How Colleges Use Growth Hacks To Recruit Students – What Parents Need To Know
Last March, I stood at our kitchen table stirring coffee while my 17-year-old son Luka sorted through the daily stack of college mail, a half-eaten strawberry pop tart balanced on the edge of the pile. He held up a neon purple hoodie folded neatly in a padded envelope, raised an eyebrow, and said, “Did you sign me up for this? I’ve never even heard of this school.” It was a small liberal arts college in Ohio, 12 hours from our home in western Pennsylvania, and Luka had never filled out a single form expressing interest in any school outside a three-hour drive. We both stared at the hoodie for a minute, then Luka shrugged and pulled it on over his cross country sweatshirt. It fit perfectly.
For the next month, the outreach from that school didn’t let up. Luka got a personalized video email from the admissions director saying he’d “love to have a student with Luka’s academic record on campus” next fall. He got text messages every other Wednesday reminding him of upcoming application deadlines. He even got a handwritten note from a current environmental science student (Luka’s intended major) talking about how much she loved the program. A month in, he mentioned over dinner that he was thinking about sending in an application, just “to see what happens.” I asked him why, and he said, “They really want me, right? It seems rude not to.”
That’s when I started asking around about what was going on. A college friend of mine, Claire, works in enrollment management at our local state university, and she laughed when I told her the story. “That’s just growth hacking for higher ed,” she said. Most colleges these days are dealing with a steady drop in the number of high school graduates nationwide, so small schools and even mid-sized public programs are turning to these fast, data-driven tactics to boost enrollment fast. A growth hacker’s job isn’t just to find students who are a good fit – it’s to get more applications, more acceptances, and higher incoming class numbers, as quickly as possible.
Claire explained that it all starts with data. Colleges buy lists of students from the College Board and ACT, filtered by GPA, test scores, zip code, even specific extracurriculars. If your kid scored above a 1200 on the SAT and listed “environmental science” as an interest, you’ll end up on 100 different buying lists before you even start thinking about applications. Then the personalized gifts start coming – hoodies, mugs, stickers, even $10 Starbucks gift cards sometimes. Growth hackers rely on that little voice in your head that says, “They sent me a free thing, I owe them a look.” They send unsolicited application fee waivers, so applying feels free and low-stakes. The more applications they get, the more students they can reject, which lowers their acceptance rate and pushes them up a few spots in national rankings. Higher rankings bring more applications the next year, and the cycle keeps going.
I saw this in action a few weeks later at a regional college fair. Luka and I wandered past booths, and one small private college had a free ice cream truck and a custom sticker photo booth set up right by the entrance. Luka stopped to get a cone and a sticker with his name printed on it for his laptop, and spent 10 minutes chatting with the admissions rep. Walking away, he kept saying how friendly everyone was, what a cool vibe the school had. When I checked the program list later, I pointed out they didn’t even offer a bachelor’s in environmental science. He’d been sucked in by the little, personal touches that are designed to stick in your head, no fit required.
It’s not all bad, honestly. Some small schools with amazing niche programs would never get in front of the right kids without this kind of outreach. But the problem is that all the noise creates unnecessary stress. I saw that with my neighbor’s daughter, Mia, last year. Mia has a 3.2 GPA, wants to study nursing, and she was crying to her mom one night because all her friends were getting bags of free swag and personalized letters, and she barely got any mail at all. She thought no colleges wanted her, that she wasn’t a good enough student. The reality is that growth hackers target higher-scoring students first, because they’re more likely to accept offers and keep graduation rates up. It had nothing to do with Mia’s ability, and everything to do with the college’s numbers.
After Luka mentioned applying to that Ohio school, we put a simple system in place to sort through the noise that took 10 minutes every Sunday. First, Luka splits all incoming mail and messages into three piles: schools he already had on his list from before all the outreach started, schools he’s curious about that actually check his two non-negotiable boxes (they have environmental science, they’re in a location he’d actually live for four years), and everything else. The everything else pile gets recycled, and we keep the free swag – that Ohio hoodie gets worn to every high school football game now. We made a rule that you don’t have to apply anywhere just because they sent you something, and you don’t have to reply to any message from a school you don’t care about. I also reminded him that a personalized note or video doesn’t mean the director of admissions actually knows his name – 9 times out of 10, it’s just a template with a name inserted by an automated system. It doesn’t mean he’s a top candidate any more than the kid who never got a note.
Luka ended up enrolling this fall at the state university he’d had his eye on since sophomore year, the one that never sent him a free hoodie or a handwritten note. We still get recruitment mail from that Ohio school, now asking him to consider transferring after his freshman year. I don’t blame colleges for doing this – they’re running institutions that need to stay open, especially small schools that don’t have huge endowments to fall back on. But it’s easy for parents and kids to forget that all that attention is just marketing, not a reflection of how good a fit the school is, or how good a student you are. Next year, my younger daughter will start her own college search, and I know we’ll be sorting through a whole new stack of padded envelopes and free hoodies. We’ll pull out the Sunday sorting system again, and we’ll get through it, one envelope at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How Colleges Use Growth Hacks To Recruit Students – What Parents Need To Know