I Got Detention For Throwing A Paper Plane, And I Still Think About It Sometimes
I was in the checkout line at Walmart last week, waiting for my turn behind a mom and her 11-year-old kid, when the kid folded a crumpled cake receipt into a lumpy paper plane and launched it across the lane. It smacked right into the side of a 12-pack of root beer a retiree was holding, and the whole thing wobbled before he caught it. I tensed up, waiting for the reaction, because I know that exact stomach-drop feeling.
It was 10th grade, AP Bio, last period before spring break. The room smelled like chalk dust and the overripe bananas Ms. Hale kept on her desk for lunch. Jake had slipped me his acceptance letter to the State summer engineering program five minutes earlier, scrawled look what I got!! in the margin, and I couldn’t keep the stupid grin off my face. I folded it into the pointy-nosed, wide-winged plane Jake taught me to fold when we were 8 at the town pool, and I threw it across the room to him.
It didn’t hit anyone. It just clipped the edge of the overhead projector Ms. Hale was using to show us parts of a flower, shifted the whole slide crooked, and then the projector’s fan blew it right into the trash can by her desk anyway. Everyone went dead quiet. I froze, my face so hot I could feel the heat down my neck. I thought okay, I apologize, get a warning, we move on. It’s the last week before break, literally everyone was checked out.
But Ms. Hale had just dealt with the whole slime incident a month earlier, where someone dumped a bucket of neon green slime all over her desk and ruined a stack of progress reports she’d spent all weekend grading. She’d been cracking down, making examples out of every tiny disruption that month. She didn’t even yell, just looked right at me over her thick black glasses and said “Detention after school today. Pack your bag.”
I couldn’t believe it. I apologized right there, said it was just a stupid celebration, I wasn’t trying to disrupt anything. She just shook her head and turned the projector back. The whole rest of class I couldn’t focus on the stupid flower diagram. I had JV soccer practice right after school, we had a scrimmage the next week, and coach had already chewed me out for being late once that semester. I texted my mom under the desk, she texted back are you kidding me? I have to reschedule my book club just because you threw a piece of paper?
Detention was just me and Ms. Hale in that empty room after everyone left. The custodian had mopped the hallway outside, so you could smell pine cleaner seeping under the door. The clock above the door ticked so loud it was almost all I could hear. I sat in the back row, staring at my scuffed white sneakers, waiting for the hour to be up. I knocked over a stack of graded quizzes trying to cross my legs, they went flying everywhere, I had to pick them up one by one, my hands all sweaty, and I could feel Ms. Hale watching me the whole time. That was the worst part, honestly – the awkwardness of being already embarrassed, and having someone just watch you fumble through cleaning up your mess.
Halfway through the hour, she pushed her grading aside and asked me what the paper plane was made of. I fished it out of her trash can, a little crumpled but still mostly in one piece, and handed her Jake’s acceptance letter. She unfolded it, read it, leaned back in her chair and twisted that chunky pearl necklace she always wore – the one that kept getting caught on the projector knob every single class. “I used to fold planes out of my unused exam blue books when I was in college,” she said. “Threw them right out the lecture hall window into the quad. Got yelled at once, never got detention though.”
I didn’t know what to say to that. I just nodded. She still didn’t let me leave early, though. I stayed the whole hour, missed the first 45 minutes of practice, coach made me run ten extra laps after everyone else left, my legs were sore for three days. Jake waited for me outside the school, said he felt bad, bought me a blue raspberry slushie from the gas station down the street. It stained my tongue blue for the rest of the day.
Back at Walmart last week, the mom was red in the face, dragging the kid out to the car yelling about how he’s grounded for a week, and the old lady with the root beer just laughed and said “I used to do that when I was his age,” but the mom wouldn’t let it go. And it made me think of my coworker last month, who threw a foam stress ball across the open office to his friend, it hit the regional manager’s iced latte, spilled all over her work laptop, and he got a formal written warning put in his permanent file. Like throwing a stress ball, or a paper plane, is some big moral failure that needs to be documented forever.
I don’t know. I don’t hate Ms. Hale. She wasn’t a bad teacher, I got a 4 on that AP test, she wrote me a solid college recommendation a year later. I ran into her at that same Walmart a few years after I graduated, she remembered my name, asked how Jake was, I told her Jake designs civilian aircraft now, can you believe that, and she laughed so hard she snort-laughed. But I still can’t help thinking: what was the point of the detention? Did it make me more respectful of rules or authority? No, it just made me scared to get caught doing anything even a little fun in class for the rest of high school. It just taught me that when people in charge are tired and still stinging from someone else’s mistake, they’ll pick the first small, harmless thing to make an example of, no matter how silly it is.
I still fold paper planes when I’m on a boring work call, actually. I fold them out of old printed meeting agendas, throw them into the trash can across my tiny home office. I’ve missed twice in the last year, had to crawl under the desk to get them. No one’s given me detention yet. It’s just a piece of paper, folded into something that flies for ten seconds. It’s not that deep. But stupid little punishments for stupid little moments of joy stick with you, don’t they?
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » I Got Detention For Throwing A Paper Plane, And I Still Think About It Sometimes