Is Accreditation the Most Important Factor When Choosing an Online School? A Parent’s Honest Experience
It was 9:17 p.m. on a Tuesday in March, and my kitchen table was covered in crushed Goldfish crackers, a half-empty mug of cold coffee, and the open laptop that was giving me a headache. My 8-year-old son Leo, who has sensory processing disorder, had spent the week coming home from public school with migraines, after his district cut the sensory support block he’d relied on for two years. We’d finally decided to try online elementary school, and I was deep in a Google rabbit hole, every article repeating the same line: First, check accreditation.
Then I found it: a small, project-based program out of Portland, with capped class sizes of 8 kids, all teachers trained in special ed, and a policy that let kids take as many 15-minute movement breaks as they needed throughout the day. It was everything Leo needed, but it only held national accreditation, not the regional accreditation our state’s public schools use. I froze, and called my older sister, a 4th grade teacher in our district, who picked up on the first ring.
“Before you panic,” she said, when I explained the problem, “let’s back up. When did everyone start acting like accreditation is the only thing that matters?”
I’d spent the past week absorbing the idea that any online school without the right accreditation was a scam, that all credits would be worthless if we ever decided to go back to traditional school. But my sister reminded me that she’d worked with plenty of families who’d chosen small, niche online programs for elementary, and only a handful had ever run into credit issues. I still wasn’t convinced, so the next day I called our district’s guidance office, and talked to Sue, the counselor who’d handled Leo’s IEP since kindergarten.
She laid it out plain: Accreditation is important, but how important depends entirely on what you’re using online school for. If your kid is in high school and wants to go to a four-year college, regional accreditation is non-negotiable. Colleges won’t accept a diploma from an unaccredited program, and most won’t accept transfer credits either. I’ve got a friend whose teenage son graduated from an unaccredited religious online program a few years back, and he had to get his GED just to enroll in our local community college—so that’s a real risk, no question.
But for K-8, when most districts just want to see that your kid was doing actual school work, accreditation is a checkbox, not a dealbreaker. Sue told me that our district accepts any accreditation from a recognized national or regional board, and that even if a program wasn’t accredited, they’d just do a quick placement test to figure out what grade level your kid is at when they transfer back. The horror stories I’d read online about kids being held back a year because of unaccredited online school? Almost all of them were for high school, not elementary.
I ended up emailing three current parents of kids in that Portland program, and all three got back to me within a day. One had transferred her daughter back to our local public middle school the year before, and she sent me a screenshot of the acceptance letter that showed all of her daughter’s work counted. Another was doing long-term online school for her kid with anxiety, and she’d already confirmed with the local community college that the program’s accreditation works for dual enrollment when her kid hits high school.
I still hesitated, because every blog post had screamed that accreditation was the most important thing. But then I looked at the big, fully regionally accredited state online program that was supposed to be the “safe” choice. It had 30 kids per class, required Leo to be on camera for six hours straight every day, and didn’t allow flexible scheduling. Even if it was perfectly accredited, what good would it do if Leo couldn’t make it through a single day without a meltdown? We would have quit after a month, and ended up right back where we started.
We enrolled Leo in the smaller program that August, and it’s now mid-March a year later. This morning, he finished his math lesson by 10 a.m., put on his rain boots, and took a 25-minute break to dig for worms in the backyard for his upcoming science project on decomposition. He hasn’t had a migraine since the first week of school, and he actually asks when it’s time for reading group.
From what I’ve learned, the best order to check things when you’re looking for an online school isn’t accreditation first. It’s your goal first. Figure out what you need this for: is it a one-year break while your kid works through anxiety or bullying? Is it long-term through high school for college? That tells you how non-negotiable accreditation is. Then, if you’re even a little unsure about transfer, call the school your kid would transfer to, ask what accreditations they accept, and write down the name of the person you talked to. That takes 10 minutes, and it’s way more reliable than any blog post’s generic rule.
Accreditation is a useful stamp of approval that weeds out actual scams, but it doesn’t tell you anything about whether your kid will get the support they need, or if the schedule will work for your family. I’ve seen fully accredited online programs that were just pre-recorded videos with no teacher response for weeks, and small, differently accredited programs that have teachers who check in with your kid every single day.
We still don’t know if we’ll stick with online school through high school, or if we’ll transfer Leo back to traditional when he’s older. If we do end up switching, there’s a small chance we’ll hit a snag with credits. But so far, having a place where Leo can actually learn without being in constant pain is worth the tiny bit of extra prep we did to confirm our choices. Accreditation matters, but it’s never been more important than my kid’s daily ability to show up and feel okay. That’s the part no stamp on a website can check for you.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is Accreditation the Most Important Factor When Choosing an Online School