That Viral Child Welfare Story Got Me Staring At My Cold Coffee For 20 Minutes This Morning
I dropped my 5-year-old niece off at her kindergarten this morning, grabbed an iced oolong from the street cart by the gate, and was scrolling through WeChat moments while waiting for the bus to work. The cart always puts too much ice, so the cup sweats through the paper sleeve, dripping all over my phone screen. I wiped it off three times before I could make out the thumbnail of the 17-second clip everyone was sharing. It’s that little girl, the one who lives in the old brick apartment complex on the west side of town. You can hear a man yelling off-camera, and you see her huddle in the corner of the balcony, thin, in a too-big stained t-shirt. Neighbors have been calling child protective services for months, the caption said. No one’s done anything.
I’ve been thinking about this off and on for three weeks now. It’s not like I don’t have other stuff going on—my rent went up last month, my cat chewed through his old scratching post and I keep forgetting to buy a new one, I have a work deadline next Friday. But this keeps popping up. Last night, my cousin came over to help me mend a hole in my favorite jeans, and we got to talking about it. She has a boy the same age as that little girl, and she kept pausing mid-stitch, her hands all clenched around the needle, saying “what if that was my kid?” I didn’t know what to say. Because the only official update we’ve gotten is one two-sentence post on the city government’s Weibo, saying they’re investigating, and that they prioritize child safety. That was 18 days ago. Nothing since.
I get it, really. I volunteered at a community after-school program for at-risk kids for a year and a half back when I was in college. I know you can’t just blast a kid’s personal business all over the internet. Privacy matters, especially for kids who’ve been through trauma. You don’t want strangers hounding the family, or the kid growing up seeing her whole terrible story all over random forums when she’s older. That’s completely fair. I would never argue against that. But where’s the middle ground here? No information at all isn’t protection. It just leaves space for every terrible rumor you can imagine.
I remember one case we had back at the program. A 7-year-old boy who showed up with a black eye, said his mom’s boyfriend hit him. We called child welfare, they came out, took him to a temporary placement for a week. Then the local office just said “the case is resolved” and that was it. No one knew what that meant. For a month, everyone in the neighborhood was saying they sent him back home, that the boyfriend paid someone off, that no one cared about a poor kid from a bad neighborhood. There was a petition going around, people were yelling at the community workers, it got really ugly. Turned out, the mom had left the boyfriend, gone to a women’s shelter, got a new job, and the kid was staying with her in a new apartment on the other side of the city. That black eye he got a month later was from falling off the playground slide. But no one told anyone that. All we had was that one line “case resolved”, so everyone made up the worst possible story. Doesn’t that just make everything worse, for everyone involved?
I still have a crayon drawing that little boy gave me, actually. It’s taped to the side of my fridge, a blue dinosaur with three lopsided tails. I look at it every morning when I get my cereal out. I don’t think he even remembers me, but I never took it down.
Last Sunday, I had dinner with my extended family, and I got into this stupid little argument with my uncle about this case. He said regular people don’t need to know every little detail of an ongoing investigation, we should just trust the process. I said, but what if the process is broken? If no one ever tells us anything, how do we know it’s working? He got huffy, ate a big piece of braised pork belly, and changed the subject to why I still haven’t found a boyfriend and settled down. Awkward silence, everyone ate their dumplings, no one brought it up again. That’s how these conversations go, right? No one wants to ruin a family dinner with something sad and messy.
I walked past that old brick apartment complex last week, I had to go to the Bank of China down the street to wire my dad some money for his new bike. I slowed down when I got to the building number everyone’s been talking about. The curtains on the balcony were all drawn. I stood there for a minute, like I might hear something, or see the little girl peeking out. Nothing. An old lady walking her corgi stopped and looked at me like I was up to no good, so I kept walking. I get why people are nosy, why everyone keeps sharing the clip even when it’s been taken down half a dozen times. It’s not that we want to be voyeurs. Most of us just have kids, or know kids, and we can’t stop thinking about what it would be like to be that small, that scared, and no one comes to help even when dozens of people know what’s going on.
I don’t have all the answers. I don’t know how to fix the whole child welfare system in one go, I don’t know what the exact right line between privacy and transparency is. I just know that “we’re investigating” followed by three weeks of silence isn’t enough. It doesn’t protect the kid, it doesn’t reassure the public, it just makes everyone more anxious, more angry, more likely to believe the worst. I still check the city government’s Weibo account every other morning, when I’m waiting for my bus. There’s still no new update. My iced oolong went cold this morning, before I even took half of it. I just left it on the bus stop bench, and walked to work. I still can’t stop thinking about her.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » That Viral Child Welfare Story Got Me Staring At My Cold Coffee For 20 Minutes This Morning