Why Your Senior Is Hesitant to Go In Person for Last Year of High School: What Actually Works
The crumpled bus pass sat on the kitchen counter next to Leo’s half-eaten Cheerios, 10 minutes before his first bell. I folded the last of his hoodies and nodded at it. “You gonna miss another first period?” He pushed off the fridge, where he’d been leaning staring at his phone, and stuffed his hands into the pockets of his faded debate club hoodie. “I don’t really want to go today. Can’t I just do the work from home?”
This is his senior year, the last year of high school everyone keeps telling me is supposed to be magical. For months leading up to August, every other parent at the grocery store or soccer practice talked about making the most of every moment, checking off all the traditions they missed during shutdowns. I bought into it too, grabbed him a cheap “Senior 2024” hoodie for the first day, asked every night how spirit week went, reminded him how fast it all goes. But by the third week of school, he was staying home one or two days a week, saying he just couldn’t handle being in the building that long. I got mad at first, told him he’d regret it, that he was wasting the last year he’d ever have with these people. He just shut down, went to his room and didn’t talk about it for three days.
It was 9 o’clock when I took the trash out that weekend, and found him sitting on the porch step staring at the street. I grabbed two root beers from the fridge, didn’t say anything about the borrowed cigarette he was hiding behind his ankle, just sat down next to him. After 10 minutes of quiet, he started talking. Said the whole school feels like one big commercial for senior year. Every morning’s announcements are just list after list of events, all yelling “make your last memories!” but he doesn’t even know 30 people in his graduating class. Half his closest friends graduated early, the kids he went to middle school with have completely different schedules now, he spent all of junior year doing class from his bedroom. He doesn’t know how to keep up with 8 hours of small talk between classes, doesn’t want to sit through loud assemblies where everyone’s pushing school spirit he doesn’t feel, doesn’t get why he has to show up to a study hall just to sit at a desk when he can finish his homework twice as fast at home. He already got his early acceptance to the state college he wanted, so none of the last-minute grade panic applies. What’s the point of dragging himself in every single day just to check a box everyone else says he has to check?
I made an appointment with his guidance counselor the next week, expecting to be told I needed to push harder to get him in the building every day. Instead, she told me this is way more common than most people think—right now, close to a third of the seniors she works with have some level of hesitation about full-time in person. She didn’t give me vague “be supportive” lines, just concrete things to try that I hadn’t thought of.
First, stop leading with nostalgia and regret. That line of thinking doesn’t land for this group of kids, because their high school experience never matched the narrative we’re pushing. They didn’t get four full years of normal, so asking them to get sentimental over the last eight months of it feels forced. Instead of opening with “Aren’t you excited for homecoming?” try “What’s the worst part of going in tomorrow? What’s one thing that would make it easier?” That small shift in question gets you actual answers instead of eye rolls and silence.
Second, ask for a small compromise, don’t force all or nothing. Most schools will work with you if your kid’s grades are solid—they don’t want to fight a senior who’s already on track to graduate. Leo had a 3.8 GPA, so we asked if he could do his study hall and PE (which he hates, it’s just walking around the track for an hour) online on Fridays, so he only goes four days a week. The school approved it in a week, no extra paperwork hassle. That one 3-day weekend every month gives him time to reset, without pulling him out of school entirely.
Third, let them pick their own senior moments, don’t make them check every box. Schools push 10 different optional events for seniors, and it’s easy to bug your kid to go to all of them so they don’t miss out. Now we just ask Leo to pick one event a semester that actually sounds kind of fun, no pressure for more. He picked the end-of-month senior paint fight, skipped homecoming and the senior mountain hike, and that’s enough.
I’ve talked to three other parents of seniors in the last month, all dealing with the same thing. One mom told me her daughter refuses to go three days a week, says all the “last this last that” talk makes her uncomfortable, because she never got the first three years of normal high school, so the last one feels fake. I think what a lot of us get wrong is assuming that all seniors want the same thing, that in person is automatically better. A lot of these kids spent the last three years building a routine that works for them, that’s low stress, and asking them to drop it entirely for a narrative that doesn’t fit their experience is unfair. It’s not laziness, it’s not that they don’t care—it’s just that their relationship to school is different than ours was.
It’s mid-October now. Leo still calls me some mornings from his room to say he’s feeling tired and wants to start second period, and I let him most of the time. He went to the paint fight two weeks ago, came home with neon pink paint in his eyebrows and a soda stain on his hoodie, and said it was “fine, not life changing but fine.” We still have the occasional argument when he stays home for a full day and I slip back into the “you’ll regret it” mindset. But for the most part, the four-day schedule works. He’s keeping his grades up, he still meets his friends for pizza after school on Wednesdays, he’s ordering bedding for his dorm next fall. It’s not the perfect, memory-filled senior year I imagined back in August, but it’s the one he wants. And that’s enough, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Your Senior Is Hesitant to Go In Person for Last Year of High School: What Actually Works