’t want to fail, and you don’t want to hurt the person who needs your friend right now. That’s the worst kind of stuck. Is that right?” He nodded so hard his hair fell in his face. “Yeah. Exactly.”
We spent the next 20 minutes just talking through the options he’d already thought of, instead of me dumping mine on him. He’d already thought about doing Javi’s work for him, but soccer practice takes up three evenings a week and he has a book report due the same week as the project. He’d thought about asking the teacher for an extension, but he didn’t want to do it without Javi knowing. I didn’t offer any solutions, just asked questions: “What do you think would happen if you did that?” “How would that feel for Javi?” “What’s the worst that could come out of that option?”
By the end of the conversation, he had his own plan. He’d meet Javi after soccer practice the next day, ask him if he wanted to handle the poster for the project—drawing all the planets and labeling them, the fun creative part that doesn’t require research or writing that Javi hates. If Javi said he couldn’t even do that, they’d go to the teacher together, explain what’s going on with Javi’s family, and ask for an extra three days to finish. That wasn’t my plan. It was his.
What I’ve learned since that day is that when kids ask “what would you do if you were me?”, 9 times out of 10, they don’t actually want your answer. They want to know that you get how hard their situation is before you start telling them what to do. The concrete shift I’ve made is simple, and any parent or teacher can do it: when they ask the question, pause for three seconds before you answer. First, name the feeling you’re hearing, don’t jump to the solution. If you already messed up and jumped to fix it like I did, just say “I got that wrong, can we start over?” It doesn’t need a big, dramatic apology. Then, ask them to walk you through what they’ve already thought of trying, before you share your ideas. Only give your own take if they ask for it after that.
Leo’s project turned out fine. Javi loved drawing the planets, used glow-in-the-dark paint he had at his house, they got a B+ which was more than good enough for both of them. Last week, though, Leo came home and asked me the same question again, after Javi bailed on their planned hike to the lake because he was too down to get out of bed. “What would you do if you were me?” he asked. This time, I didn’t give an answer. I just said, “It sucks when your friend pulls away and you don’t know how to help, doesn’t it?” He agreed, and we talked through his options.
We still don’t always get it right. Some days I still slip up and give advice before I listen. But this small shift has made a big difference. Most of the time, being stuck isn’t about needing a solution. It’s about needing someone to see how stuck you are first.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Your Kid Asks “What Would You Do If You Were Me