What I Learned About Good Nurseries After Crying In My Car For 20 Minutes
I dropped Máté off at his first nursery back in March, when he was 18 months old. I’d packed his bag the night before, ironed his extra change of clothes, wrote his name on everything with that waterproof marker everyone says you need. I stood by the gate while he clung to my jeans, and when the caregiver pulled him off – not gently, sort of pried him loose – I noticed her nails were done really nice, all glossy pale pink. I don’t know why I remembered that, but I did. Then I walked to my car, sat in the driver’s seat, and cried for 20 minutes straight. That’s how I started this whole nursery journey, and that’s how I ended up with an opinion about what makes one good, that I never would’ve had before I went through it.
That first nursery was the one everyone told us to chase. It’s brand new, built in 2021, has a heated indoor playroom for rainy days, a menu posted online every week with organic everything, the walls painted these soft neutral tones that look perfect on parent Instagram reels. We paid an extra deposit just to get a spot there, I was so proud when we got the acceptance email. I thought that’s what good is, right? New, clean, planned, all the boxes ticked off the list parenting blogs tell you to check. But after two weeks, something was just off. Máté would wake up screaming three times a night, he’d lock his legs around my ankles when we turned onto the street the nursery is on. One time I forgot his stuffed rabbit, the one he can’t sleep without, and I drove back 15 minutes after drop off to drop it off. I walked in the side door, no one was at the front desk, and I saw him standing by his cubby, just holding the edge, not playing, not even crying, just staring at the linoleum. No one was anywhere near him. The other kids were all gluing cotton balls onto paper sheep at the table, and the two caregivers were helping them, and I guess they just forgot he was there. I grabbed him and left that day, called them that night to say we weren’t coming back. I felt guilty for weeks, like I was being an overreacting first-time mom. Maybe I was. But it didn’t feel right, and that mattered more than being the chill, reasonable mom everyone wants you to be.
The new nursery we found is this old converted house on a tree-lined side street, the kind with a cracked front step and a garden that’s half dandelions, half wild strawberries the kids pick every spring. It doesn’t have a proper website, just a Facebook page with three blurry photos from 2018. I was skeptical at first, I’ll admit. The first time we went to visit, the lead caregiver, Zsófi, was kneeling in the playroom squishing playdough with three kids, and she had a big smudge of blue on her left cheek, and she didn’t wipe it off before she came to greet us. She just wiped her hands on her own jeans that have a hole at the knee, and said “Hi, I’m Zsófi. That little guy’s hiding behind your leg, you want a lemonade while he goes check out the truck bin? No rush, we’ve got time.” That was the first thing that made me relax, I think. No one was rushing us to fill out 10 forms, no one was giving me a scripted tour pointing out all the fancy features, no one was quizzing me on what Máté already knows how to do.
There’s a big brown stain on the living room carpet from when a kid spilled an entire bottle of grape juice there last Christmas, Zsófi told me that when I commented on it, and she said “we tried three times to get it out, everyone knows it’s the juice spot now, no one minds.” The cubbies have hand-drawn name tags, not the printed laminated ones the first nursery had. Half the toys have a piece missing – the farm animal puzzle is missing the chicken, the favorite tricycle has a wobbly back wheel. None of that matters, though.
Last month Máté had a big poop accident right after snack time. He’s weird about being changed by other people, gets so embarrassed he just clams up and won’t move. When I got there to pick him up, I was expecting to hear that he’d been crying for an hour, that it was a whole big mess I’d caused by not reminding him to ask to go. Instead, I found them sitting on the bathroom floor, Zsófi and Máté, dumping a bin of plastic buttons out onto the rug and sorting them by size. Máté was wearing a pair of the nursery’s spare sweatpants that have a hole at the knee, and Zsófi just looked up and said “He didn’t want to change for 15 minutes, so we waited it out. No big deal. His clothes are in a bag by the door, don’t worry about it.” I stood there for a second, shocked, because at the first nursery they would’ve called me 10 minutes in to come handle it, like it was an emergency.
I used to think a good nursery was all the big stuff. Enough fancy certificates framed on the wall, a low kid-to-caregiver ratio, a big fenced garden, organic snacks, all the things the parenting sites tell you to prioritize. Don’t get me wrong, those things are nice, but they’re not the thing that makes it good. The thing that makes it good is that Zsófi remembers Máté hates crusts on his bread, so she cuts them off every day even though it’s an extra step. It’s that when he gets overstimulated by all the kids yelling and singing, he can sit on the porch step with her and pick dandelions instead of joining in. It’s that last week they were supposed to do a big Easter craft, cutting out paper bunnies and all that, but all the kids got obsessed with a snail that was crawling up the garden fence, so they just sat there for an hour watching the snail, and no one made them go back inside to do the planned activity.
I brought Zsófi and the other girls fancy shortbread cookies for caregiver appreciation week, the ones I spent three hours baking. I was so proud of them, wrapped them in nice cellophane with a ribbon. When I gave them to her, she opened the bag, took one bite, and said “Oh these are incredible, thank you. I’m gonna save the rest for after you leave, though – one of the kids brought donuts this morning and we’re already bouncing off the walls.” I was a little embarrassed for half a second, like did I mess up? Then I realized, that’s just her being honest. She’s not putting on a nice show for the parents, she’s just running a nursery full of messy little kids, and that’s okay.
I still worry sometimes, honestly. Some of the other moms at the playground talk about how their kids know all their letters already, how their nursery does weekly French classes, and I think, am I shortchanging him? He spends most of his day digging for worms and chasing the stray cat that lives in the nursery’s garden, he still can’t consistently name blue. Then he runs to me when I come pick him up, yelling about how the snail came back today, or the wild strawberry he found that was actually sweet, and he turns around and gives Zsófi a big hug before we leave, no clinging, no crying. I don’t have a perfect answer to what makes a good nursery. I just know this one feels like home, for him, even when it’s messy, even when it’s not what I thought I wanted. And that’s enough, I think. Most days, anyway.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned About Good Nurseries After Crying In My Car For 20 Minutes